9 ms·
"They asked 554 mock jurors to read a story about a dog detecting the odor of drugs on a suspect’s car even though a later search turned up cash but no evidence
by ClumsyPilot 5y ago
"They asked 554 mock jurors to read a story about a dog detecting the odor of drugs on a suspect’s car even though a later search turned up cash but no evidence of illegal activity. Lit says the scenario was meant to sound preposterous. Nonetheless, two-thirds of jurors surveyed said they would have found the suspect guilty."
There is a real problem right there. Looks like you could get a conviction based on a fortune teller.
- biofox 5y agoTo me, it just highlights that there really ought to be some basic comprehension and reasoning test for jurors.
- MomoXenosaga 5y agoI disagree with the jury system but as I understand it American jurors are supposed to reflect society. If you only want smart people you leave it to the judge.
- dls2016 5y agoAbout those judges…
- dTal 5y agoIn fact jury selection is notorious for discarding potential jurors with intelligence, critical thinking, legal awareness, or domain expertise. Jurors reflect the part of society least qualified to be making these decisions. Attorneys do not want thinkers, they want predictable cogs in the court machine.
- parineum 5y ago> In fact jury selection is notorious for discarding potential jurors with intelligence, critical thinking, legal awareness, or domain expertise. Jurors reflect the part of society least qualified to be making these decisions. Jurors get dismissed based on whether or not one side feels they decide in their favor or not. That's it.
- Buttons840 5y agoWhen there's no agreement I suspect the less educated are favored though. I'd believe a juror getting dismissed for knowing statistics and being persuadable by logical arguments, before I'd believe a juror being dismissed for being in a demographic who favors police and emotional arguments.
- parineum 5y agoDepends on which side is moving to dismiss that particular juror and what finding in their favor would require.
- Nevermark 5y agoSo whoever thinks their case is weakest when viewed intelligently (i.e. ability to handle subtletly, nuance, complexity, rational over emotion, science, statistics) is going to need to get those intelligent people off the jury.
- oceanghost 5y agoJust mentioning FIJA can be enough to land you in jail.
- jjeaff 5y agoThat's not true. Jury nullification is legal (both talking about it and carrying it out), even if some judges and prosecutors wish it otherwise.
- oceanghost 5y agoI can't find any supporting documentation-- so take this as hearsay-- but I recall a man being arrested for handing out FIJA pamphlets in front of a courthouse at the Southwestern Justice Center in Riverside, CA.
- caymanjim 5y agoYou have the right to not have a jury. There are some downsides. It's harder to win an appeal; jury nullification is off the table; plenty of judges are biased or uninformed. Your lawyer can't manipulate a judge as easily as a jury. Still, if I had to defend myself against some emotionally charged claim whose defense relied on legal technicalities, I might prefer a bench trial to a bunch of idiots who couldn't get out of jury duty. If the potential jury of "my peers" were going to be biased against me for reasons of religion or race or culture, I'd be more inclined to let a judge decide.
- kevin_thibedeau 5y agoWhat we need is a right to a multi-judge tribunal.
- caymanjim 5y agoAgreed, although impractical due to a shortage of judges. You shouldn't have to rely on making it to an appeals panel to have your fate decided by more than the whims of a single person.
- reddog 5y ago> a bunch of idiots who couldn't get out of jury duty Maybe they are not idiots, just regular folks who take their civic duty seriously.
- caymanjim 5y agoYeah, that was too dismissive. I do think there's a problem with juries in that the pool of people is narrowed to those who both want to and are able to serve. Some jobs will pay employees who have jury duty, but many will not. Some people have backup caregivers for their dependents, but many don't. I'm not interested enough to look for statistics on it, but I would be surprised if juries aren't primarily composed of a narrow subset of social classes, like upper middle class professionals, retired people, the childless, and the unemployed, or some similar categories. It should be hard to get out of serving and jurors should be compensated in a way that eliminates the financial burden without becoming an incentive in itself.
- scotty79 5y agoWhat's worse is that judges are elected and it creates perverse incentives.
- kingcharles 5y agoWait... there are smart judges?!
- boomboomsubban 5y agoSo do you think it's completely impossible that you would be part of the 2/3rd that found the fake suspect guilty? I don't think basic comprehension or reasoning prevent you from falling for these kinds of arguments, and rather than try to limit possible jurors we should just bar unscientific evidence.
