3 ms·
There is a huge difference between a dog finding a body (material evidence independent of the dog's behavioral characteristics) and a dog handler "reading" his
by inglor_cz 5y ago
There is a huge difference between a dog finding a body (material evidence independent of the dog's behavioral characteristics) and a dog handler "reading" his dog's behavior and making various predictions out of it. The latter should absolutely not have any value in court.
And to think that we laugh at the Romans for predicting future from the flight of birds (augury) and animal liver (haruspexy)...
- agys 5y agoThank you for “augury”! I looked up the etymology in Italian for auguri and it derives from the flight of birds. “Tanti auguri“ means “best wishes“, on the contrary “sciagura” (same root as “auguri”) means “misfortune“.
- DaiPlusPlus 5y ago> predicting future from the flight of birds Well, to be fair, we can - to the extent that when I see birds fly-off from my back-garden I know it's about to rain...
- ashtonkem 5y agoAnd to be fair, if you’re a subsistance farmer the ability to predict rain and other weather events is a huge percentage of the future you care about. Augury would be able to predict a decent bit of the important future for those people.