3 ms·
> If I buy a book in one format, it doesn’t seem fair to pay full price to get it in another format. Really? What if you're buying it for someone else? How is
by kazinator 5y ago
> If I buy a book in one format, it doesn’t seem fair to pay full price to get it in another format.
Really? What if you're buying it for someone else? How is the purchase transaction supposed to validate something like that?
If you paid for a copy of something, then within the copyright framework, you may create a copy of it for yourself in another format.
> Paper? Just cover its cost: $4 each (+ postage)
> It’s worked out well. People are buying many hardcover copies as gifts. A few people have bought over 500 copies each to give to clients or members of their organization.
OK, but traditional publishing is going to see that as being asked to institutionalize copyright infringement. This is literally describing paying for the content once and then just making copies at cost to distribute to others to whom the content is entirely new.
Why not pay for the first hard copy to cover the cost of content, and then buy 500,000 cheap copies just "covering the cost" for making copies for every other reader the book will ever have?
I think that within the copyright framework in which publishing operates, the implementation of someething like this has to be severely limited. When you buy a work, you actually purchase some unique token linking you to that work. Under that token, you have the right to buy a small number of additional copies of that work (in various formats) at a big discount. Not hundreds!
When the token reaches its purchase limit, that's it; it is is deactivated for further purchases.