10 ms·
If Silence Is the Cost of Great Ramen, So Be It
- jjuel 5y ago> Could you help us out by quieting down? He said that most people have a hard time turning down such a request. Can you imagine trying that somewhere in the United States? Let's just say there are quite a few people that would definitely turn down that request. I am shocked how little people in this country care about other people or society in general. Especially compared to a place like Japan.
- ggm 5y agohttps://goo.gl/maps/aysrGeHtVDYdrnqw5 https://goo.gl/maps/aysrGeHtVDYdrnqw5
- oliv__ 5y agoWhere does this end? When will people be satisfied? When we all remain alone at home in silence, masked up and living through VR goggles in the Metaverse? It's becoming harder and harder to claim what's happening is all about "health".
- dymk 5y agoIf a restaurant asks me to not talk with my partner while I’m eating there, I’ll just chose to not eat there. I’m vaccinated. I’ve done my part. It seems like new restrictions and rules are forever escalating, and will continue to do so past any reasonable point.
- macintux 5y ago[flagged]
- syshum 5y agoThe OP did not say they could not, or should not be allowed to prevent patrons from talking, only that they personally would choose not to eat there To many people believe "freedom" means "people need to do, and accept what I want"... That is not freedom the business is free to say "no talking" and I am free to say "no shopping there".... That is the market at work. The problem is when government attempts to impose requirements on either the business or the customer. Let the market work, we do not need government mandating in either direction
- macintux 5y agoI specifically quoted the part I disagreed with: “I’ve done my part”.
- horns4lyfe 5y agoIf it’s obvious the vaccine doesn’t stop the spread, then why is it table stakes for anything? At that point it’s just a personal safety choice, and I don’t care at all if others get it.
- taylortbb 5y agoThere's space between "stops the spread" and "doesn't affect the spread" . Current vaccination levels are inadequate to stop the spread, but they do significantly reduce it.
- pessimizer 5y agoVaccination isn't a ticket or an anointment, it's an injection that prepares your immune system to better fight the coronavirus. Saying that there's no need for it because it's not a complete solution is like selling your car because you still have to walk to get from your couch to your car.
- horns4lyfe 5y agoSure, and that’s why I got it. That doesn’t explain why everyone is so hell-bent on forcing others to get it.
- knowfilter 5y agoPeople are encouraged to get vaccinations to reduce the transmission of diseases
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ajuc 5y agoIf a parachute doesn't stop the fall why use it? Let's jump without.
- 5y ago
- exo762 5y ago> It’s increasingly obvious vaccination doesn’t prevent the spread. The idea that spread is something that should be stopped at ANY cost is false. Now, what is the price we are willing to pay to stop it? We've already used a novel vaccine. What next? The highest price acceptable by me has been paid.
- Ekaros 5y agoMandatory testing before you are allowed to leave house? I see that as next logical step. And really should have been the chosen method instead of vaccination passports.
- syshum 5y agoSo where do you stop? Do I need mandatory testing for all illness as well? What about inebration, should my door have a BAC meter on it? Every car?? The amount of draconian authoritarianism people are willing to accept here is insanity to me. I often read Sci-Fi dystopian novels thinking "How could a future like that happen really" Now I know... people are willing to trade every ounce of freedom they have for the perception of safety. Very sad
- nextaccountic 5y agoThe price of inaction is way higher. There are still people dying of Covid. Covid deaths in the US are at the same level as they were in May 2020.
- tasogare 5y agoI agree with your first paragraph. I don't eat with other people often but if a shop asked me not to talk when being with someone else I would just go elsewhere. Also I suspect the writer of the article put lot of efforts searching for such a shop because the only place I ever saw with the mokushoku policy is one of the university cafeteria and people (including me) don't follow it anyway. There is also a lot of plastic, which is useless but in line of the Japanese mentality of doing things for the sake of doing them instead of the impact it has on the output.
- sildur 5y agoAt this point I'm starting to suspect this is basically people on a power trip, disguised.
