5 ms·
The Internet Archive transforms access to books in a digital world
- gigel82 5y agoArchive.org is great; especially their archive of abandonware old games (MS-DOS, older console ROMs), some of which can be played online. But don't find yourself actually needing to get in touch with a human there. I have a friend that inadvertently doxxed themself on a website they own; they removed the pages, added a robots.txt to disallow crawling and is trying for months to reach someone over there to just get that data removed from The Wayback Machine, to no avail. Perhaps archive.org doesn't have a lot of staff or they simply don't care but I imagine these kinds of things happen often enough that they should at least have an automated process in place (and continuing to crawl a website that specifically forbids it through the standard robots.txt is a bit icky).
- EastOfTruth 5y agoIf it was easy to remove content, there would be a lot less content. And that's usually a good thing that it isn't easy.
- KarlKemp 5y agoThey very clearly don’t care about such matter. Or, more accurately, they specifically want to harm people who have committed the great sin of accidentally posting something. Opinions and practices are very different across different projects in the space. Wikipedia and WP commons, for example, have detailed policies for personal data. Commons is so careful about copyright, it sometimes can’t host a file that lots of commercial publishers freely use, such as (photos of) ads or logos that lack explicit licenses. Both approaches have their pros and cons. I can’t help but think both projects would be improved by moving a bit into the direction of the other.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- d1lanka 5y ago> Archive.org is great; especially their archive of abandonware old games (MS-DOS, older console ROMs), some of which can be played online. See: https://archive.org/details/softwarelibrary_msdos_games https://archive.org/details/softwarelibrary_msdos_games > But don't find yourself actually needing to get in touch with a human there. I have a friend that inadvertently doxxed themself on a website they own; they removed the pages, added a robots.txt to disallow crawling and is trying for months to reach someone over there to just get that data removed from The Wayback Machine, to no avail. That sucks. I've always been able to get a hold of a human the few times I emailed them - but nothing due to something like this. > Perhaps archive.org doesn't have a lot of staff or they simply don't care but I imagine these kinds of things happen often enough that they should at least have an automated process in place (and continuing to crawl a website that specifically forbids it through the standard robots.txt is a bit icky). Also, FYI they stopped honoring robots.txt directives: https://teleread.org/2017/04/24/the-internet-archive-will-soon-stop-honoring-robots-txt-files/ https://teleread.org/2017/04/24/the-internet-archive-will-so... — so if you're a webmaster that would like to exclude your website from the internet archive, you'll have to email them directly to make that request.
- LocalH 5y ago>Also, FYI they stopped honoring robots.txt directives: https://teleread.org/2017/04/24/the-internet-archive-will-so https://teleread.org/2017/04/24/the-internet-archive-will-so... — so if you're a webmaster that would like to exclude your website from the internet archive, you'll have to email them directly to make that request. Good. It shouldn't be as simple as "put a robots.txt on your domain" to erase the entire publicly archived history of any sites ever hosted under that domain. This happened a lot when domains would expire.
- charcircuit 5y agoArchive.org is supposed to be an archive. Unlisting data (they don't delete stuff) goes entirely against the ideao of archiving the internet. It's because of people like him that you have to archive archive.org itself which is stupid.
- gigel82 5y agoAgree in principle, but surely there are exceptions. In my friend's case they reused nicknames across hobbies and projects; potentially dangerous people got upset over whatever reason and now they're concerned a connection will be made to that personal data they once posted (including home address). Surprisingly, both Google and Bing removed the data within 1 week of making the request.
- atty 5y agoIs your stance that the archive should continue to list information that can put someone’s life in imminent danger (the address of someone receiving death threats, for instance)? I would find it hard to defend such a position.
- charcircuit 5y agoYes they should. Information should be free. I don't like all these restrictions trying to lock it down. Anyways, someone's address is public information.
- LocalH 5y agoAwaiting to see how you handle the situation if your personal details are ever doxxed.
