23 ms·
Truths about video game stories
- Causality1 5y agoIf I was, I'd be writing books nobody buys because nobody buys books anymore Sales of printed books have been increasing every year since 2012. Last year alone saw a jump of over eight percent.
- giantrobot 5y agoOverall sales might be up but are those sales making the head fatter, the tail fatter, or the tail longer? For any individual writer without sales in the head, increased sales only matter if the tail gets fatter. They don't individually make any more money if it gets longer (more books by more writers).
- Causality1 5y agoAs long as the writers are making enough money to produce their best output, the ideal situation is as long a tail as possible. The greater the variety of author, the greater the variety of books.
- giantrobot 5y agoBut that's the core issue. A long tail is good for Amazon and theoretically good for readers. It's not really helpful for writers. Any in the long tail are unlikely to ever pay back an advance and actually make money off sales let alone be making enough to produce their best output. So total unit sales being up doesn't necessarily counter that statement "no one reads books anymore". Unit sales being "up" has a lot of qualifiers.
- YeGoblynQueenne 5y agoIt looks to me like the author was making a joke.
- Kye 5y agoAgreed. I read it like the classic "nobody goes there anymore, it's too crowded."
- ddingus 5y agoSame. Text can sometimes be hard. That text is fairly lucid. The tone and humor stand out fairly well. Like the author said: competent. ...which means a percentage of us will take it differently than intended.
- merciBien 5y agoI agree, I enjoyed the self-deprecating, comic tone of the article. I still appreciate the comment pointing out that large numbers of people apparently still read books. I was surprised to learn that!
- merciBien 5y agoThanks for posting this comment, I searched for sources on this topic after reading it and was very surprised to see corroboration. Here’s a quote and few links for those interested: In the US in 2019, a high % of adults reported reading a book recently https://www.markinblog.com/book-sales-statistics/ https://www.markinblog.com/book-sales-statistics/ …who is reading in the US? In October of 2019, over 80% of adults, age 18 to 29, have read at least one book in the previous year. Older adults, possibly because they are not spending as much time studying and more time working, read slightly less. Lockdowns may have increased reading in the US https://publishingperspectives.com/2021/02/aap-statshot-sees-us-trade-book-sales-up-9-7-percent-for-2020-covid19/ https://publishingperspectives.com/2021/02/aap-statshot-sees... Political polarization in the UK appears to drive book sales https://www.theguardian.com/books/datablog/2017/mar/18/the-fall-and-rise-of-physical-book-sales-worldwide-in-data https://www.theguardian.com/books/datablog/2017/mar/18/the-f... (edit for formatting)
- yeetaccount 5y agoBooks sales are sales of anything with an ISBN. This includes adult colouring books, which I’ve heard is responsible for possibly all the sales increases in the past few years.
- gregjw 5y agoCome on...
- kibwen 5y agoAfter a flurry of activity in the last decade, I haven't heard anyone mention adult coloring books even once in the past two or three years. As long as we're all baselessly speculating, I will baselessly speculate that they were just an ordinary fad. My own anecdote is that disillusionment with internet content and electronic consumption in general has caused me to buy and read more books recently than at any point in my life.
- watwut 5y agoThey are prominently in bookstores. They did not disappeared and people did not stopped buying them. Just the hand wringing over them stopped.
- haunter 5y agoThis is quite an incredibly toxic and negative piece. There are countless games with great stories The whole article feels like OP is upset about something behind the scenes and just had to rumble about it Maybe it's even sarcasm, you never know nowdays
- jsiepkes 5y ago> This is quite an incredibly toxic and negative piece The author might have a negative take on things and you might not like the article but to brand the article as "incredibly toxic" is a bit of a hyperbole.
- haunter 5y agoWell to me it's toxic when it opens with the achievements (being successful in the business for 27 years) then shits on the whole industry and their own customers (treat your own players as idiots) in a holier than thou attitude. Just very bitter.
- chongli 5y agoIt’s not bitter at all. It’s self-deprecating and funny. The author, Jeff, has been making games that I’ve been playing for their story and gameplay alone (the graphics are truly terrible) since the 90’s. Jeff is irreverent and highly opinionated but absolutely not “holier than thou.” He knows his games are ugly and played only by a tiny niche. The only thing he can remotely claim to be better at than most people is running a video game studio that manages to support his small household.
- nottorp 5y agoSo... everyone that disagrees with you is "toxic"?
- haunter 5y agoNo but OP is the one setting up the field in an incredibly negative way Also the title ("truths") implies there is no room for negotiation
- imbnwa 5y agoI wanna know what quality of zombie movie this guy is watching that The Last of Us is somehow beneath them. The only zombie movie worth a damn this century is 28 Days Later. The Last of Us Part II was an even more amazing story, I literally was saying NO at the penultimate scene on the beach. The franchise is so well done HBO is adapting it.
- sien 5y agoShaun of the Dead was great. Fido was pretty good too.
- imbnwa 5y agoComedies just aren't the same thing though, I mean where do you really start comparing Shaun of the Dead, which is hilarious don't get me wrong, with The Last Of Us?
- EdwardDiego 5y agoI'm one of those weirdos who thinks 28 Weeks Later was artistic genius, and that's a hill I'm willing to die on - all those people dying to save an asymptomatic carrier because he's a kid? Entirely plausible and tragic.
- bananamerica 5y agoWeeks or days?
- sk0g 5y agoWeeks, which is the sequel to the original film, Days. Weeks revolves around the asymptomatic carriers, while Days is mostly about the outbreak developing.
- BeFlatXIII 5y agoThe section about “witty” dialogue, meme humor, and twist endings hit home for me. It’s also the same reasons I’m not a fan of most Marvel movies.
- Hamuko 5y agoI feel that way about most American blockbuster movies. They all seem to plagued by it.
- aspaceman 5y ago> Good story isn't what gamers are after. Which is good, because they ain't gettin' it. I emphatically disagree. Good story is what I'm after. Good story is what I've gotten. (Undertale, the Nier games, even Ocarina of Time has a very unique story-telling experience). A game can tell a different type of story than a book or a movie - these stories are interactive, and involve an element of meta-narrative story-telling. What was that fight like? What was that choice like? Did the choice _feel_ meaningful? The story is told through these mechanisms rather than simply words on a page. I very much agree that many players come to games for a carnal feeling. A release that comes from the ticking of boxes or completion of objectives, or the satisfaction from a skilled execution. But these elements as well can contribute to a narrative experience (ex Undertale). Really disagree with this article. Reminds me of those historical articles about movies being a worse version of the theatre and opera (which they were).
- senectus1 5y agoyeah I yearn for good story line, but I find myself putting up with weak ones.
- t-3 5y agoIt's gotten to the point that I just don't buy or play new games from American or Japanese studios. It's too disappointing to pick up new releases of series that I've played for more than half my life (such as the Tales series) and find everything that made them great ripped out and replaced with consumerist trash that panders to the lowest common denominator. China seems to be the only country that still has some original and compelling new games and stories being produced.
- aynsof 5y agoI remember all the press praising the original Half Life for its story. I was really surprised - it was the same story as all first person shooters going back to Doom: Bad guys spawn across an inter-dimensional portal and start wreaking havoc. Protagonist has to kill them all, crossing the portal in the process to go destroy the alien leader. There were some cool extra details - the G Man, the marines entering as a third force, the diversions to do things like launch a missile into space - but all of those things were additional to that same, basic story. This author has it spot on: our standards for story telling in video games are really low.
