3 ms·
My point is, saying "be disruptive" is about as valuable as saying "just win!" I agree it's not the most prescriptive advice, but it's not the same as "just wi
by erikpukinskis 15y ago
My point is, saying "be disruptive" is about as valuable as saying "just win!"
I agree it's not the most prescriptive advice, but it's not the same as "just win!". The term "disruptive technology" was coined by Clayton Christensen, who has written several books on the topic. In The Innovator's Dilemma he describes several disruptions in many industries in great detail.
The scenarios he describes (which the OP is referencing by using the term "disruptive") are not generic "here's a company who won!" situations. They are very specific. Namely, a competitor introduced a new technology that was inferior to established technologies in many important ways, but which was vastly superior in at least one. And importantly, it was superior in a way that could not be "backported" to the mainstream technology.
We talk about defensibility here sometimes, and each of these new technologies has a clear defensibility strategy.
Every Google Doc has a URL your coworker can click in an email, and be immediately editing the document, on any computer, whether or not they've paid for Office. That is a feature that will never be added to Office. It can't be added to office.
Telling Google (or HP, or Amazon) to be disruptive is telling them to focus on finding features that Apple won't or can't add to the iPad, and building your products around those.
That's a hell of a lot more to go on than "just win".
- joebadmo 15y agoAnd Innovator's Dilemma was written like fifteen years ago. I'm pretty sure anyone at any position of authority understands the concept. That's not what stops large companies from being disruptive. It's fear, bureaucracy, risk aversion, any number of things. But it's not because they've never heard of disruption before. So, I stand by my point that the value proposition for the sentiment "be disruptive" is equal to that of "just win," namely: zero.