3 ms·
Part of the value of the original was kids could see and feel how it worked. That made it a fascinating toy. It's all been lost.
by fortran77 5y ago
Part of the value of the original was kids could see and feel how it worked. That made it a fascinating toy. It's all been lost.
- smegcicle 5y agoand nowadays you could 3dprint new records for it
- Jtsummers 5y agoI have a music box that uses a paper tape, it was an extra as I was making a gift for a family member and Thinkgeek (long before the Gamestop acquisition) accidentally sent me two. It was actually a lot of fun to make extra songs for it, the toy becomes interactive for the player. Which is a much better thing for kids than something that can only ever play 10 songs, and which they cannot alter in any meaningful sense.
- dangle1 5y agoYeah, this brought back an early memory of my sparkling new brain examining the mechanism of the original version of this toy with my eyes and fingers without any words to describe what I was learning. Just some kind of sense of mastery that I couldn't communicate, but made me feel more confident about my understanding of the world. It seems pretty cynical to market this in order to appeal to people like me with memories like this, with a huge dimension of the enrichment value stripped away.
- tyleo 5y agoI agree, I’d pay a little more for a mechanical version. If this trend continues even wooden blocks will some day come with batteries :p
- johnsonap 5y agoand will also have bluetooth
- handrous 5y agoI seem to recall looking into wooden blocks for my kids when they were a little younger, and finding not that they need batteries, but the new normal-tier wooden blocks are now kinda shit—small, uneven finish and size consistency isn't good, et c.—and you have to start looking into niche "premium" toys to get good ones. We got some of those cube ones with the letters and numbers at one point, and they were noticeably smaller and worse-finished than the ones I had as a kid in the 80s, which I'm sure were just the only blocks of that type that some cheap local store had and were probably the same quality as all such blocks on the market at the time, not something special. The newer ones looked very similar in a photo, but were missing lots of textures (kinda, you know, a big deal to babies and early toddlers) and details that mine had, and the paint chipped more easily (probably a thinner coat, I guess, plus probably just lower-quality paint). We bought our first kid a rolling walker/phone thing with some other features—yeah, electronic crap, but at least this one had a volume setting, unlike many modern ones that are just fixed to "deafen your child" with no other options unless you break out a soldering iron. By ~4 years later, between seeing other people's version of the same thing—same brand and all—they bought a couple years after ours, and seeing newer version at the store when toy shopping, we'd noticed that the "same" product, which looked nearly identical, had had a couple revisions, each one making parts that used to move or be interactive fixed & dormant, and otherwise lowering the quality.
- BadCookie 5y agoExactly right. That’s why I bought an “antique” one on eBay for my young son a few years ago. I had zero desire for the new garbage version. It was maybe twice as expensive, but 100% worth it to me.
- DaiPlusPlus 5y ago> kids could see and feel how it worked. That made it a fascinating toy I assume all of us here on HN are the type-of-person who as a child would have been fascinated about how mechanical and electromechanical toys and gizmos worked - and probably disassembled the thing to our parents' chagrin and figured out how it works (and hopefully put it back together correctly!) and ended the day with a sense of satisfaction from learning something new. ...and then I'm remind myself that we are not like everyone else: I'm still able to vividly remember the things I did with my mechanical/electro toys to see and try to understand how they worked, but that most of the other kids my age didn't: their objective was simply to use the toy as entertainment or make-believe-play or the like - not as an object of curiosity - and they weren't particularly interested in any explanation I'd have for them (it didn't help that I wouldn't have asked them if they wanted to hear my explanation in the first place though... heh) So for us, this digital-fake of a classic toy is an insult to our imagined younger-selves of the 21st century, but when I think about this ultra-modern toy from the perspective of someone just after something of solely nostalgia value - and a modern-day kid uninterested now (and shall most-likely forever-be uninterested) in how things work then indeed none of what we're griping about here matters - in fact it's the opposite: this 2010 remake is demonstrably tougher and more resilient to damage and wear than the mechanical original despite being superficially the same - given we're in the minority overall (...I think?) then this new design is objectively better as far as moral-utilitarianism is concerned. ...and it's not like Fischer-Price is selling this remake as a toy of interest to kids with a curiosity for things mechanical. They're not being totally dishonest.
- Jtsummers 5y agoIt's a tradeoff, though. The loss of explorability means that kids no longer have (with these newer toys) the same opportunity for exercising their curiosity that the older toys permitted. My sister never took our toys apart and reassembled them, that was all on me. With a toy like this one I would have (and probably did, with whatever equivalent I had) taken it apart and seen how the music box worked (the metal tines, the bumps on the record corresponding to notes, etc.). The new version removes that opportunity, taken or not. That is a loss.
- ummwhat 5y ago
- handrous 5y agoLots of great 70s and 80s toys that are still around are terrible. Super soaker? A joke, premium prices and way worse than squirt guns 1/4 the price, which are themselves not as good as early Super Soakers. Tank's not even removable which means it's basically not even the same sort of product at all—I'm sure the gaskets added too much to the production cost. Loopin' Louie? Motor's too weak, and it's lighter, so it doesn't work as well. They even managed to make Hungry Hungry Hippos suck. Rock 'em Sock 'em? Really bad compared to the original (you can find the original at flea markets sometimes—it's so much better, this isn't just nostalgia). The usual approach seems to be to cut vital features, shrink everything 10-30% (it's sometimes hard to tell if you don't have the original to compare it to, but it's really obvious when you do), and make all the plastic paper thin. I think it's part of most things that aren't computers getting worse over the last few decades. Shit would be double the price if they still "made it like they used to". Even fast-food pizza—Pizza Hut's in fact way worse than it was even in the mid 90s (they've had at least two major reformulations of the sauce, for one thing, getting worse each time), but if you find a different pizza place that makes pizza around 90s PH quality it'll be 50+% more expensive. But yeah, inflation's only low-single-digits percent a year. LOL sure.
- mustacheemperor 5y agoFrom what I can tell pump to charge water guns like the original super soaker simply don’t exist anymore, only pump to fire. I think you’re right that the gaskets/hardware necessary for the pressure tank add a lot of cost, and I wonder if there’s a liability factor as well. Nothing you can buy today can fire with nearly the same power as a super soaker since there’s no charged pressure tank. I had kind of assumed there’d be some small brand selling “classic” water gun designs but a quick google looks like most people only recommend vintage.
- underwater 5y agoOur kids were gifted "Guess Who" (a game which is problematic in a whole host of other ways). I was shocked that it was thin plastic and cardboard. The while thing felt disposable. I feel that this must be a strategy used on toys that were previously popular. They're not going to return to being the popular must-have item that people will pay a premium for, but there is residual value in the marketing campaign from the 80s. So the toy companies push the build quality as low as they can and milk the last good will from the brand by making it a cheap impulse purchase. To your larger point, there are still high quality toys around. You just avoid the big Toys R Us style stores and go to an independent or smaller toy story. Plan Toys and Green Toys stick out to me as two brands which felt consistently high quality and were widely available.