3 ms·
I don't see any logical issue with that. Logic makes no moral judgements, and also logic doesn't care about the future, if it doesn't include the invididual.
by coldtea 5y ago
I don't see any logical issue with that.
Logic makes no moral judgements, and also logic doesn't care about the future, if it doesn't include the invididual.
(Here logic is also a stand-in for "maximizing benefit").
If one/a group hunts whales to extintion and makes a huge profit (say, enough to retire), they would be logically sound (if morally bankrupt) to not care less if there are no whales left.
- User23 5y agoIt's a shame that the explicit study of logic, ethics, and aesthetics isn't really part of the secondary school curriculum anymore. Everyone should be able to tell whether a problem falls in the domain of logic or ethics.
- coldtea 5y agoYeah. And even "maximizing benefit/utility" is not logic (I went with that, since at best, it's what many mean by "makes logical sense"). Logic could as well be used perfectly well for minimizing benefit, it's just a tool for forming and evaluating syllogisms based on a set of axioms.