2 ms·
> That only makes sense if the shield-building adversary is some sort of psychopath who wants to see you dead. Or if they may become a psychopath who wants to
by vkou 5y ago
> That only makes sense if the shield-building adversary is some sort of psychopath who wants to see you dead.
Or if they may become a psychopath who wants to see you dead - in the name of self-defense, of course. Or if they think that you are a psychopath who wants to see them dead. Or if they think you may become a psychopath who wants to see them dead.
It's difficult to assure your counterparty that you will never behave in a psychotic manner in the future - or to assure yourself that they will not.
If you're not planning on starting a nuclear war, and you assume that your adversary isn't going to, either, why do you need a missile shield, anyways? MAD is a necessary and sufficient deterrent. If you're building a shield, you are very conspicuously betting that at least one of these two assumptions is no longer true...
- joconde 5y ago> Or if they may become a psychopath who wants to see you dead - in the name of self-defense, of course. Or if they think that you are a psychopath who wants to see them dead. Or if they think you may become a psychopath who wants to see them dead. These assumptions better be strongly supported by evidence, if one's going to decide to get their country annihilated by attempting a first strike. Striking first won't protect the country from a hypothetical future attack, it will just make it happen now. I don't really see a sane reason to do it if the threat isn't considered immediate.