7 ms·
I'm sorry, but this is sheer silliness. A "country" doesn't "decide" to make an asset class appreciate or depreciate. It's always been driven by supply and dema
by noduerme 5y ago
I'm sorry, but this is sheer silliness. A "country" doesn't "decide" to make an asset class appreciate or depreciate. It's always been driven by supply and demand.
If the population of this country stopped growing and started shrinking, a lot of real estate would be freed up. Demand for housing in the densest cities would drop, and it would be cheaper to live.
Real estate prices have gone up for the last hundred years because there are more people. This is why it has been an effective and predictable model for businesses like car dealerships to always locate on the outskirts of cities and wait for the city to come to them, sell the land and move further out.
There isn't anything nefarious or even strange about it. It's a natural result of population growth and increasing demand that consistently (so far) outpaces supply. Nor is it inevitable; look at China. Tons of empty apartments, cheap bordering on free to live in. That's what happens when supply outstrips demand.
- watwut 5y agoIt is possible to build new houses. It is possible to scratch zoning policies that prevents building more houses in one area. Housing does not have to be fixed amount resource.
- yobbo 5y ago> by supply and demand. The relevant unit of supply/demand here is mortgages, which are indeed controlled by government policies.
- noduerme 5y agoInterest rates act as an incentive or disincentive, but ultimately a government can't forever lend infinite credit to a population that doesn't pay its debts. America has certainly tried to extend her credit infinitely, and our parents and their parents got the best of that, but ultimately our credit as a country is tapering off. Are you suggesting credit should be loosened again so you don't need 20% down to buy a property?
- beebmam 5y agoCitations needed for basically every sentence in this comment please
- GhettoComputers 5y agoThey raise property taxes and tell you your house is worth more to justify it. How is that not manipulative?
- noduerme 5y agoOh hey, they raised mine by almost 5% this year. But it makes plenty of sense because the purchasing power of a dollar has clearly declined by at least 10% in the same span of time. So, every purchase you make with fiat money in a fiat economy is some form of arbitrage. You're trying to hold value against inflation. Yeah, they raised my taxes but in doing so they invented $25k in value for my house. That's great since I'm going to need that to buy vegetables. In the long run, it doesn't matter. Nothing of value has actually been gained or lost. I raise my hourly rate with inflation.
- DeathArrow 5y ago>I raise my hourly rate with inflation. You are lucky that you are able to do so.
- noduerme 5y agoSetting your own price. It's the future. I've been living in it since 1998. I still check pay scales for various skill sets regularly to make sure I'm not totally out of whack with them.
- missedthecue 5y agoAnyone can set their own price for how much they sell their labor. There is no guarantee that they will find a willing buyer at any price.
- GhettoComputers 5y agoThis would be securities fraud if you applied it to any other asset. You’d be jailed if you did this.
- DeathArrow 5y ago>A "country" doesn't "decide" to make an asset class appreciate or depreciate. In communist regimes they did exactly this.
- odiroot 5y agoAnd Central/Eastern Europe is still hurting today because of policies like this.
- xg15 5y agoBecause of policies like this? Please explain.
- ChuckNorris89 5y agoHurting how? The real estate market in Easter Europe is better than in Western Europe as the communist governments built many high density housing in the cities so reas estate remains affordable for young people with skilled jobs even today. Compare that to Germany, Netherlands, Switzerland and you can't afford anything as a young professional without a FAANG job or help from parents and a 30 year bank loan. Eastern Europe is hurting in many ways due to corruption and political incompetence but the real estate market remains mostly affordable compared to the west.
- inglor_cz 5y agoThe Czech Republic is AFAIK the worst EU country when it comes to the ratio of real estate price to net income. It wasn't that bad five or six years ago, but now we are screwed beyond belief. Edit: and no, it is not just the tourist hotspots like Prague, even though AirBnB contributed to the situation, especially in the rental market. Prices are crazy everywhere, including rust belt cities that have been losing population for a generation.
- jhgb 5y agoI'm just glad today that our family managed to purchase a three-story house from the municipal government for the equivalent of $US6K (!) about twenty years ago. In retrospect probably one of the best investments anyone could have ever made at that time. North Bohemia, but still...
