2 ms·
DNS itself is certainly problematic. Incorporating a time dimension to domains, such that it's explicitly recognised, and greatly restricting transfers, would
by dredmorbius 5y ago
DNS itself is certainly problematic.
Incorporating a time dimension to domains, such that it's explicitly recognised, and greatly restricting transfers, would be one element.
Ownership of domains should sit with the registrant, not the registrar.
Characterspace should be explicitly restricted to 7-byte ASCII to avoid homoglyph attacks. It's not a shrine to cultural affirmation, it's a globally-utilised indexing system, and as such is inherently a pidgen.
Other obvious pain points:
- BGP / routing
- Identity, authentication, integrity, and trust. This includes anonymity and repudiation. Either pole of singular authentication or total anonymity seems quite problematic.
- Security. It shouldn't have been permitted to be baked on.
- Protocol extensibility. Standards are good, but they can be stifling, and a tool for control. Much of the worst of the current Internet reflects both these problems.
- Lack of true public advocacy. It's deeply ironic that the most extensive and universal communications platform ever devised is controlled by a small handful of interests, none answerable to the public.
- More address space. IPv6 is a problematic answer.
- Better support for small-player participation. Servers are still highly dependent on persistence and major infrastructure. A much more robust peered / mesh / distributed protocol set that could be utilised without deep expertise ... well, it might not make things better, but we'd have a different problem-set than we face presently.
- Explicit public funding model for content, and a ban or very heavy tax on most advertising.
- A much keener, skeptical, and pessimistic early analysis of the interactions of media and society.
- poetaster 5y agoOLpC kind of dream?
- dredmorbius 5y agoSorry? (One Laptop Per Child I underststand. Not its relationship to my comments.)
- poetaster 5y agoIn the main, decentralized community (small player?) centered networking. Mesh ++. I admit it's some time since I thought about it but OLPC is what came to mind.
- dredmorbius 5y agoMaybe in part. I suspect that might get problematic ultimately. Within the transport network itself, localised dendritic trust relations (and corresponding transport flows) will all but certainly emerge. There might be some ad-hoc leaf-node communications, but standard, equipment, maintenance, etc., all favour some level of centralisation. Note that "some level" != "complete and total".
- CuriousSkeptic 5y agoOn the domain name issues. Perhaps identity shouldn’t hinge on a mnemonic globally unique identifier at all. Instead something like local mnemonics linking to authenticated reputation based identities. I guess a web of trust kind of approach.
- dredmorbius 5y agoSo ... I lean that way in theory, though the question of how a WoT gets structured to support search (and unambiguous search) is its own interesting question. That's something PGP never managed to do. That said, an identity defined by a set of relationships, rather than a single pecuniary relationship with a registrar, seems more robust.