- dredmorbius 5y agoI've had excellent results in getting responses from info@archive.org.
- Causality1 5y ago(and continuing to crawl a website that specifically forbids it through the standard robots.txt is a bit icky). I find the idea you, in control of a server, can send someone data and then demand they erase it a bit ridiculous. If you want to control distribution then control it. Require a login to access any data you don't intend to be public.
- dr_dshiv 5y agoThank god for organizations like IA and EFF. We are so lucky. Consider donating!
- okprod 5y agoThey and everyone else should also be grateful for the FSF.
- aero-glide2 5y agoI think libgen deserves even more respect!
- base3 5y agoWhen a friend was doxxed, I helped him get the problematic material excluded from current Internet Archive results. It was easier than I had anticipated. The volunteers who helped me were intelligent and humane. Keep in mind that at its core Internet Archive is a library that preserves and shares information. My friend was happy to have his personal information temporarily suppressed, but didn't try to change the permanent record. History will be history. He loves and cherishes libraries and has no objection to future researchers seeing his personal information 50 years from now. It's a great institution that we should protect and cherish.
- Causality1 5y agoWithin that context, the Archive has made careful efforts to ensure its uses are lawful. Except for that bit where somebody in power at the IA decided to ruin the future of CDL by declaring a free-for-all during the pandemic. I still want to know who it was that made a decision so mind-bendingly idiotic it put the very existence of the Internet Archive itself at risk. Of course our current copyright laws are stupid! That doesn't mean you as an organization with twenty million dollars in yearly revenue get to just ignore them and trust that having the moral high ground will protect you from the lawyers of an entire industry.
- unityByFreedom 5y ago> Except for that bit where somebody in power at the IA decided to ruin the future of CDL by declaring a free-for-all during the pandemic. You beat me to this comment. No wonder they are now being sued. That decision may send them the way of Google Books. I hope it doesn't. Maybe in twenty or forty years we will see an accepted library like Spotify's arrival 15 years after Napster. Archive didn't even have the moral high ground. Authors and publishers deserve to be remunerated for their effort and controlled lending supports that. When that's off the table you're just like libgen.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jjcon 5y agoAgreed, I often agree with EFF and I love what IA does typically but this was a terrible terrible decision. IMO even in a world with improved copyright laws the extent of what they did shouldnt even be allowed.
- jawns 5y agoI'm an author who supports CDL, and I couldn't agree more. What surprised me the most was how many people strongly defended the IA's actions. In their heads, the IA could do no wrong. Or they failed to grasp the illogic of "public libraries are closed, so we're going to pretend we own their books and lend them out." Even here on HN, there were some people who refused to acknowledge that what the IA did was both unfair to copyright holders and a poor strategy for trying to uphold CDL over the long term.
- kmeisthax 5y agoThis is quite possibly the weakest fair use argument imaginable. Actually, I take this one step further: this is not a fair use argument, it's a copyright reform argument; and I doubt a court is going to give you the reform you want. The CDL program rests on a shaky legal theory that's already proven wrong by Capitol Records v. ReDigi. That is, it seeks to argue that as long as we have some DRM technology that lets us recreate the circumstances of something protected by first sale or copyright exhaustion (which, btw, is separate from Fair Use), then we should have first sale rights. I like the spirit of this argument, but it will not persuade a court; because the current law doesn't work this way. First sale works specifically because the act of physical resale does not create a copy and does not tread upon the copyright monopoly even a little. Copying something and then destroying the original (as in ReDigi) does. If you want digital first sale you have to ask Congress for that.
- veltas 5y agoI keep seeing the word 'democratizing' used online applied to stuff where I don't understand its relevance. Surely Internet Archive is not 'democratic', but also why would that matter? Do we all need a vote on what they do? It feels like some kind of buzzword.
- Emma_Goldman 5y ago'Demos' means the common people. IA is democratising because it distributes knowledge to anyone and everyone with internet access, instead of just the rich or the global minority with access to major libraries.