3 ms·
It's a remedy for existing discrimination. For example, if for a job we have 100 candidates in group A and 100 in group B, and we only hire from group A, then r
by wolverine876 5y ago
It's a remedy for existing discrimination. For example, if for a job we have 100 candidates in group A and 100 in group B, and we only hire from group A, then requiring some hiring from group B likely increases the hiring based on merit and decreases discrimination.
The odd thing is a lack of concern for the decades and centuries of discrimination that continue today, and only focusing on criticizing remedies for it. When do we see posts on HN addressing the former?
- twofornone 5y ago>For example, if for a job we have 100 candidates in group A and 100 in group B, and we only hire from group A, then requiring some hiring from group B likely increases the hiring based on merit and decreases discrimination. This is borderline disingenuous. In the vast majority of institutions accused of discrimination because of disproportionate representation, the underrepresented groups are already underrepresented among applicants. Especially in the military - what proportion of military applicants have historically (or contemporaneously) been female? More importantly, your repeated justification for discrimination against white males is predicated upon the dangerous and ubiquitous conflation of equality of opportunity with equality of outcome. There is absolutely no reason to expect one to imply the other in a diverse, even perfectly meritocratic civilization. Culture heavily influences career/employment goals. That's one of the major issues with the entire diversity movement. The bulk of evidentiary support for reverse racism comes from statistical underrepresentation, which is effectively impossible to conclusively blame on discrimination. Equal representation is not a viable goal at least because, ignoring other reasons, not all demographics are equally interested in all jobs.
- wolverine876 5y agoAgain, we keep looking for alternative explanations, like an obsession, like climate change denial. What are we avoiding? There's plenty of evidence, all over, of racial and gender discrimination. Let's do something about it.
- Chris2048 5y agoCan't we hire disproportionally for one group and be meritorious? Why assume all groups are equally good at a thing?
- wolverine876 5y agoTheoretically, yes, But the overwhelming evidence is that isn't what has happened or is happening. An important question is, why are people looking for every theoretical possibility instead of where the evidence clearly points: plain prejudice.
- Chris2048 5y agoThen pick the best of this overwhelming evidence and present that alone. The logic in your comment implied the discrepancy was enough to assume discrimination w/o any reference to evidence. > why are people looking for every theoretical possibility Are you talking about my comment? Your own comment ("if for a job we have 100 candidates in group A and 100 in group B...") is a theoretical, so that's why I countered with one. Present evidence of prejudice specific to the topic at hand and I can comment more tangibly one that.
- wolverine876 5y agoIt's like climate change denial or the theory of gravity: I'm not reestablishing the facts for the 10 billionth time. Racism has been extremely well researched, documented, and discussed for generations.
- Chris2048 5y ago> Racism has.. What, exactly? "Racism" and it's very existence, or specifically it's effect on the topic at hand ? You haven't really established what it is you are arguing, let alone any of the facts/research specific you allude to, specific to that argument. And no, soft science subjects like this are not like hard-science topics like global climate or gravity. It feels like you only include this to paint me as some kind of "Racism denier" or something. I don't deny racism exists, I just don't accept that as an argument that means it must be the cause of every unequal outcome.