- namdnay 5y agoI think the praise for Half Life was the story telling. The story itself is pretty generic scifi action, but the fact that you discovered it through the player rather than a paragraph of exposition or a cutscene was pretty novel for that genre
- eterm 5y agoAbsolutely this. In half-life you were exposed to a world and left to figure out what was going on from that. You were rarely directly told to do anything. For the first hour or two you were implored to, "Get to the surface" because it was your and your fellow scientists hope of being rescued. When you run into the marines you aren't told they're bad, they just start trying to kill you and you figure out that you're not getting a rescue. World-building wise it was leaps ahead of anything that came before it and the in-game (rather than FMV) dialogue was fantastic and immersive. It didn't have "level screens", the level transitions were natural rather than forced with loading screen hints and title cards. While that's all completely standard now, the other competitor titles at the time were games like Quake 2 and half-life's predecessors were games like Duke Nukem 3D and Quake, which while both ground-breaking in their own way weren't a touch on the visceral world of half-life. The only other FPS games that came close to lore was rainbow six, but that was the "set pieces" style of choosing levels and going through rehearsed action rather than what felt like an emergent world in half-life. While replaying half-life now it feels far more linear and scripted, that's because we have nearly 15 years of gameplay improvements built on top of where it lay the foundations. For players at the time, going from games like quake to half-life it really did feel like it was genre defining.
- Theodores 5y agoParents play video games as well as their kids. This never used to happen if we roll back to when Space Invaders was the latest and greatest. Nowadays you can have the 50 year old dad spending his quality time in bed next to his wife blasting enemies with the teenage/student kids doing the same. With another generation it will be the folks in retirement homes too. With music you get stuck on the stuff you discovered and made your own. Into punk? Probably born way back in the 60s. Techno? 70s. Will it be the same with games? The guy in the retirement home still playing World of Warcraft? Or that copy of Diablo that came out in 2003? Story in video games therefore has to be good enough to not just last a week or a summer, but a lifetime.
- davidelettieri 5y ago50 years old dad was in his twenties when Doom was out. Older people that plays videogames are mostly the ones that played videogames at a young age.
- watwut 5y agoIt did used to happen. Really. And it does not happen super often now.
- DeathArrow 5y ago>With music you get stuck on the stuff you discovered and made your own. Into punk? Probably born way back in the 60s. Techno? 70s. I don't listen to particular genres of music or music from a particular period of time. As for gaming, I would rather watch a film, read a book, go outside, watch a play, meet people, do something else, because I don't have much free time and gaming is not a priority. I would probably play some games if I would have more free time. As a matter of fact I worked for 7 years as a game programmer and during that period I never played other games than our own stuff and some stuff from the competition where we wanted to understand some mechanics.
- billyjobob 5y agoSpace Invaders and arcades in general seemed more popular with adults than with children in 1980. I’m not sure when or why video games came to be regarded as a juvenile pastime. Possibly coincided with the kid-friendly characters and home consoles promoted by Sega and Nintendo around 1990. Or maybe games have always appealed to nerds of all ages, but what happened in the 90s is they began to appeal to normie children too, and as you point out those normie kids continued to play them when they became normie adults.
- mattowen_uk 5y agoIf you want a good, different, video game story, I can 100% recommend "Everybody's Gone To The Rapture". It's not a bang-bang-shooty game though.
- HatchedLake721 5y agoNothing beats The Last of Us story for me (it’s why it became PlayStation game of the decade). The Last of Us Part II spoils you even further, there isn’t anything else close to the level of detail and story telling that Naugthy Dog has done here. “It’s a rollercoaster thrill ride which lasts like 20 hours and leaves you scarred for the rest of your days. 10/10” FYI HBO and creators of Chernobyl have picked up The Last of Us and are filming 10 episode series right now with a bigger budget than Game of Thrones.
- dgb23 5y agoWhat makes them stand out to me is the emersion. The game and rythm let you feel the story on a different level.
- thendrill 5y agoYes last of us is amazing to watch. But the game never starts. Your basically navigating cut scenes on rails. Same can be said for cod campaigns and Titanfall. Hell titanfall 1 was multi-player only and it still has a story spawning Apex Legends
- Matthias247 5y agoI remembered enjoying the first TLOU, but when I played the second one last year it didn't click with me. It felt like a rather long and brutal rage trip. There was story to it and very nicely produced settings, but it all felt like minor elements on this rage trip than any big changes and surprises. Actually wondering if anyone else felt that way, or whether my taste of games just changed over the last years.
- DeathArrow 5y agoAnother truth is that you don't need a good story to achieve success. There are many successful games with no good story or no story at all.
- qsort 5y agoThis. Space Invaders, Pacman, Mario, Tetris are games that single-handedly defined an entire generation of games. No story to be found. I think the OP is perfectly on point. A good story demands an authorial voice, and most games can't have (or won't bother with) that.
- mkotowski 5y agoOr, as Nintendo often does, you create a good gameplay first, and only then you start creating a plot around it. Of course, it can fail too, but in my humble opinion it is one of the best approach to game design.
- ycombinete 5y agoI like the John Carmack quote: "Story in a game is like a story in a porn movie. It's expected to be there, but it's not that important."
- freeflight 5y agoImho that quote says more about what parts of games John Carmack has mostly worked on during his life than it actually says anything about storytelling in games. The guy is so deep in code engineering that sometimes other, more nuanced, details can be seemingly totally lost on him.
- nmfisher 5y agoYeah, I have a lot of respect for Carmack as a developer/engineer but I doubt you’d want him in charge of actually designing your game. I’m sure he’d admit as much.
- hnick 5y agoThe problem is that "games" is one word, but we really have two core types of game. Some games focus on mechanical skills or rules akin to a sport or boardgame, others are an interactive narrative experience. This interactive experience can further be broken down into games that tell you what is happening (cinema), and games that let you make your own story (tabletop RPG). So while there is a lot of crossover and blurred lines, of these types of game, only one type really needs a well written or scripted story to achieve its goals. We have many successful games with no story due to this, but other games wouldn't have succeeded without one.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- pdpi 5y agoWe've had theatre and literature as narrative art for centuries. Film has been around for a tiny bit over 100 years, and it took them decades to find their own voices distinct from their predecessors. By comparison, video games are in their infancy. We've been at it for only a few short decades, and having the audience directly involved with the narrative is a radical shift from what we had before. We're looking at a new art form finding its identity. Right now the industry is drowing in AAA games that stick to the cinematic style of storytelling (and "cinematic" is still used as praise for storytelling in games), but there's also lots of (mostly indie) games out there that are trying to push the boundaries. You have games like Braid, Brothers and Hades exploring how to strongly bind narrative and game mechanics together. You have games like the first Bioshock, which abuse your understanding of genre conventions. You have games like Return of the Obra Dinn doing amazing work with non-linear storytelling. It's a good time to be into video game storytelling.
- imbnwa 5y agoJourney and Abzü are great examples of what video games can do with just exploration of the environment telling you a story with zero dialogue/exposition that by definition can't be done in other mediums
- pdpi 5y agoI would argue that what you're describing is close to an interactive version of the sort of storytelling you can achieve in a painting (also - you piqued my interest, installing Journey!).