- iszomer 5y agoWhat I don't understand is why The Atlantic is compelled to write up this piece of how to eat ramen from a Western perspective. Shouldn't this specific mandate be more applicable to those eating at a teppanyaki or hot pot restaurant instead? Eating ramen is highly individualized and tends to not include miscellaneous side dishes.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- arp242 5y ago> If a restaurant asks me to not talk with my partner while I’m eating there, I’ll just chose to not eat there. That's fair enough. Personally, I think I'd actually appreciate this kind of quiet and serenity for a bit, completely separate from COVID. A moment of peace, silence, and reflection. I think we could all do with a bit more of that instead of the constant distractions of music, chatter, etc.
- dymk 5y agoYou do you. But I'll eat at home alone if that's what I want to do. If I'm eating at a restaurant, almost all of the value proposition is the environment and socialization with the people I went with.
- marssaxman 5y agoI feel similarly about the "show ID and proof of vaccination to enter" policy that went into effect last week here in King County. It's too much. I got my shots, I've done my part with masks and distancing and so forth; a "return to normal" which includes checkpoints and paperwork at every door does not feel at all normal to me. I'd rather just keep waiting.
- dymk 5y agoYou know what the real kicker is? The new King County policy _explicitly_ disallows asking for ID to verify the name on the vaccination card matches the person holding it (something about being unequitable for those who don't have an ID). It's all a power trip, meant to look like leadership is taking decisive action. But they have no idea what they're doing.
- xutopia 5y agoDidn't David Chang go to that restaurant and find it was just OK and requiring silence was just some pretentious thing?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- z0r 5y agoDavid Chang's food is overrated in my opinion
- fredestine 5y agonot even talking about him riding the woke wave and talking about cultural appropriation and stuff while appropriating japanese culture or chinese culture and calling his dishes "MALA" something to make it ethnic while the dish doesn't share anything with its roots.
- jiscariot 5y agoNetflix is trying to make him the next Anothony Bordain. Momofuku and Milkbar are given so much love, you'd think they invented flight or something. Netflix will go full Terrance Mallick mode backed by a symphony, while they pan the camera to someone making a cookie. It is utterly absurd.
- delogos 5y agoThat sounds fabulous and is a definite stark contrast from "the best local ramen" here in the Austin,TX area. It's apparently vogue here to have music so loud you can't hear your dining companion unless they shout.
- Jakob 5y agoIn Singapore, music in the public is largely forbidden until further notice. Especially in restaurants, so people do not need to raise their voice to understand each other. It was eerie at first but I enjoy the calmness in the city now, e.g. drinking a glass in a rooftop bar of a 60 story building in total quietude is an event.
- me_me_me 5y ago"Are you guys ok?", "would you like a drink top up?", "is everything ok?", "do you need anything?" Dinners in US are irritable to me. I understand why and how it happens, I just wish there was a sign a wrist band or something to signal to waiting staff to leave me alone unless i ask for their help.
- chiyc 5y agoI feel like I've encountered less of that style of service lately. But I don't know though if it's that the types of restaurants I go to have changed, or there's a cultural difference having moved recently to NYC.
- cafard 5y ago"vogue here"? Only if "here" is defined to mean the United States as a whole. How are you going to know that you're enjoying yourself if you aren't half-deafened?
- Youden 5y agoMy ramen experiences in Japan are very different to the ones abroad. In Japan, ramen is meant to be pretty quick, taking "fast food" to a whole other level: you go in, order and pay, sit down, eat, then leave. The eating environment is often either a tiny table, a seat at a bar or a small booth. It's usually not a place for social get togethers. In Europe on the other hand, they're usually normal sit down restaurants. You have to go through the normal dance of waiting to be seated, ordering with the server, waiting 10-15 mins for your food then trying to get somebody's attention to pay when you're done.
- silexia 5y agoI am vaccinated and went to Seattle to visit some friends there last weekend. I was shocked to find that I had to show my vaccine card to enter a restaurant and wear a mask the whole time. I was the first one of my friends group to go into full quarantine in February 2020, but the statistics now show it is as safe as it was pre-pandemic to return to our regular lives. Why are people insisting on escalating restrictions further?
