4 ms·
I never thought I would want a "walled garden" on my desktop, but these shit software stacks that companies are integrating into their products are forcing me t
by JKCalhoun 5y ago
I never thought I would want a "walled garden" on my desktop, but these shit software stacks that companies are integrating into their products are forcing me to want to fight back to lock down my machine.
I would love a simple utility that could not only neatly encapsulate and display the data being sent from my machine out on the network but also allow me to merely check a box to block that traffic.
A smart initial config of course would "allow list" the usual web traffic from my browser(s), mail traffic from my mail client, etc.
I don't want to mess with proxies, don't want to have to block ports using a command-line tool or by wading through my router config.
Maybe I am asking for too much.
- jacquesm 5y agohttps://www.qubes-os.org/ https://www.qubes-os.org/
- xoa 5y ago>I would love a simple utility that could not only neatly encapsulate and display the data being sent from my machine out on the network but also allow me to merely check a box to block that traffic. Does Little Snitch not meet your needs there? I believe even with the challenges caused by Apple's unfortunate elimination of kernel extensions it's still powerful and effective. The GUI is solid and I've had solid success over many years with it for this sort of thing.
- JKCalhoun 5y agoThank (both of) you. I don't know why, I had always assumed Little Snitch was command-line. I'll play with it. In my line of work I had used Charles (but no, that is not something I would consider was to use).
- azalemeth 5y agoIt's worth mentioning that an excellent FOSS alternative is LuLu -- https://objective-see.com/products/lulu.html https://objective-see.com/products/lulu.html or https://github.com/objective-see/LuLu https://github.com/objective-see/LuLu [last commit a week ago!]
- d3nj4l 5y agoOpenSnitch is a good equivalent for Linux users, btw. Don’t assume you’re not being mined for data because you’re on Linux!
- Multicomp 5y ago> Don’t assume you’re not being mined for data because you’re on Linux! You make a good point that I'd not really considered. When I'm on Linux, I have a tendency to think I'm less likely to be tracked for stuff since mostly I just use the open source drivers. I have a wacom tablet connected to my machine running Fedora and didn't install wacom drivers, it 'just worked' using whoever's amazing open source graphics tablet driver contributions. But if I didn't know that or I had to install Wacom's sneaky drivers anyways? If I had to use Little / Open Snitch either way to use a particular piece of hardware, the thought occurs to me (this may be OT) that it I may just wander back to what I'm used to from the past: Windows. Gravity pulls me to Windows because I'm familiar with its UX, I have lots of software I run on it, and it's less fragmented than desktop Linux. But I am using Fedora here because it has a superior privacy stance, is not going to force me to update, is not going to violate my express preferences by willfully ignoring or un-setting my settings, and because there's less third party drivers required (provided I do the special Linux-friendly hardware dance). I guess I'm trying to say one's personal computing choices are a constantly changing balance and your statement caused me to re-evaluate my balance there, so thank you for the thought provoking comment.
- rocqua 5y agoIt doesn't take much of a walled garden to prevent mouse drivers from surreptitious network access. It only takes a capability based permission system.
- JKCalhoun 5y agoYou're right. I shouldn't have said "walled garden" — a permissions system is a perfectly adequate solution.
- ivanmontillam 5y agoWe could go a bit further with MAC (Mandatory Access Control). Something like SELinux. Properly understood, SELinux can provide rock-solid security. Of course, it's not a replacement of other security software, but it can prevent most of sneaky leakages such as the we had just seen in this post. MacOS doesn't ship with SELinux, but I believe it has something similar.
- jodrellblank 5y agoCan it? (Genuine question). I understand SELinux can block processes from opening network sockets for example, but aren't drivers modules loaded into the kernel and not their own process, so you'd have to block the kernel from doing things or not? Or can SELinux go more granular than that?
- wtallis 5y agoWhen a proprietary/vendor-supplied out of tree driver includes analytics/telemetry/spyware, it's most likely going to be in a userspace component. Such drivers will almost always include at least a userspace configuration tool and often a userspace daemon.
- jeroenhd 5y agoI don't know if it's SELinux or the containerisation API, but such a mechanism is also in play with sandboxed Linux applications (Flatpak, Snap). On Ubuntu there are many apps you can disable a lot of permissions for because of the snappification of the OS.
- Willamin 5y agoIf you're on MacOS, there's a third party program that's relatively simple to use that does exactly what you've described: Little Snitch
- Mollythedog 5y agoIf I am not mistaken, there was, back in the day, a small program called Proxomitron that did this.
- userbinator 5y agoI still use it. Unfortunately, apps that don't respect the system proxy settings are common. (And now we have browsers that don't respect system DNS, but that's another rant...)
- throwaway09223 5y agoI think you want the opposite of a walled garden (app store). I think you want a completely open garden, such as we have with a typical Linux distro. A walled garden just changes the entities which can control your devices. It doesn't fix the problem of agency, trust, choice and consent. My tablets can't have spyware, because the drivers are stock open source. The folks making the hardware aren't in control of the driver software that runs the device. I can trust the community that any attempts to do this nonsense in an open source driver will make the news. The track record against spyware in the linux kernel is spotless. This kind of nonsense is only a problem with closed source software.
- ant6n 5y agoDoes anybody remember ZoneAlarm? At some point later these firewalls became a standard of windows, and then when later they went away again.
- marderfarker2 5y agoBack in the Windows XP days my dad installed an Enterprise copy on the family PC. You could see per application network access in real-time, and would ask for permission whenever an application tries to make an outgoing connection, unlike Windows Firewall which seems to be extremely leaky.