- imbnwa 5y agoIt's a really great game and I think by the end you'll be awestruck by what it successfully evokes in you, but a painting, or a silent movie for that matter, are by definition not interactive environments unless using your imagination/interpretation is equivalent to a video game. In the games I describe you can miss things by not exploring. I won't miss anything in watching a silent movie or the opening sequence to Up because there's a definite set of frames and they run one way. A painting is even more limited.
- ajsnigrutin 5y agoFor me, this depends on the game genre... FPS? All the story I need is the 'end condition' (basically what do I have to do to win this level), and I can play. "reach point X", "detonate bomb", "kill everyone".... sure. Strategy games? Same... kill everyone, destroy base, done. But for example, point and click adventures with a shitty story? Totally unplayable for me.
- jimbob45 5y agohttps://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLzqQqTZGYi1b6SBlFWhgr38sPrJygI9La https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLzqQqTZGYi1b6SBlFWhgr38sP... I’d like to submit the Marathon series of video games on how to integrate story into a game without needing to change virtually any gameplay or include cutscenes. That the story is incredibly intelligent is just bonus. For those unfamiliar, it includes AI mental illness, AIs getting molested, subjugated alien races, infinite alternative timelines, and Lovecraftian beings. It might have been recognized as a better Doom if it wasn’t doomed to be a Mac-exclusive game series in the early 90s.
- nosianu 5y agoI have not played any computer game in over more than a decade, but I played a lot earlier. Anyway, what I did for a while - not recently due to a lack of good targets - is watch Youtube "playthrough no commentary" videos (and with story-less gameplay parts heavily cut out). That's usually 4-6 hours of game movie. The Last of Us was good, but the very top #1 for me as far as story goes - ignoring the game play completely - was Horizon Zero Dawn. One of many such game movies for this game: https://youtu.be/W6jbYfmQAG4 https://youtu.be/W6jbYfmQAG4 That story seemed to be good but kind of stupid and the same as always, completely predictable, you already know what happened when you see the start and it's a bit stupid and too far-fetched - that kind. Until it wasn't. Turned out it wasn't just well-made, when you find out what was really going on it was THE BEST. Not only does it have two very different stories layered (three, if you count the present time story): One about what happened to earth and its people and one layered inside of two people, the MC and a woman in the past, with seemingly no connection, until we find out the opposite is the case. Both story-parts actually had me crying. When I found out after about four hours what had actually happened on earth, it was a great emotional shock. Same with the ending, that used the connection between the MC and that person from the past. Even the machines and their (animal) forms make sense, there is a good and IMO satisfying explanation. The stories in this game and in a handful of others are much better than most movies. If you are in the mood for something really dark, watch a game movie of "SOMA". Underwater survival. Earth is gone - a giant meteor made the surface into a fiery hell, the only survivors are some researchers in a deep ocean facility. Best small detail: They get the "uploading your brain into a computer simulation" right, see the very ending of that game which shows it one last time (TL;DW: As someone who knows neuroscience, the idea makes no sense anyway, but let's forget that and assume it makes sense. What will happen is you still stand there in front of the computer, wandering what happened, after the "upload". Because you still exist, and the copy is not you. It's a copy. You still die, there is no magical connection between you and your copy.)
- OldOneEye 5y agoI couldn't agree more with you! I played through the game and Horizon Dawn story was so rewarding! I kept playing for it even though the gameplay part had long run its course in keeping my interest. The expansion also expanded a little bit on the lore, broadening a little bit the world outside of the main arc, which was nice. This game surprised me so much, because I just picked it on a whim a short while ago. It is so much more than what the cover suggests. A very emotional and impactful story, really looking forward what they do for the next chapter of her story.
- Tehdasi 5y agoShould be noted that for Portal it didn't even have a narrative really, just a games long monologue. It was closer to Notes from the Underground than most game narratives.
- vjancik 5y agoThis author seems to have never played a game with an actual good story. You can tell from his comparison of game stories to movies. How can you compare a 2 hour narrative with a 10-100 hour narrative? This article grossly overgeneralizes stories in games and ignores the unique storytelling device that is a "game". A good book doesn't necessarily make for a good movie and a good movie doesn't necessarily make for a good game (and the other way around, as we've seen over and over again). This article seems like a self-congratulating piece by an indie developer for being an indie developer. Good for you. That doesn't mean AAA studios can't make a good game story, same as big budget movies can have a compelling story.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Aaargh20318 5y ago> (…) his comparison of game stories to movies. > How can you compare a 2 hour narrative with a 10-100 hour narrative? Not only the length makes video game stories different. Another huge difference is that in video games you actually get to be the character(s). You don’t just passively experience the story like in a movie or a book, you’re an active part of it. Even better: you can have the player make meaningful choices that affect the plot, which is something unique to games as a medium.
- TeMPOraL 5y agoExactly. And even if you don't have any real choices to make, you still get to experience the story as your story, not a tale. The author would probably think I'm a lunatic for it, but I consider the original Call of Duty: Modern Warfare trilogy to have a good story. I thoroughly enjoyed it, and unlike with other shooters, and even though it followed multiple characters simultaneously, I was able to suspend disbelief enough to experience it as if it was my story, my world. The writing of CoD: MW 1-3 would probably be considered a passable military fiction by most critic, if even that. But I bring this particular example up, instead of say Mass Effect trilogy, to highlight the unique aspect of videogames: it can make you live through a story, which neither books nor movies can. It's a distinct kind of experience.
- powersnail 5y agoReading this article makes me realize how little I know about games. I've never heard of any game the writer used as examples, except World of Warcraft (which I never played, however). The author made a lot of pithy statements, but the article feels strangely lack of substance. There's little evidence or elaboration. Just statement after statement, with a lot of repetitiveness. And the writing. Paragraphs like these: > Now let's be clear. I'm not a great fantasy writer. If I was, I'd be writing books nobody buys because nobody buys books anymore. Still, as a writer I'm simply competent. Which, by video games standards, makes me awesome. Overall, I'm good enough that people give me money, and that is sufficient. ...... are just strange, and made me grimace. He's quite plainly saying, that he's mediocre, but because everyone else is bad, he's great. And what's with the "nobody buys books anymore"? Plenty of people do. > Good story isn't what gamers are after. Which is good, because they ain't gettin' it. While not having played many games, I remember some GBA games having decent stories. They are not Charles Dickens level literature, but comparable to good short stories, definitely worthy of "good writing". --- I had expected much more---more substance, better writing---from a "successful" story writer of a game company.
- watwut 5y ago> He's quite plainly saying, that he's mediocre, but because everyone else is bad, he's great. Why is this bad thing to say? If he thinks this is true, then it is OK to say it. And earning money making games is actual achievement - most indie game makers are in financial loss and that is it. Someone who make small profit is exactly people who can say the above.
- powersnail 5y agoBecause not everyone else is bad? It's not like he's the only one writing stories for games that make a profit. I mean it's fine to like your own achievement. Nothing wrong with that. But he's certainly not successful enough to be so cocky as to detract everyone else's work (and again, he did so without much evidence or elaboration).