- giantg2 5y agoWho makes the rules for the aptitude? Who decides if it's scientific or not, and what the limit is (p .1 or .001, study design, etc)? The people running the system makes the rules. The general attitude is to treat the law enforcement side more favorably than the defendant, to the point that they are basically assumed guilty from the start.
- annoyingnoob 5y agoI sat in court once for 3 days as a potential juror. I was the last person that was not selected for the jury. There is a process like what you describe called voir dire. Both sides have an opportunity to interview jurors and can ask to eliminate some. In the case I watched there was a potential juror that had recently become a citizen and was very interested in being a juror, but she was also not a native English speaker and was clearly not following everything that was going on - both sides wanted her gone right away. You still get a jury of citizens from the local community, which is the point.
- zamadatix 5y agoThe process is a good one but it's not like what was described. Each side gets a chance to remove some jurors, not a chance to insure all jurors in the pool meet a criteria, and removal is based on how much the attorney thinks you'll hurt their chances not based on if you'll be able to accurately interpret the case. I was also the last person struck in a case involving IT once the prosecuting side found out I worked in IT. Looking at the case results the prosecution lost the case for reasons that would be apparent to anyone that understood how IT systems worked. To be clear I think the selection process is a good one (or at least I think it's better than other options I've heard) it's just not the same thing as the GP was proposing.
- annoyingnoob 5y agoI disagree, both sides have the opportunity to ask potential jurors a lot of questions. The answers to those questions can clearly illuminate someone's comprehension and reasoning - they definitely did in my experience. Now each side does not necessarily get all of the eliminations that they want but that is part of the process. The case I watched was a domestic violence case. Both sides were asking potential jurors about their knowledge of bruising and the way bruises change/develop over time. One of the potential jurors was an older Engineer from an aerospace company you've heard of, his answer included explaining that the most interesting problems that he deals with include how one handles the unknowns of a given project/situation. He gave a clear indication of his reasoning and thought process, the prosecution dropped him like a hot rock. Its not a jury of your peers if its a jury of only the sharpest or most educated people.
- clairity 5y agoyou’ve just failed your own test, since you don’t understand how and why a jury works. if you did, you’d comprehend that the better solution is expanding juries, not testing jurors. i’ll let you work out why that would be the case, and perhaps come up with an even better option as a result.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- refurb 5y agoSo I sat on a 6 week felony jury and had low expectations but was pleasantly surprised - fellow jurors took it very seriously, the judges instructions are clear and written at a layman’s level and the “presumption of innocence” dominated. Anecdotal but it really gave me faith that juries do a pretty good job.
- jrockway 5y agoI was on a grand jury and we were all a very cynical bunch. They presented a bunch of cases that boiled down to "person we don't like talked back to the police" and our jury refused to indict them. In one case, it was painfully obvious that the police officers testifying were flat-out lying. Their story changed from sentence to sentence. I think even the prosecutor thought that continuing to prosecute this particular case would be a career killer. Eventually the ADAs caught on that our group asked too many questions, and just carefully ran out the clock on our two week grand jury session. Cases we were halfway through hearing mysteriously disappeared. Apparently the other two juries that met during our two week cycle had to stay late every day, while we got dismissed early. It's one of those things where the system is designed to be good (23 randos get to decide if the cops are full of shit before you even get indicted, and you don't have to be very smart to see that sometimes the cops are full of shit), but The System turned it into something bad for no good reason. I guess if people aren't committing felonies, we don't need assistant district attorneys, and then the people that already do that job have their career progress reset. So they are forced to play into a broken system and make up very tenuous felonies for their own personal career gain. It's sad. Someone should do something about that. (I wonder if there should be an after-the-fact non-binding review board. Look at all the cases that were prosecuted over a given year, and just have a group of experts gut-check them. If a lot of cases seem like bullshit, dock the numbers for the DA's office so they suffer at election time.)
- Buttons840 5y agoThe fact that your joury went home early while others stayed late, is this information available to the defense?
- AlbertCory 5y agoTo me, it just highlights that if you've never served on a jury, your opinion is merely prejudice against those who are (presumably) less credentialed than you are.
