3 ms·
If there was a heinous criminal and they were using Signal, I wonder if law enforcement could get a warrant to push an update to Signal (or even OS push service
by rthomas6 5y ago
If there was a heinous criminal and they were using Signal, I wonder if law enforcement could get a warrant to push an update to Signal (or even OS push services) through the Play Store/App Store, just for that user. Wouldn't that work? It's the same legality and hoops to jump through as a wiretap, it seems to me, and it solves law enforcement's problem.
The more I think about it, the more I am convinced they could do this, but they would rather not because it's much harder, since it requires a special warrant with high evidence thresholds for each user. This reinforces the claim that what they really want is an ability to get any messaging data without a warrant, but they don't want to say so.
- surajrmal 5y agoThis is exactly why I don't put 100% trust in these apps that claim e2e encryption. It's trivial to update the app and destroy the contract if the company is willing and cooperating. You need hardware based security to make it truly impossible, like the case of unlocking and iPhone, although I honestly don't know how hardware based security could be leveraged for chat. Maybe in a similar way to how DRM works where the CPU never has access to the data and something else is drawing the pixels on the screen?