- watwut 5y ago
- wodenokoto 5y agoI think the author is right that games generally have poor, or poorly executed stories, and even great stories need to be squeezed into the game play box (e.g. his "ends with bang"-trope.) But I also feel like the author misunderstands how the medium can elevate a story: "Old mans Journey" was critized for having too simple puzzles, but it is not a puzzle game. It's a story, where a few simple puzzles gives you time to interact with the landscape and soak up the atmosphere, which enhances the impact of the worldless storytelling between levels. It's a simple, nothing new story, made extremely impactful through the medium. I also felt the story in Celeste was very impactful, even though it probably would make for a boring movie. But I struggled as Madelein as she conquered the mountain and her fears, and that struggle primed me to feel her struggle through the sparse dialogue.
- ajuc 5y agoYes. It's like saying stories in opera are worse than in novels because dialogues in opera aren't realistic and the story is too short :) You have to play to the strengths of the medium. The less defined the story is the more freedom players have. It's a design tradeoff that makes stories in games different, and they should be judged based on these different media constraints.
- roenxi 5y agoStories in opera are worse than in novels. Good opera is usually paired with woefully poor story. The whole point of the story is to provide basic context to the songs. Consider Turandot. The story is bad to the point of being objectionable, and whatever is left verges on gibber. And yet, without it, a song like Ho una casa nell'Honan is lessened because there has to be at least some reason to care about why this guy has a house in what sounds like a badly corrupted pronunciation of Yunnan.
- ajuc 5y agoBut that's the point. What makes a story good for one medium makes it bad for other. So it's not fair to compare them abstracting from the medium. You can still have better and worse stories withing given medium, and you can compare them between media if you insist, but you have to separate the inherent trade-offs from real quality differences.
- npinsker 5y agoI guess 'The Lord of the Rings' is a bad story then? After all it is exactly the kind of story this person is complaining about...
- baq 5y agoIt was a good story at the time; it created a genre and is indirectly responsible for many, many great works. If it was created today, it’d be a generic high fantasy work.
- nottorp 5y agoLoTR's execution of the story is high quality though. There were fantasy stories before and after it, but most aren't remembered..
- dudul 5y agoIt would be generic high fantasy work maybe because it literally defined all the codes of this genre. Blame everyone else who came after Tolkien.
- awild 5y agoThat's exactly what GP is saying though? There's a borges fake essay on exactly this topic: Pierre Menard, Author of the Quixote
- watwut 5y agoNo. One of the six things article complains about is repeating the same trick to death. Lord of the rings did not repeated the trick from other books, it created own. It does not fit other points either. It does not uses meme humor. It does not allow you to ignore the story. It has individual human voice. It does not fit the thing article is complaining about at all.
- johnchristopher 5y agoCan't remeber where I read it or if it's an original thought but reading lotr was like reading the main story, okay, but also sitting at the campfire and hearing about stories from before. The whole book is as much about the fellowship's quest than the backstory of the whole world and that's what got me in when reading it. It's not about what's happening to our heroes but what happened to others before.
- jrootabega 5y agoThe Talos Principle is an interesting example of the weird relationship between a game and its story. The gameplay is just a ton of small, repetitive, Portal-like puzzles, and I don't say that as a criticism; it's just reality. The story is presented almost completely passively through notes and computer terminals. You could easily believe the game was developed first and then the story was written afterwards. But somehow they combine to make a very engrossing experience.
- Toutouxc 5y agoHow exactly are Raiders of the Lost Ark or Breaking Bad storylines better than those of the first Mafia, The Witcher 3, Uncharted 4, Metro Exodus, Kingdom Come: Deliverance or Half-Life 2 + episodes? And I'm not even mentioning artistic pieces like What Remains of Edith Finch or Life is Strange. There are quests in The Witcher 3 you could make a movie from (Bloody Baron).
- ChrisKnott 5y agoAre you really suggesting Uncharted 4 has as good a story as Breaking Bad?
- gambiting 5y agoI'd say better personally, but that's just me. Edit: to explain a touch more - I liked the story and its characters more, and even though I played it over 2 years ago I still remember the story pretty well. Breaking bad had a couple interesting points but I couldn't tell you what happened between seasons or really much outside of the main points.
- Toutouxc 5y agoWell Breaking Bad is a series and Uncharted 4 is a pretty short, intense ride, so it's a little apples to oranges comparison, but if I compare the first season of Breaking Bad (the only one I've seen) to Uncharted 4, which are both a few hours worth of entertainment, I don't remember the storyline of Breaking Bad being any more intricate or innovative, I mean, terminal patient does questionable things with an unlikely sidekick with expected results. Of course I may be entirely wrong, it's been some time, but I remember both leaving a similar impression on me.
- Hamuko 5y ago>the first season of Breaking Bad (the only one I've seen) Breaking Bad is one of those shows that gets better with every season (the Metacritic score goes 73 → 84 → 89 → 96 → 99 from season 1 to season 5). The first season wasn't really anything special but it's gangbusters by the end.
- unpopularopp 5y ago>The Last of Us has decent gameplay but became a phenomenon by having a story as good as a medium-quality zombie movie Seems like the writer is just hating AAA games But I'm also curious what zombie movies does this guy watch that have a so so much better story than TLoU
- nottorp 5y ago> Seems like the writer is just hating AAA games He's not alone. But I don't hate them, they bore me to tears. Same goes for the current Hollywood blockbusters. > But I'm also curious what zombie movies does this guy watch that have a so so much better story than TLoU Zombieland :)
- reilly3000 5y agoThere are several games I’ve played where I remember playing racing through the action to get further into the story, or games that put storytelling at the center. In no particular order: - Bastion - The Stanley Parable - Bioshock Infinite - The Elder Scrolls series - GTA: V - Control - Sam and Max Sure this isn’t high art, but often is deeply compelling regardless. The possibilities of the medium are still yet to be fully explored. Are there other titles I should look into?
- Sharlin 5y agoPlanescape: Torment, of course, in which combat is rare, often optional, and doesn’t net you much XP compared to story milestones and noncombat quests. Also, probably the only D&D based computer game where it’s a better idea to max Cha/Int/Wis than Str/Con/Dex. (Although unfortunately the third act devolves into a much more linear dungeon crawl, probably due to the devs running out of time.) Vampire: the Masquerade – Bloodlines, with its infamously janky combat but incredibly memorable characters and some superb storytelling moments. Unfortunately, the third-act degeneration is very much a thing here as well. The original Deus Ex, again with rather janky combat and emphasis on stealth and nonviolent problem-solving. Exploration and finding out more about the world is much more rewarding than killing enemies. But the third act… Uh, I think I’m starting to repeat myself here :(
- johnchristopher 5y agoI suggest Father and Son https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=it.tuomuseo.fatherandson&hl=en&gl=US https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=it.tuomuseo.fa... on Android.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- yobert 5y agoI feel like the author has missed some important games, like Star Control 2 and Final Fantasy 7.
- baq 5y agoJust listing important games with a sentence of rationale for each would take longer than the article.
- isoskeles 5y ago> You can kill the bad jerk, but then his chest opens up and a God flies out and the God is the new bad jerk and you beat it up too. (Also known as the JRPG option.) Looks like they covered FF7.
- DeathArrow 5y agoIt's wrong to compare literature with games and think about the story. In literature you have to do two things: tell a story and do it in a pleasant way. If you fail at telling the story, you fail at it. Games have much more to them than just telling a story. You have mechanics, you have visuals. It is interactive and it has outcomes. To not fail a game you have to give player satisfaction. It would be nice to think of all of the things that might appeal to players, the story being just one thing among lots of others. If story would be the only important thing then people would play lots of text based games but they do not. The bad thing is that most of the times players get what designers think is a good game, not what they actually think it is a good game.
