4 ms·
The supposed paradoxical increase of this effect with increasing wealth has been replicated fairly often with the only real opposition I’ve noticed being that s
by renewiltord 5y ago
The supposed paradoxical increase of this effect with increasing wealth has been replicated fairly often with the only real opposition I’ve noticed being that sociocultural incentives dominate.
That is, if you aren’t going to starve, the most important thing is what other people think. The closer to starving you get the less important that becomes.
Anyway, that’s the hypothesis explaining the difference. What research out there explores that hypothesis? Otherwise, this seems like just more of the same revealing that there are differences in participation.
- noptd 5y ago>That is, if you aren’t going to starve, the most important thing is what other people think. This seems like too strong of a claim to make without any supporting evidence.
- shadowgovt 5y agoThe study authors draw a conclusion that wealth allows people to choose work that more reflects their intrinsic interest. To my mind, that's a claim at least as worthy of skepticism as the claim that wealthy people choose social-status-enhancing work (which differs based on gender due to cultural norms).
- snek_case 5y ago>That is, if you aren’t going to starve, the most important thing is what other people think. IMO that hypothesis is politically biased. It implies that men/women in wealthier societies are trying harder to conform to gender norms. Blames societal norms for the difference. The simpler and less dehumanizing alternative is that people in wealthier countries are more free to live life however they want. There are less constraints.
- renewiltord 5y agoWell, then, that’s on me for misrepresenting it. Let’s try again. You can see desire to comply with gender norms as a constant X and starvation risk Y as a variable. Appropriately scale each and measure X-Y. That can go positive or negative depending on Y without X varying at all. I want to eliminate this explanation as significantly causative. Where would I find evidence for that?
- jjk166 5y agoYou're still making the assumption that the thing competing with starvation is compliance with gender norms (or to be more general, social norms). As a thought experiment, consider being trapped on a desert island where the only thing edible were termites. My starvation risk is high, so I will eat the termites. Eventually I get back to civilization and my starvation risk is much lower, and I no longer choose to eat termites. Is this because A) the social norms which dictate that I shouldn't eat termites are now more important to me, or B) I prefer other foods to termites? It is perfectly reasonable that under differing circumstances the weights we will give different factors in decision making vary, but that does not on its own tell us what those factors actually are.
- renewiltord 5y agoI think I must be misspeaking quite a bit because I am not making any claims here. I am constructing a hypothesis and I want it falsified. The fact that it is falsifiable is a feature not a bug. The possibility of this not being the cause isn’t interesting. That is by construction. I want to see evidence of what is actually the case. I want to know what the factors are. And by what weight in aggregate. I am not alleging that they have any specific value.
- shadowgovt 5y agoYour example hits the nail on the head, because there are cultures in the world where people would prefer termites to, say, Pop-Tarts if they were more habituated at a young age to eating termites. We are extremely social creatures, and socialization happens starting from infancy. So the issue is that without more information, we actually can't tell whether our hypothetical desert island survivor has gone off the termites upon returning to (euro-centric) civilization because they actually don't much care for them or because you can't order them at any of the fine dining establishments in town. I mean, hell, without invoking a desert island... I know people in the United States who swear by the taste of squirrel meat and you generally won't find them eating it at the restaurants in cities.
- jjk166 5y ago
- shadowgovt 5y ago> The simpler and less dehumanizing alternative Occam's razor is great, but it's probably not a reasonable assumption to make on a system as fundamentally complicated as human behavior. How would we control for the possibility that as wealth increases, the dominant effect in a person's life isn't social status (which could be enhanced by gender-norm conformity)?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]