3 ms·
That's just insane. Sites and apps I build these days usually include FontAwesome and/or another icon library, frequently along with a custom dingbat font for t
by noduerme 5y ago
That's just insane. Sites and apps I build these days usually include FontAwesome and/or another icon library, frequently along with a custom dingbat font for the company's unique logos and iconography (we bundle all relevant vector art as a font). Then you have primary and secondary brand fonts, along with sometimes readability fonts. Not to mention iframed forms coming off credit card gateways. I have no idea how a proposal like this could be implemented, but it definitely would destroy most modern layouts.
- tomthe 5y agoI could live with that and I think many users would agree.
- noduerme 5y agoLive with a 2 font maximum and popups every time a site chose to load another font? It would break every icon on the web. You'd either only load the icons or only load the text fonts. If you want to avoid fingerprinting, and actually think this method remotely works, by all means block those requests. If you actually care about privacy a better place to start would be the fact that chrome logs you in on the browser level whenever you login to anything with a Google password. Some random fingerprinting is not worth shutting down all design for. On that idea we should just go back to dialup because everything is too dangerous for idiots to handle.
- onion2k 5y agoIf you actually care about privacy a better place to start would be the fact that chrome logs you in on the browser level whenever you login to anything with a Google password. Google is not the only company that has no respect for privacy. Privacy protection needs to go further, and stop privacy invasion completely. There is a reasonable balance to strike between privacy, design and usability though. That's why I said 2 or 3 fonts. Maybe 4 at a push. If a site is using more than that then either the developers aren't very good, or the designers aren't very good, or it's trying to attack the user's privacy. Whichever one it is, it should be stopped.
- GhettoComputers 5y agoI hate fancy designed sites that take forever to load, or need to be refreshed to work. If you’re really calling everyone an idiot who doesn’t like your bloated site design, re-examine why is it genius to have bloated sites like yours?
- playpause 5y agoThey might agree in principle, but they’d be pretty pissed off when nothing works when the open their web browser. The golden rule in web standards development is “don’t break the web”, ie you can’t just recklessly change web platform features, you have to do it thoughtfully and carefully to avoid breaking existing websites. It’s not a perfect rule, there are exceptions where the breakage is tiny and the benefit is huge, but what you’re proposing is huge destruction and would not make it past the first stage of consideration.
- beagle3 5y agoWhat’s the benefit of including vector art as font rather than SVG? How do you do multiple colors in fonts?
- marginalia_nu 5y agoWhy can't you design sites that degrades gracefully? Keep in mind that font loading in low-bandwidth areas can be atrociously slow. You may have to wait minutes before all the assets have loaded. Vanilla HTML has no such accessibility or compatibility problems and can be viewed in all browsers on any network. Whatever issues your sites have are issues you have added to them. I know you're thinking "well I don't see any of that in my analytics so this seems unlikely". Consider then that your analytics needs to actually load before the visitor bounces for them to show up in the statistics.
- hansel_der 5y agopainfully true thou it will be argued that it is a minority that is affected and it makes little economic sense to care.
- marginalia_nu 5y agoAre the majority affluent city-dwellers? Maybe in Luxembourg this is true, but in many parts of the world it just isn't. But you get a sort of selection bias. Out of the people with money to buy the tech that can keep up with these sites and the network speeds to use these sites, out of those people, most people have modern tech and good metropolitan network access.