- dakial1 5y agoAs I get older (40 y/o) I'm noticing that my video game taste is migrating from dont-think-just-shoot FPS towards well written RPGs (but still with some action, and not turn based rpg). Might be interesting to know i f this happens with everyone...
- dudeman13 5y agoI'll get back to turn based RPGs once the industry stops going bonkers with random encounter frequency (or ditches random encounters altogether). It's ridiculous how The Last Sovereign, a lewd game made with RPG Maker is one of the few turn based games that got story and turn-based combat right.
- orthoxerox 5y agoTLS is just that good. But even it has some problems with combat, namely the over-reliance on hard-hitting enemies, so by the time you get your own stronghold your fights are all about juggling rez and nuke skills, or at least I couldn't make a party that could tank or cc well.
- shmde 5y agoHere are some single player narrative/story driven games which are worth your time and money and also has decent to good storyline. The author seems way too salty over some games I think. - The Last of Us 1 & 2 ( Must play ) - RDR 1&2. ( 2 is must play ) - GTA IV - Mafia 2 - A Plague Tale: Innocence ( must play ) - Metro series. - Inside - Witcher 3 - A Way out ( needs 2 player ) - Night in the woods - Breath of the Wild ( if you own a switch ) - Undertale - The whole Walking Dead series by TellTale. ( Similar theme of Last of Us ) - Life is strange. ( People say it has a clichéd story but I loved it ) - Detroit become human. - Yakuza Series - Sleeping dogs ( A man who never eats pork buns is never a whole man! ) - GoW (2018) ( PlayStation exclusive ) - Uncharted series especially Uncharted 4. ( PS exclusive but its coming to PC soon ) - Horizon Zero Dawn - Nier Automata - Subnautica - Firewatch - Alan Wake. - Fallout (especially New Vegas) - Dishonored series - Pathologic 2. - Disco Elysium.
- thriftwy 5y agoStar Control II and Alpha Centauri are on par with the best SF books out there. Vernor Vinge quality, I would say.
- Noumenon72 5y agoSCII is a great example. The way the Ur-Quan are characterized, their motivations revealed, their factions delineated, is a lot more than you know about most villains. The way some little side mysteries become plot threads while others reveal the depths of the side character races is really good storytelling.
- wellthisisgreat 5y agoOh yeaah SCII
- kyriakos 5y agosince you mentioned Alan Wake all games by Remedy seem to have good stories backing the gameplay. Control would easily make a nice twisted TV series.
- 5y ago
- ElonMuskrat 5y agoIt's great the author has found success and carved out a niche. However it's quiet a stretch for them to speak as an authority, to assert truisms about video games. Several other commentators have great counter examples. From memory games like The Last of Us, Brothers, Life is Strange and Disco Elysium.
- etiam 5y agoThis seems like a somewhat adequate time to ask for storytelling advice. I'm willing to embrace the exhortation to do the storytelling right, without reservation, but how do people actually develop good, or great, skills at it?
- ChrisKnott 5y agoI think the author is absolutely right that the standard for "good story" in games is incredibly low. Games are an immature medium that got catapulted into the mainstream on its other strengths (as challenge/sport/attractive gizmo) and not as art. Unfortunately most of the current audience for games (particularly the vocal part) are people that were attracted by these aspects. I was definitely attracted by the technical feat/ingenious gizmo aspect. If you look at the way games have traditionally been reviewed, you can see that this aspect is incredibly important. These people tend to get upset at articles like this and overreact by claiming that the art aspects of their favourite games are better than they actually are. That said, there are still the green shoots of an incredible artistic medium here and there. I am always on the lookout for things, however crude/I'm-14-and-this-is-deep they are, if they could only have been done in games. Uncharted is a decent action adventure, probably as good as something like Jurassic World, but it could have been done in film. Something like Journey, Her Story, Brothers etc, have aspects that could only have been done in games. They make (fairly crude) artistic points, in an intrinsically interactive way.
- throwthrow564 5y agoI'm surprised this article has no mention of things like visual novels which are generally considered video games, but pretty much work just like novels. Also, Trails in the Sky (and the trails series in general) have a pretty solid story.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- woliveirajr 5y agoI didn't see comments about Under a killing moon or any Monkey's Island. Those games had a different playability, puzzle-solving approach, and their plot was thicker.
- Zababa 5y agoOne thing that isn't mentionned is that games makes you engage way more with the story than movies because of how they are. In most games you can explore areas to discover more things. The equivalent doesn't really exist in movies or books. You can maybe reread a chapter or a paragraph. Pause a film and look at all the details. But that's something people rarely do unless they are analyzing the thing. In games, you have a way more "a la carte" experience. I know that I and many people have a "main road" sense, in which it's easy to see what's the main road that will progress the game, and what are optional branches. That means that if you want to engage more with the world, you can easily choose to. The main quest of Skyrim takes 30 hours, but I'm sure that most people played way more than that. Same thing with games like Far Cry, you can rush the main story, or you can take your time and do way more things. I think that makes games a media where often you don't follow a story but engage with a world. Those are two very different things. Even in linear "walking simulators", there are usually tons of optional stuff. The equivalent would be to have a movie or book that dynamically react to you, and that doesn't really exists, at least not as well as how games do it. On the other hand, the experience of reading a book and imagining all the visual parts, or sitting there watching a movie are also very unique, and can't be filled by other medias.
- SamoyedFurFluff 5y ago> The equivalent would be to have a movie or book that dynamically react to you, and that doesn't really exists, at least not as well as how games do it. This does exist and is called interactive fiction, FWIW. I do agree however it isn’t as clearly reactive to the consumer as a video game (you can turn on a dime in a video game, but in interactive fiction you don’t get such a granular level of control in how you interact).
- Zababa 5y agoI would personally classify interactive fiction closer to games, unless you count gamebooks in that, which I consider closer to books. There was also a movie where you get to get choices linked to Black Mirror that was popular recently, and a few people on youtube explored this by making different videos and letting you pick "what happens next". There's also the whole genre of visual novels, mostly from Japan. I'm not sure if they are more games, books or interactive fiction.