- pfortuny 5y agoA jury of peers is a jury of citizens with no regard to their upbringing, education, rece, religion, or any other thing. Citizens.
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoI would really like to see a much bigger juror pool and results sorted by on zip code. I suspect I can do an ok job predicting relative conviction rates based on well known location and demographic based stereotypes of authoritarian tendencies and attitudes toward drug use.
- bumby 5y agoWould this change if instead of a drug charge it was a murder charge as in the article?
- HenryKissinger 5y agoPeople trust dogs too much. Dogs are friendly and make good pets and all but people need to draw a line.
- Ensorceled 5y ago"My dog would never bite. He just snarls and snaps like that when he's nervous." "My dog is a good dog at heart, but she's a rescue so you have to make allowances." "My dog is only growling because you are showing fear." "If you got bit, you must have done something to the dog. No dog bites without good reason." People "trust" dogs to a ludicrous degree, even dogs that clearly can't be trusted.
- kapp_in_life 5y agoWhenever someone says crap like this to me I feel sorry for the dog because its clearly poorly socialized and thats entirely the blame of the owner.
- Ensorceled 5y agoYep. Our weekly long run takes us through an off leash park, never had an issue with literally dozens of dogs every run. Dogs are all socialized; running around, chasing each other, running beside us, barking happily. All my unpleasant dog encounters have been with people who can't take their dog to the off leash park ...
- Taywee 5y agoThat's reductive. Dogs have a surprising degree of individuality, intelligence, and personality. There are dogs with anxiety disorders, psychological disorders, attention disorders, and other issues that aren't necessarily the blame of the owner (or even might be the fault of previous owners). Trying to reduce it to that is like blaming every problem behavior on somebody's parents. Dogs aren't simple machines.
- pxc 5y ago
- cm2187 5y agoThough that’s without the defence having a chance to tell the jury why they should disregard that fact. But in the end, I don’t think judges are doing any better. The only reason the justice system works is because the vast majority of cases aren’t very complicated and have physical evidence. Colombo-style crime mystery is fairly rare.
- lettergram 5y agoThis is why they have an entire field focusing on finding unbiased juries. They conduct interviews, etc
- vkou 5y agoUnbiased relative to the background level of nonsense that the general public believes? Or unbiased relative to some platonic ideal of a jury?
- pessimizer 5y agoThat's not why attorneys interview jurors. They're trying to find jurors who are biased but not biased enough to retrospectively throw the entire trial into question.
- taneq 5y agoIf you’d spent the last 40 years telling jurors that fortune tellers were the gold standard for detecting drug mules then yeah. The issue is that we’ve been sold the idea that drug dogs are effective, not that jurors are gullible.
- chmod600 5y agoAnd we believe that dogs are noble beyond any doubt. But maybe the dog just wants the handler to smile, take her home, and give her a steak?
- ClumsyPilot 5y ago"The issue is that we’ve been sold the idea that drug dogs are effective, not that jurors are gullible." But we know that they are gullible, they take police as a trustworthy source of information and assume police would not mislead them. Nimerous studies have shown that.
- giantg2 5y agoThat's because society, the courts, etc believe people are guilty before it is proven. And "reasonable" doubt is basically whatever they say it is, which is often unreasonable. Innocent until proven guilty is a cruel joke.
- kingcharles 5y agoOn the flip side of this, which you don't hear about very often, during my eight years locked up I saw a decent number of jury trials where the jury aquitted a clearly very, very guilty defendant. So, I would always go with a jury trial even if you are horribly guilty as you might as well just roll the dice on the jury verdict. One example: A guy was thrown down onto the grass in front of his house by the cops during a drug arrest. When they picked him up a gun was lying on the grass under him. He told me it fell out of the waistband of his pants. At trial his lawyer argued that the gun was already randomly lying on the ground when the police threw him down. The jury acquitted him of the gun possession charge.
- ClumsyPilot 5y ago"At trial his lawyer argued that the gun was already randomly lying on the ground when the police threw him down. The jury acquitted him" Blackstone's ratio is the commonly accepted benchmark: "It is better that ten guilty persons escape than that one innocent suffer" It's job of the prosecution to make sure their proof is "beyond reasonable doubt", which is obviously in the eye of the beholder.