- doubleunplussed 5y agoStrange to use China's oversupply as a comparison when it too is the result of intentional government action. Governments can cause oversupply, governments can cause undersupply. Bet you can think of plenty of examples without my help of government policy resulting in supply for some goods decreasing or increasing relative to demand. Governments can do a lot. Like, they can pretty much dictate what you're allowed to make, how much they're gonna tax you on profits from making something, who you're allowed to sell it to - they can absolutely decide to cause an asset to appreciate.
- noduerme 5y agoYeah - sure. But basically every government intervention leads to some abominable result. Politicians get traction by promising to fix markets, then get rich by twisting them for their own benefit. China distorted the real estate market to the degree that they overbuilt. The theory here is that America has underbuilt due to local regulations? Okay, but if that's the case I don't think the answer is more government intervention.
- heurisko 5y ago> But basically every government intervention leads to some abominable result. Some interventions do, some don't. Without environmental legislation, for example, companies would export their negative externalities, e.g. pumping sewage into water systems, onto the rest of us. Saying that, however, there have been some bad housing policies in the UK, for example, "Help to Buy" which could just as easily be called "Help to Sell".
- noduerme 5y agoThat's true. But that's of a different category. Governments should regulate the public sphere and public resources. That benefits individuals. Who in a democracy ostensibly are the ones who vote in the government. Notably, authoritarian governments which don't respect individuals don't spend much time on environmental regulation either. Market manipulation or redistribution of individual (not corporate) wealth by governments -- as opposed to regulation -- is always a bad idea because (a) the people making those calls from within the government are getting rich by doing so, directly siphoning wealth from the citizenry by exercising inside knowledge and the power to tweak a market, and (b) those actions directly harm the golden goose that produces the economic uplift the government needs to survive - that is, the individual in the middle class.
- killtimeatwork 5y ago> A "country" doesn't "decide" to make an asset class appreciate or depreciate. It's always been driven by supply and demand. But it does. The supply is partially driven by speculators who bet on the prices continuing to grow. Currently, a lot of people are buying more expensive houses than they need because "house is a good investment". This (the speculators) can be easily stopped with a policy - e.g. tax heavily all profits from real estate sales, incl. primary residences. If taxes make it next to impossible to profit on increase of house value (the profit goes to treasury and not to seller), then the market would significantly cool down. The fact that we (for example) tax heavily income from work, but not from real estate speculation, is a CHOICE.
- aww_dang 5y agoTaxation is one angle to consider, but it isn't it an inadequate band-aid for the wounds caused by easy money, artificially low interest rates and the political incentives of the US's central banking system? Look at the root causes of asset price inflation.
- dd36 5y agoThe root cause is long-term low interest rates but now that SFR is an asset class, the interest rate cycle won’t bring back the $150k home without a major crash that harms everyone. Tax policy that punishes large investors can help things land without a crash.
- supperburg 5y agoIf you tax the whole of the delta then real estate development would scrape to a halt. So that obviously won’t work.
- killtimeatwork 5y agoIt won't be affected at all, only resales (not initial sales) would be taxed.
- 5y ago
- raesene9 5y agoCountries can easily affect the market in this case and there are incentives to do so. Things like zoning laws, property taxes, taxes on investing in property all affect overall prices, it's never going to be pure supply and demand. For example if a region/country wants to keep prices down, heavily tax second/third/fourth homes. Or provide tax incentives to new builds. Then there's interest rates, one of the reasons that property prices in many countries are increasing is that the interest rates are low, so people looking to invest can't get a good return on their investment in "traditional" locations, so they turn to buying property to rent out.
- saiya-jin 5y agoYou are wrong, look what ie France is doing with its housing market. No bubbles since it highly demotivates speculations and corporate mega-investments that move markets. There are tons of tools any state has to motivate or demotivate markets. Taxes, rules on primary, secondary and investment residence ownership, same goes for rents etc. I tend to see a clear pattern here, just like in other topics - folks who are profiting from current situation by already owning see nothing wrong - in contrary, market forces in effect etc. The more the better. The rest not so much, ie younger generation thrown in the world where they probably will never own their residence, which can be pretty infuriating compared t situation say 20 years ago. There aren't that many more people to explain this. But the move to consider housing more and more as a speculative investment rather than commodity is definitely out there, everywhere.