- wanda 5y agoYou have to remember that money is the only thing that exists. Stories do not need to be good for a video game to sell. These days, the game doesn't even need to be original, you can just sell a remake or a remaster and print more money. Stories aren't even a substantial factor for maximising sales. Paid DLCs are often self-contained and not necessarily even based on the story. There is a reason why every game released now is a "cinematic" title with a generic bad story and most likely with online multiplayer (co-op and/or PvP) and microtransactions for player customisations. These games have the "breathtaking cutscenes" and "next-gen visuals" to give game review websites their headlines (game review sites are basically as crooked as financial ratings agencies) and then the game prints money with initial cost, cost of paid DLC, and the cost to give your character flashier armor than the other guy. In the beginning, people developed games with passion. They focused on make the game fun to play, rewarding to play. We didn't know the best ways to do things but we tried. Games were difficult because overcoming a thumb shredding fight is satisfying, figuring out an obscure puzzle is satisfying. But when video game publishers etc got big enough, they were able to cherrypick what they published, so naturally they go for whatever will generate the most revenue with the least risk. This means games are easier, so more people will play them and fewer people will give up on them. Games don't have puzzles that aren't solvable in seconds because this represents a distraction from the combat which some research has likely shown to give the general population more pleasure than anything else. And games don't try very hard at stories because it probably costs a lot to come up with a good story and a good story will likely involve game segments that are a little harder to put together than the generic linear levels the publishers had in mind. Publishers probably also figure it's safer to keep things basic in terms of story because they have data to show that people bought into and/or enjoyed a story 85% similar in the past. And they can just add DLC and remake/remaster the game down the line and flesh the lore out. Hell, they can just rely on the community to maintain the game on a long enough time scale. Stories in video games are bad for the same reason most movies these days are bad and samey. Money dictates everything on a large corporate level and video game production has reached that scale. You still get indie devs who can go off the beaten path, but I feel like 70% of these indie endeavours result in a 2D platforming/metroidvania game because it's easy to make. Which is fine but one could argue that this results in some samey stories. There are obviously other indie games that are good and different but it's still rare to see a great story -- the dev may not care much about the story, they have less time to write a good or original story because the game is likely their side-project, or hell maybe they just suck at stories. ultimately the story isn't super important to whether a game is enjoyable to play. it is a factor to whether the game is fondly remembered, and to whether it moves/touches people. what matters is passion, artistry, soul. hard to define, but basically if something is made with every effort to be perfect, to realise a vision, and to be made enjoyable and fun to play, regardless of cost-efficiency to some corporate timeline, it has a chance of being a great game. if it has a great story, even better, it can have 10/10. I don't care what the graphics are like, I don't need to see the pores on a characters face or their nostril hairs. far too much time is put into this aspect of games. I care about whether the game is fun, whether it's all but addictive to play again. is it challenging? do I feel good when I become skilful enough to overcome challenges? how the hell do I get out of this room? did I seriously just have to read through books I luckily coincidentally own to find the solution to this problem? then comes the story -- and to be honest, this is mostly because there's par for the course. if it's really bad, like horror channel b-movie bad, then there it makes a game struggle to stick. but things like good execution and quality voice acting can help recover a mediocre or unoriginal story. I value originality, I think I am just a little bit too jaded to expect it from games or indeed any media at this point -- it's nice when it happens, but if it doesn't, as long as it's done well and there's passion, as long as the game tries and is fun to play, well made, I'm not gonna hate on it for having not-shakespeare story. but there's a threshold, like I said. Halo is a good example of a shooter with a story that is pretty familiar prima facie, but it earned a pass by being fun to play and the story has more interesting features than immediately meet the eye. metal gear solid, the PSX gsme -- a very familiar plot, certainly for a while into the game anyway, but the execution and storytelling was so good you didn't care.
- wirthjason 5y agoThe first game I remember having a story was The Legend of Zelda. The competition at the time was Mario, Duck Hunt, Excitebike, and all the arcade and Atari games.
- low_tech_love 5y agoOn one hand, the author is spot on about smug ironic dialogue being a plague. Am I too old for this kind of stuff? Nowadays, I feel very lucky when I find a game that is not smug and/or ironic, even if it's bad. On the other hand, the author is smug and ironic in his text. :(
- bsd44 5y agoThat's why I mostly play point&click adventure/rpg games and text adventures, because that genre can't really survive without a good story. I'm rarely disappointed and the games cost a fraction of what you would pay for a AAA title. Not that I don't like AAA, but every time I watch a gameplay video I get bored fairly quickly because I don't feel drawn to the game, it seems "same old, same old". Perhaps it's just me. I think "Life is strange" is a good example of what can happen when the writing is strong combined with a nice, easygoing gameplay that takes you through the story. The only AAA game that I bought was "The Witcher 3" precisely for the back story, but after 5-10h of playing it just felt so repetitive that I gave up on it. I am likely in a minority but I'd take strong writing over graphics, physics and other elements of a game any day.
- Tarsul 5y agoI never played the Witcher but if Cyberpunk 2077 is anything to go by (same developer) I'm not surprised. At least for Cyberpunk the storytelling was not its strong part (neither were its bugs etc... but the visuals were, oh my.). I tried out Gamedec recently and that's an isometric RPG without fights. Which means reading and decisions. And of course great storytelling because without it the game would have basically nothing.
- setpatchaddress 5y agoI wouldn’t judge Witcher 3 based on Cyberpunk 2077. Very different experiences, systems, UI, everything.
- Hamuko 5y agoI quite enjoyed the story in Cyberpunk 2077. And there was quite a lot of lore to go with the story, so it actually felt like a lived-in world.
- ajvs 5y agoIf you like Gamedec you'd love Disco Elysium, but you've probably already heard of it.
- dmos62 5y ago
- namelosw 5y ago> When people say a video game has a good story, they mean that it has a story. The standard is so low is not necessarily a bad thing. Most of the games are bad, but people will try random things to improve storytelling, and we'll see games with great stories like Planescape: Torment or Disco Elysium in the future, or even better. Movies, on the other hand, where there are so many established patterns - people tend to abuse them because 1) they don't want to take the risk to make something subpar 2) it's easier. They were so many terrible movies in the last centuries, but there are so many great movies as well. The golden era of movies has passed, but for games, it's yet to come. There are in fact patterns that could be found in great games, but not as widespread as Hollywood cliches, for example: 1. Planescape: Torment, Witcher 1/2: Amnesia. It allows no assumption of prior knowledge of the protagonist, making the player discover the world, the past, and even the protagonist himself/herself incrementally with himself/herself. Witcher 3 on the contrary, makes me feel less connected because the protagonist knows many characters that I don't know like Dijkstra even though I played through the first two games. 2. Baldur's Gate 2, Pillar of Eternity: Meet the villain in EVERY chapter, and make it feel like watching Steve Jobs at Apple launch events. This gives the player a clear goal, and a villain that can keep all the game plots together instead of being too random and sloppy. 3. Original Sin 2, Baldur's Gate 3: Lock the protagonist with a magical shackle, put a parasite in the protagonist's head, this also gives the player a clear goal, but without spoiling who the villain is (DoS2 is THAT surprising, I bet it might be the same in BG3). Actually, good games can be established on these patterns, until everyone started to abuse them.
- schmorptron 5y agoI really liked the storytelling in Hypnospace Outlaw, where you're just an onlooker to a pseudo-internet and can learn details from peoples' pages and mannerisms.
- platz 5y agoWhen photography was invented, people judged it by how well it could compare to a painting, before discovering what made the medium unique. Video games are in a similar position, in which they are evaluated on 'story', which is how one evaluates movies. once we realize video games are not movies in terms of what effect they are supposed to produce, we will to be able to evaluate them on their own terms For example, maybe what kind of beauty we should seek to maximize in a video game isnt the story, but the act of agency in the player as shaped by the game's rules or constraints. With that idea, it is the player's performance that is most beautiful, not the story.
- smoldesu 5y agoAs John Carmack once said (I'm loosely paraphrasing here) "Stories in video games are like stories in porno: they're expected to be there, but never any good."
- jjoonathan 5y agoWell, that's definitely true of John Carmack's games...
- DiggyJohnson 5y agoI'm writing a book about Why We Play RuneScape, and this is especially true for the MMORPG genre. Great insight.
