3 ms·
Truth Social Violated Mastodon’s License; Entire Platform Might Now Be DOA
- iab 5y agoThis is a touch hyperbolic, isn't it? If they are rolling in SPAC cash, why not just write a large sponsorship check to Mastodon gGmbH and get a closed-source license?
- chuckee 5y agoOr why not comply with the license and open-source it? It's not like their social network is popular due to their technological edge, and if someone else copies that, their users would leave..
- iab 5y agoIt’s a fair point
- tinus_hn 5y agoJust a touch? What would this project have customized that they would need to keep secret and that would be interesting for others? Probably next to nothing. It’s just people harassing Trump because it’s Trump. Meanwhile it just looks really bad for open source in general: This project is free but if you use it people will sue you for not complying with obtuse regulations. With this other software the rules are clear and the vendor isn’t going to sue you, you just have to pay a few thousand dollars. Now let’s all act all surprised companies are hesitant to use open source software.
- dane-pgp 5y ago> Open-source software is free to use but that doesn’t mean that it’s in the public domain. So far so good. > A lot of open-source software is made available under what is known as a “copyleft” license. The terms are simple: ... if you fork it, you must put the new version of the software—including the parts you developed—in the public domain and make the source code freely available. Wrong and wrong. The author is an appellate lawyer, and yet he seems unsure about the meaning of "public domain", or just hasn't read the licence (which is ironic, given that he is criticising people for exactly that failing). Also he hasn't understood the more nuanced point that "copyleft" licences don't necessarily require that you share the source code with people who only interact with the running code via a network service. That extra requirement is a feature of the AGPL beyond being a copyleft licence.
- readflaggedcomm 5y ago>Mastodon, the software Trump is using to create Truth Social I see this restated as fact, when the public has no access to its closed beta. Where is the proof?
- Kina 5y agoIt's things like this (https://twitter.com/therealsunbunny/status/1454191029062717451/photo/1 https://twitter.com/therealsunbunny/status/14541910290627174...) that people noticed.
- Proven 5y agoWhat part of "the public has no access" do you not understand?
- aaron695 5y agoAnd where's the proof they modified it? ( Incorrectly explained as a fork in this article) The host doesn't have to share the code unless they changed it. Is AGPL that hard to understand? I get HN is not very technical but the license is written in pretty plain English.
- NicoJuicy 5y agoIt is, so a simple search for yourselve.