- noduerme 5y ago20 years ago I was the younger generation and hearing how we were the first generation who would have it worse than our parents, would never have a path to home ownership, and we should be so enraged because the "dream" had been stolen from us. I don't hear a lot of people (like me) defending the fact that it takes a couple decades of work to own a home, and that that's OK and how it should be. I just hear a volume boost on the angry 21-year-old I used to be when I thought I would be deprived of those things. They'll get there. Their parents' generation all have houses and are the richest in history, and are the ones who've driven prices up to inconceivable levels. A lot of this complaining comes from people who've never even rented a room.
- pksebben 5y agoI'm in my mid-30s, and I find this a little bit offensive. There is absolutely a difference in the action potential I need to buy a house vs what my parents dealt with - this is patently not just twentysomethings being upset.
- dd36 5y agoYeah, I don’t think they’ve done much research on historical pricing vs. income.
- eevilspock 5y agoSee Georgism[1], Geolibertarianism[2], Are you a Real Libertarian, or a ROYAL Libertarian?[3] and Vulgar libertarianism[4]. --- [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Georgism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Georgism [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geolibertarianism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geolibertarianism [3] https://geolib.com/essays/sullivan.dan/royallib.html https://geolib.com/essays/sullivan.dan/royallib.html, and prior HN discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7076632 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7076632 [4] https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Vulgar_libertarianism https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Vulgar_libertarianism
- sumedh 5y ago> A "country" doesn't "decide" to make an asset class appreciate or depreciate. Look up negative gearing in Australia
- noduerme 5y agoInteresting. But it's just a form of writing off a loss. It seems like a stupid move, and at the end of the day I'm not sure how it hurts renters since the whole idea is to offer the rental at a loss to get the tax credits (?) Also historically, Australia has had a lot of bizarre policies of paying people just to go occupy some empty piece of dirt or live in the bush, so I'm wondering if that's got something to do with advantaging this type of a write-off. In any case, you have to realize money will go somewhere. It will go into a bank vault or it will go into a house, or it will go into the stock market; people want a return on investment. If you outright make it onerous and expensive for the middle class to invest in real estate, the only real estate investors will then be trusts and speculators. This is a simple fact any time a government goes after small land holders.
- sumedh 5y agoYour original point was that a country doesn't "decide" to make an asset class appreciate or depreciate. I just gave you an example that the country can decide it can make an asset appreciate. In Australia's example it can make investors take more risks. Did you also forget that the US govt created Fannie_Mae so that banks could issue more home loans, guess what happens when you issue more loans to more people, house prices go up.
- mchaver 5y ago> If the population of this country stopped growing and started shrinking, a lot of real estate would be freed up. Demand for housing in the densest cities would drop, and it would be cheaper to live. Without a policy to disincentive it, couldn't large asset holders purchase freed up real estate and artificially control the supply?
- seoaeu 5y agoNot profitably. Renting out apartments is profitable, but paying property tax and maintenance costs on a bunch of housing that you hold empty isn't. And to artificially control the supply the housing needs to be empty. (This is actually one way we know this isn't happening at a large scale right now: vacancies are at historic lows) Buying up a bunch of real estate to drive up the price and sell for a profit also doesn't work. For the same reason that a pump-and-dump scheme needs other bag holders: when you start selling the price will drop too quickly
- mchaver 5y ago> paying property tax Exactly, this is point I was trying to make. Policy can have an effect on the market. It is more than just supply and demand like noduerme was suggesting. An example is London. There is a large number of empty housing owned by non-residents because they can avoid a lot of taxes and its a good place to park money. If there wasn't preferential treatment for non-UK residents then the housing market there would look a bit different. Also buying up housing assets could be a long term strategy that would benefit the owners in ways short term would not (change of policy 10 years later, increased population because of migration laws, etc.)
- seoaeu 5y agoThe apartment vacancy rate in London is apparently only 3.4% [0] right now! That's not even the 4.5-6% rate that it takes to cause rents to stop growing. I would hardly consider that a large number of empty housing. [0]: https://lfpress.com/news/local-news/london-apartment-vacancy-rate-hits-eight-year-high-of-3-4-per-cent https://lfpress.com/news/local-news/london-apartment-vacancy...