- ycombinete 5y agoThat sounds like an interesting book. I’ve never really played an MMO and never understood the appeal. I’d log in and not quite know what to do. I’ve just had the same experience with New World. Do you have some of your writing online somewhere?
- DiggyJohnson 5y agoNot yet, but I think this is the rare (book) project that seems to get people asking me exactly your question. I'll be starting to share materials as the project comes along. Really appreciate your interest! Your experience is illuminating, and not unexpected.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dav_Oz 5y agoVideo games with its interactive possibilites possess a unique mechanic device which books or movies simply don't have. So, in a way stories in a game do not serve the same purpose. And if you delve deep into literary theory itself; "stories" do not exist without its form. This dichotmoy is frankly quite misleading. I personally prefer to use another vantage point for examining "video games" borrowed from the strucuralists: What is the difference (to other games)? This quote from Viktor Shklovsky, a Russian Formalist, can be easily translated to the art form of "video games": "And so, in order to return sensation to our limbs, in order to make us feel objects, to make a stone feel stony, man has been given the tool of art. The purpose of art, then, is to lead us to a knowledge of a thing through the organ of sight instead of recognition. By "enstranging" objects and complicating form, the device of art makes perception long and "laborious." The perceptual process in art has a purpose all its own and ought to be extended to the fullest. Art is a means of experiencing the process of creativity. The artifact itself is quite unimportant."
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- unity1001 5y ago> Doesn't matter, because the vast majority of players just tune out the story. As long as you let them skip past it, it's fine. There are a lot of people out there who have put hundreds of hours into World of Warcraft, myself included. If you quizzed us all on World of Warcraft lore, 99% of us would get an F-, guaranteed. Doesnt compute. Not only the above particular tidbit about Wow is his own personal perception, but also the longer you game, the more you get bored of 'pew pew' and you want something that actually is memorable.
- bombcar 5y agoI played WoW for almost a decade and the only story I remember with much clarity is that of Pamela. Otherwise things happened quest objectives lit up and I think Arthas married Thrall or something.
- VortexDream 5y agoI used to be deeply immersed in Warcraft lore. WoW helped me kick that habit, ironically. I think though if the game had good stories told well, more people would be interested in paying attention. And people are interested in WoW's story. Or else there wouldn't be as much squabbling about the latest way in which Blizzard butchered the story. FFXIV shows how much many players want to care. Some of my favorite story-based experiences in gaming were in an MMO (The Secret World).
- bombcar 5y agoMMOs are uniquely suited to a particular type of storytelling- drawn out over many quests in many parts of the world, where major aspects of the main story are only glimpsed at. But to do that you need the main story set well which WoW has lacked since post-Arthas.
- unity1001 5y agoYeah, and that's your personal experience. I dont care about Wow's story, I didnt even pay attention to the quests or cinematics, yet even i can count 40-50% of the chronology. Likewise many people on my server.
- BashiBazouk 5y agoI'd be in the opposite camp. Video game stories are those things I have to quickly click through to get to the next bit of action. Ya, ya, ya, bla, bla, bla, click, click click, don't care. My ideal is to create my own story rather than have it spoon fed to me. Let me roll a character then let me do what I want in an interactive open world. Sure, some curating and minor direction is OK, but the less the better. I don't remember much of the story of GTA 3 other than slogging through it to open the city up but surfing a car all over town causing mayhem or endlessly jumping the ski jump on the third island, those are the memories of that game I remember vividly and cherish. To enhance this I absolutely love good procedural generation. Finding that one out of a thousand planet in No Mans Sky and just exploring it, taking screen shots knowing that I'm likely the only person who will ever visit it, wonderful. The other problem with modern video game stories I notice now that I have a kid: there are plenty of video games that action wise I have no problem letting my kid play but can't due to the story and mainly the cut scenes. Seems to be a path to some edgy cred when the base action does not really justify it.
- humblepie 5y agoThis is what I do since, I don't know, King's Quest series? After the death of adventure games I don't care about stories anymore. The graphics and the gameplay carry all the weight now. The Assassin's Creed series-what is this Animus crap? Just make the character be that assassin guy instead of switching to some pandering story about a time computer. Seeing what they did to ancient settings and bringing these cities to life is cool but have no time for little stories.
- ace2358 5y agoI can’t stand that animus stuff honestly I usually turn it off after one of those scenes just to wash it away. Totally destroys the game for me (which I only just started with origins and odyssey)
- teawrecks 5y ago> there are plenty of video games that action wise I have no problem letting my kid play but can't due to the story and mainly the cut scenes. Examples?
- everdrive 5y agoMany video games have very poor or bare plots, but amazing settings. In fact, I'm not sure that video games are actually good vehicles for plots. Video games are interactive, but all good plots require careful pacing and timing in order to be successful. It's possible to force this in a game, but the more you do, the more the game becomes an interactive movie. A great example would be Dark Souls: incredible setting, but really bare-bones plot. The plot is effectively: "You're the chosen undead, and you must quest for some items." The setting, on the other hand, could fill books. In some sense, it's similar to comparing a good news article to a good story. A good story. Good story generally can't be purely fact-based, since this interrupts the needs of narrative: pacing, good vs. evil, moral decisions, defeats, and victories, etc. A good news story may have something like a narrative, but it's more of a collection of facts. If there's an narrative at all, it exists simply to help explain the relevance of the facts presented. Video games are metaphorically similar: You may have an interesting plot in the game, but it is punctuated by the actions you get to take as a player. For example, in Wind Waker you must rescue your sister, but in practice the player is running around an island, breaking pots, and doing sidequests. The narrative plot and the play actions are almost totally disparate. The plot is nearly a side story, which helps add context to the player actions.
- hypertele-Xii 5y ago> not sure that video games are actually good vehicles for plots. Video games are interactive, but all good plots require careful pacing and timing in order to be successful. Video games are a great medium for plots! You just have to allow the plot to fail, and let the player take it on tangents. Games that go "uhh you died that's not canon let's rewind" are just shitty games.
- watwut 5y ago> Games that go "uhh you died that's not canon let's rewind" are just shitty games. That would be overwhelming majority of them. And overwhelming majority of players don't mind this aspect or even actively like it.
- 5y ago
- oblak 5y ago"Blah blah blah blah secret base. Blah blah blah blah plan. Blah blah blah nuclear missile bomb. Blah blah blah counting on you. Utmost importance. Win. Good luck." Too bad Bulletstorm has no jumping so I did not buy it. In any case, even that's too much story for me. Look what happened with Doom. The 2016 game was pure. It knew what it was and ended that nonsense right away. Doom Eternal, on the other hand, had to feature a story, a castle, idiotic cut scenes and what not. Dear god. Just stop it.
- SV_BubbleTime 5y ago> Observation 6: Good writing comes from a distinctive, individual, human voice. Thus, you'll mainly get it in indie games. Outer Wilds. Hands down one of my top games of all time, a total sleeper. But has more heart than any AAA title I’ve ever played. If you haven’t tried it, super highly recommend.
- DantesKite 5y agoWolfentstein II was a masterclass in story telling and right up there with Quentin Tarantino.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- krumpet 5y agoThank you for mentioning Ultima IV! My favorite game of all times and, to your point, a definite departure from what other games were doing at the time. Having to consider the long-term impact of the actions my character took changed everything about gaming for me in the mid-80s.
- geogra4 5y agoSpiderweb software is really legendary for anyone who was a Mac user in the 90s. Really great products.
