3 ms·
> The United States has been a stable democracy with absolute freedom of speech for two and a half centuries. The United States has had plenty of limits on fre
by krapp 5y ago
> The United States has been a stable democracy with absolute freedom of speech for two and a half centuries.
The United States has had plenty of limits on free speech throughout its history. Letting Nazis or the KKK or whomever speak their mind and publish their literature doesn't mean we have absolute freedom of speech, just fewer restrictions on speech than elsewhere.
And it's worth pointing out that the paradox of tolerance was written as a reaction to Nazi Germany. The Nazis were the kind of intolerant group that paradox was arguing shouldn't be tolerated, not because of their speech alone, but because of their willingness to use violence, and refusal to tolerate any speech but their own.
If one side incites violence with their speech and the other side merely tolerates them for the sake of free speech the violent side wins. That was the relevant lesson of Nazism, not that the Nazis never would taken power in a Germany that allowed them to speak and publish freely, because they did.
This is why the KKK is allowed to march, but not allowed to make terrorist threats or incite violence (which they would be, if the US had absolute free speech,) because even tolerating the speech of scoundrels has to have a limit.
- DeathArrow 5y agoCommunist regimes made orders of magnitude more victims and forbid free speech for much longer for much more people than nazis ever dreamed of. And yet all the countries who forbid and condemn nazi speech tolerates the communist speech. Source: I spent part of my childhood in a communist country.
- trasz 5y agoIt's equally true if you s/Communist regimes/Church/g.
- jokethrowaway 5y agoTrue, if you're into medieval history. I don't think the Church has any hope to regain the power they once had. These days my biggest fears are communist regimes (like China) and Islam spreading in Europe (we already have some courts partially applying Sharia laws in the UK).
- trasz 5y agoChurch was the Evil Empire long after medieval - in some countries, like Poland, people are still being denied reproductive rights because of catholic ideology. Islamic extremism is a marginal problem compared to this - there are no places in Europe where people's rights would be limited because of Sharia.