3 ms·
It's because Bash is everywhere and is thus the next least common denominator after sh.
by heavyset_go 5y ago
It's because Bash is everywhere and is thus the next least common denominator after sh.
- chasil 5y agoBash is not everywhere. There are two very distinct places where Bash is not, that I have found. Bash is not in busybox. It pretends to be, but what is really there is the Almquist shell, with a bit of syntactic sugar to silence the common complaints. Bash is also not in Debian's shell (/bin/sh). In that place, there is no tolerance of bashisms. It is important to know the POSIX shell for these reasons.
- jude- 5y agoBash is readily available everywhere, though. Is there a widely used OS that cannot run bash, but can run BusyBox ash or dash?
- chasil 5y agoBash is not used in Android. The Android userland explicitly avoids any GPL software. The Android system shell is the MirBSD Kornshell (mksh). This is (obviously) a massive platform.
- jude- 5y agoBut, you can nevertheless install bash on Android. That was my ask -- show me a widely-used OS that cannot run bash but can run other similar shells.
- gkfasdfasdf 5y ago> Bash is also not in Debian's shell (/bin/sh). In that place, there is no tolerance of bashisms. When writing a bash script, shouldn't you be setting the shebang to /bin/bash which is available on Debian?
- chasil 5y agoBash is the default interactive shell, but the Almquist shell is the default for /bin/sh, and must be used for all system startup activity. It is otherwise advisable when speed or portability are required.