- amcoastal 5y ago>but the statistics now show it is as safe as it was pre-pandemic to return to our regular lives. Why are people insisting on escalating restrictions further? Probably because the statistics don't say that at all.
- frockington1 5y agoIf you use Florida as a basis for risk, it's almost non existent last few weeks. Unless you're old, a fat, or have a preexisting risk is relatively low.
- SketchySeaBeast 5y ago> a fat I sincerely hope that is a typo/second language error and not how you're describing/thinking about people.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- theonemind 5y ago> Unless you're old, a fat, or have a preexisting risk is relatively low. Unless you're [most people in the United States] Those probably cover like 60% of the US population (mostly due to prevalent obesity and an aging population)
- datameta 5y ago
- brian_herman 5y agoThe cost of freedom isn’t nothing. Just as our predecessors had to sacrifice for World War II. We must sacrifice things to allow people to survive against the corona virus. Edit:wording and clarification
- vnchr 5y agoI'm not sure if this post is intentionally ironic, but I think it's worth noting that story is one of giving up freedom.
- x62Bh7948f 5y agomost ramen places around my office (gotanda) could be considered fast food. customers usually go alone to eat in about 10 minutes and back to work (no time to talk). udon restaurants with no seats at all are also very common. that makes you eat even faster
- bobthechef 5y agoThe dinner table is a place for socialization. This is where conversations take place, where people discuss all sorts of things (including subjects of political relevance). Appealing to COVID to enforce silence especially in settings where a good portion of communication takes place is a great social harm. The isolation of the pandemic was bad enough in this regard. We've lost our minds where COVID is concerned. We've made rituals of real or imaginary effectiveness the highest standard of conduct. COVID is not synonymous with death, as if by voiding COVID you or others will avoid death. The extremist, fallacious, and obsessive thinking surrounding COVID very much qualifies as a phobia and one which leads to imprudent and irrational fears unmoored from the reality and risks of everyday life. You will die eventually. Everyone will. Get used to it. And it probably won't be because you got COVID.
- Mikeb85 5y agoRamen is fast food and ramen shops aren't the type of place you socialize. An Izakaya or bar would be considered more social places.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tomhunters 5y agoIf the food is worth the silence, I'll try it out. I understand the policy as Japan is a collectivist country. So it's not quite hard to follow the rules.
- Mikeb85 5y agoRamen isn't exactly a social food anyway. The food is individual by design, it's hard to eat it with good manners, it's best eaten quickly, and it's cheap so the expectation is that you don't linger and chat.
- donkeyd 5y ago> And there’s evidence that silence actually works. My God, do I despise people who pull down their mask when they talk. I see it everywhere, at work, in airplanes, etc. It's almost like any form of common sense is lost.
- Etheryte 5y agoJust the other day I had the wonderful experience of seeing someone who pulled their mask down to cough. If only there was a reason the mask was there.
- dang 5y agoPlease don't post flamewar comments or unsubstantive comments to HN, regardless of how badly other people behave or you feel they behave. We're trying for something quite different here. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- donkeyd 5y agoOk, my bad, flame war definitely wasn't what I was going for, but I get what you're saying.
- dustintrex 5y agoIchiran, a famous tonkotsu ramen joint from Fukuoka now franchised internationally, has been doing the "eat your ramen in silence" thing long since before COVID made it cool. The atmosphere has been not inaccurately likened to an old school porno parlor, with everybody intently doing their own thing in their private one-person booths. https://qz.com/quartzy/1588711/ichiran-ramen-shop-offers-serenity-in-new-yorks-times-square/ https://qz.com/quartzy/1588711/ichiran-ramen-shop-offers-ser...
- draw_down 5y agoWow, it's really lucky that shouting to the cook when you order doesn't spread the virus, even though talking to other customers does spread it. What a relief!!