4 ms·
People that think housing prices can never be solved remind me of the infamous we ‘can’t drill our way to lower gas prices’ quote. Well.. it didn’t age well, f
by mensetmanusman 5y ago
People that think housing prices can never be solved remind me of the infamous we ‘can’t drill our way to lower gas prices’ quote.
Well.. it didn’t age well, fracking was invented in the context of a policy framework that only exists in the US, and now America has 7x lower gas prices than the EU/APEC and can’t export fast enough due to liquification capacity.
This is to say that there is likely a technology/policy innovation pathway to disrupt this current situation, but people aren’t thinking on a large enough scale yet… and investors, unfortunately, aren’t aligned to fix this because they own existing assets.
This means, the policy framework required to fix this tragedy of the commons looks something like making it profitable for investors to make money by 10x’ing the housing supply, 10xing the manufacturing speed, etc.
- acdha 5y agoDo you have a citation on that 7x claim? That’s significantly higher than the <2x for natural gas or <1x for crude oil differences shown on the economic data but it’s closer to what you’d see if you were comparing retail prices without noting the differences in tax rates.
- mensetmanusman 5y agohttps://asia.nikkei.com/Business/Energy/Why-is-Asia-paying-five-times-more-than-America-for-natural-gas https://asia.nikkei.com/Business/Energy/Why-is-Asia-paying-f... Note: I should have said 5x :$ thanks for asking about a citation!
- acdha 5y agoHere's the long term history and forecasts — it's definitely going to be cheaper but I wouldn't expect 5x to exist on a long-term, especially when you consider the impact of the switch to renewables against the cost of constructing new liquefaction plants: https://www.statista.com/statistics/252791/natural-gas-prices/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/252791/natural-gas-price...
- Tiktaalik 5y agoThe technology aspect is where this analogy breaks down. The dominant costs in housing are land values, construction costs, which are dominated by labour, and highly regulated (for good reason). There is little room here for innovations that would cut costs. There is presumably some inefficiencies and red tape in the building code, but so much of it is safety oriented, efficiency gains are probably limited. The obvious answer of course lies in building denser, though larger, denser buildings are more complex and costly to build. This is not to say that people aren't trying. People have been experimenting with prefab homes and such for decades, but it hasn't become any sort of game changer. If anything the costs of construction have been going dizzyingly upward along with the underlying land values. In any other industry someone would invent a new widget that makes processes faster and cheaper etc, but it's hard to see how someone makes home development cheaper through technological innovation.
- closeparen 5y agoIt's not a safety decision to reserve the overwhelming majority of land near population centers for large-lot single family detached housing. Deploying the 100-year-old technologies of the apartment building and the subway, where it is technologically and economically feasible to do so, would have this over with in a heartbeat.
- Tiktaalik 5y agoAbsolutely. We've had the tools in our hands since the 19th century. Technological innovation isn't what is required here, it's political will.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoA century from now we might be metaphorically drowning in excess energy (e.g. instances of negative energy costs) due for example to the TW Solar installs being planned. In such a scenario, there are wild things you could imagine from a materials and construction side that could plummet building costs. Additionally, if 2D agriculture is ever disrupted, we would recover a lot of land (ever driven across me NE?). Don’t forget, we can fit 2x the global population in a city the size of Texas with a typical city population density.