- Jensson 5y agoForcing people to read through the story or sit through cutscenes is like forcing people to play the hard version of a boss. Sure playing the hard version might be more interesting, but many people don't really care much about interesting gameplay and just want to relax and enjoy themselves. The same thing with the story, sure it might be more interesting for the player if they read through and properly embraced the story, but that is a lot of work and will just feel like a chore to many people. You can make many more interesting games if you assume everywhere that the player cares about the story. Same as how you can make more interesting gameplay if you know the player wants an interesting challenge and always plays on hard, like in Dark Souls. But ultimately most people don't want to challenge themselves, regardless if it is trying to remember a lot of story content or practicing a boss fight.
- wellthisisgreat 5y agoWhat's everyone's favorite videogame plot? First thing that comes to mind if Planescape Torment but oddly I don't really remember much details. Trying to remember if any videogame has actually moved me in a way some book or film did and, frankly, I don't think so.
- karaterobot 5y agoI agree with a lot of his points, and with the general thesis of the article. But, I disagree with this: > The default video game plot is, 'See that guy over there? That guy is bad. Kill that guy.' If your plot is anything different, you're 99% of the way to having a better story. I don't think the structure of the story needs to be more complex than that to be good. It can be, but neither complexity, nor novelty, nor non-linearity are what makes stories good. The stuff he dismisses as being of limited value (good dialog and interesting worlds) are extremely important. I'd add characterization to that. But those things are, to lots of people, all equally as important as structure in making a story meaningful.
- lukaszkups 5y agoOne of the greatest game stories I've ever encountered is the one without any words- Hyper Light Drifter. The way the Heart Machine decided to tell it (images only) still amazes me. It totally opened interpretation for the players. And you didn't have to click through tons of dialogs to dive into the lore.
- krisgenre 5y agoI am not sure if there were any before but Max Payne was the first game that I had every played with an intriguing storyline and an awesome haunting music. I believe those guys invented 'bullet time'.
- markus_zhang 5y agoI tried to develop a small RPG and immediately realized that the most difficult thing to get right is the story, and the second difficult one is the arts. And no wonder most of the Indie RPG (that I know) are of roguelike/roguelite. It's a blood sea.
- bob229 5y agoVideo games are for incels
- hereme888 5y agoI rarely play video games,but when I do, it's because the ones I pick give me a more immersive story than watching a movie. So, I'm on the camp that believes in playing for the story, and I don't play so much that the amazing stories in most games I've played become boring.
- patrec 5y agoThis article is refreshingly honest about the general inanity of video games. Does anyone have a compelling explanation why video games are such an artistic wasteland even compared to other mainstream forms of entertainment like TV or cinema?
- martinmakesgame 5y agoI'm really surprised that out of 276 comments, only one comment mentions that this is Jeff Vogel. I have enjoyed playing Jeff's games in the past, I think his games are beautiful. He's amazing as a game maker with all of his experience.
- Noumenon72 5y agoI wonder if he hid that on purpose to seem like a fresh perspective? He doesn't even mention it in his Substack bio.
- fulafel 5y agoI think the focus on combat in game mechanics is what ruins most games from a interactive fiction / interactive movie POV. Players of Monkey Island gams don't and can't ignore the plot.
- SZJX 5y agoThis is exactly why I don't play single-player games anymore, not even JRPGs which are supposed to be more story-focused but which just end up going the safe and mainstream route anyways, especially if they're a big-budget production similar to AAA games in the west. Grinding against AI enemies is totally pointless (well at least until real "AI" akin to Alphago becomes popularized I guess). If I want to be challenged on skills and mental traits via gameplay, I play against other human players in multiplayer games (I don't do that either since this year, as it can ultimately be perceived as a repetitive timesink from which you get nothing new, once you reach a certain level in terms of ranking and of course can't go further by making it your full-time job). Nowadays I pretty much just read visual novels https://vndb.org/ https://vndb.org/, when not reading actual traditional books. I believe it's still a relatively niche genre in the west, though its popularity outside of Japan has been steadily growing in the last decade. There's truly no limit to the authors' creativity in the world of VN, and you get all sorts of thought-provoking and sometimes even life-changing experience (not an exaggeration, see reviews for the highest-rated VN of all time https://vndb.org/v92 https://vndb.org/v92), which when delivered well cannot be replicated in any other medium. PS: people say "nobody reads books anymore these days" all the time just like the author does, the validity of which I have always doubted. 100 years ago the literacy rate was much lower than it is nowadays. And even 30 or 40 years ago, it was unlikely that the vast majority of the populace were into serious reading instead of more straightforward pasttime such as TV or just a day out on the beach. Reading has always been a relatively minority hobby and has probably already managed to become more popular (especially with the proliferation of audiobooks and other technologies), instead of declining.
- apricot13 5y agoI spent 5? years playing destiny and destiny 2 a few times a week. I couldn't tell you a thing about the story because we played it co-op in a group and everyone talked over the story!
- deepnet 5y agoStories are trajectories on a low dimensional manifold of meaningful in the semantic vector space of states and actions. Curated stories are fragile and less impactful and personal than that interwoven serandipity we navigate by connecting experiences and imbuing them with prepotent engaged meaning viscerally entagling choronological coincidences with the synchronicity of our own personal journey. There may only be a few archetypal stories, but each heroes journey if it is transformative in the Jungian sense of individuation is a means of self discovering growth in a verdant simulation. Like culture, myth, fairy tales and dreams video games are a mytho-poetic structure that can utterly envelope and transform us through the power of beauty, harmony, dissonance and engagement. There is a lot to be said for the abstraction of pixel art in that it can let the imagination fill in the gaps and engage with the characters, suspending disbelief because there is room for the imaginative act to flourish and the self to identify more than the ultra realistic fully defined hyper realism of AAA games - near perfection is an uncanny valley, the shudder that prevents us being fully involved. Video games are powerful when they engage the imagination, the stories are created by us, we are story tellers that is how we understand ourselves and game experiences are as rich and valid as any art form.
- tweetle_beetle 5y agoMy observation is that people seem to mean many different things by story in games and many of these threads are people talking across purposes. I would agree with the author that game stories are generally pretty crude. I don't play much these days, but I've realised what I really want is not necessarily a AAA voice cast, gigabytes of lore, plot twists, or what hundreds of users might call a great story. I just want atmosphere: a coherent, impossible to explain sense of being. There are games with massive issues that have great atmosphere and vice versa. I'd argue that games are much better positioned to offer this than story. It's actually their main strength and what makes much more sense to evaluate.
- johnchristopher 5y agoThere are many things to say (and I do agree with the author) but unfortunately that conversation is going to bring out people who think Doom is scarier than Silent Hill because there are more jump scares in Doom and too much reading and personal trauma in Silent Hill. It's like when you are under 15 and watching a movie where a character gets raped or another has an abortion. The reality will only hit you later in life and that story won't be as easy to watch. It's like that episode from DS9 where Captain Sisko tells his son his writing is dull because his son doesn't know what he is writing about and Siskok encourages him to write about matters he knows. Or in Good will Hunting, when the psychotherapist explains to Will something along the line of "you can deconstruct my psyche and analyze it but you don't know jack about it". Likewise some games that were recently acclaimed for their approach to the subject (Celeste, Old man's journey, Sea of solitude) really fell dull to me.