5 ms·
The company I was working for at the time spent a not insignificant amount of money and effort migrating away from Oracle JDK when they first pulled this shit.
by marginalia_nu 5y ago
The company I was working for at the time spent a not insignificant amount of money and effort migrating away from Oracle JDK when they first pulled this shit.
It was a B2B outfit, had maybe 30 customers running a dozen different products that the customers hosted themselves. The product was critical to business and the customers were large and part of critical infrastructure. Even a short outage would have made it into the news. What I'm saying is it wasn't a place where you could just hope for the best while migrating JVMs, everything needed to be tested and re-tested from every imaginable angle.
This was extremely expensive, but in the long run, it was still a lot cheaper than ponying up for oracle licensing costs.
I don't work there anymore, but I doubt they are repeating the process to migrate back, especially given how well OpenJDK works.
- Cullinet 5y agocan I ask you for some illumination of the licensing costs components involved with remaining licensed by Oracle? this page https://dzone.com/articles/how-much-does-java-cost https://dzone.com/articles/how-much-does-java-cost gives $28,500 pa for a 200 core runtime that sounds negligible compared to the engineering investment that was preferred instead. the logic of a commercially supported license is obviously the engineering depth of the original author's knowledge and in particular being able to refer to the authoritative / canonical answers were savings the only objective? if so, what did the savings get? anything better?
- murderfs 5y ago> that sounds negligible compared to the engineering investment that was preferred instead. Can you trust Oracle not to raise the pricing in the future, given that they've raised it once already?
- Sparkle-san 5y ago>Can you trust Oracle No
- rbanffy 5y agoYou can trust they’ll do whatever makes them the most money in the short term.
- awill 5y agonegligible? It all depends on how much hardware you have. If you're a startup, you don't want scaling to cost you anymore than the hardware. I remember reading years ago about the FB vs MySpace fight. MySpace was (I think) .NET on Windows with SQL Server. Every extra machine cost a fortune in licensing. Whereas every FB machine was PHP/MySQL. It matters.
- nobleach 5y agoOriginal MySpace was ColdFusion. They later migrated to .NET. I can't imagine wanting to pay for either one of those back in that era.
- rbanffy 5y ago> It all depends on how much hardware you have. If you're a startup, you don't want scaling to cost you anymore than the hardware. A lot of companies operate with a dozen or so servers, and most startups never need to scale beyond that.
- marginalia_nu 5y agoI don't have exact figures, but I'd guess our customers really weren't too enthusiastic about getting bullied into vendor lock-in with Oracle, which through this very act had already demonstrated their unreliability and willingness to renege on existing terms. That may have been the bigger reason for migrating. Staying on Oracle was definitely an option, but nobody wanted that.
- chrisseaton 5y ago> The company I was working for at the time spent a not insignificant amount of money and effort migrating away from Oracle JDK when they first pulled this shit. What did you migrate to? Another build of the OpenJDK? But it's the same code, isn't it? What's the difference that mattered to you?
- flatiron 5y agoI did a migration too. 20+ year legacy code base. It was a 2-3 day effort. To adopt open jdk
- tapland 5y agoWe did the same thing. Just testing that everything actually worked as expected was a pretty big task.
- chrisseaton 5y ago> It was a 2-3 day effort Right but why? I'm not an expert in the difference but isn't it literally exactly the same code and functionality? What were you doing in that migration time?
- jonhohle 5y agoThere are packaging differences between various JVMs. Some of these are relatively minor (explicit or optional dependencies on X11 or other libraries), others are a bigger issue (how the Java keystore integrates with paths configured for system certificates).
- kaba0 5y ago> but I doubt they are repeating the process to migrate back, especially given how well OpenJDK works Such a surprise, knowing that the two is one and the same..
- y4mi 5y agoI'm not sure about the current version, but Oracle jdk 8 had a few classes that weren't available in openjdk, we had to switch some cryptography calls to bouncycastle in our migration iirc
- Zardoz84 5y agoSince Java 9, Oracle JDK is OpenJDK with some extra oracle stuff inside.
- _rgek 5y ago"Extra Oracle stuff" sounds like a great reason to avoid it.
- netizen-936824 5y agoI tend to avoid things with "Oracle stuff" period
- cryptonector 5y agoReminds me of BMC's FYO point blog post.
- invalidname 5y agoYep. Furthermore, Oracle JDK still isn't as free as OpenJDK: https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/oracle-java-release-17-now-free-again-richard-spithoven/ https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/oracle-java-release-17-now-fr... The license has a lot of nuances in it. OpenJDK is great and I honestly don't see a real reason to use the Oracle branded version for anything anymore.
- krzyk 5y ago> The company I was working for at the time spent a not insignificant amount of money and effort migrating away from Oracle JDK when they first pulled this shit. Why such big cost? Changing JDK is just replacing some binary installed on server or at client.
- chaostheory 5y agoThe cost comes from testing and retesting just in case you missed that part of the comment
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]