2 ms·
I think it's great to dig into this stuff, but I disagree with almost everything in this article. A 4 pixel grid is too fine to serve the purpose of a grid. I
by erikpukinskis 15y ago
I think it's great to dig into this stuff, but I disagree with almost everything in this article.
A 4 pixel grid is too fine to serve the purpose of a grid. I mean, you could do a 1 pixel grid, and everything would line up, but what's the sense in that? Grids are only visually meaningful when the base unit is a perceptible size.
The author is striving for harmony, but grids are only one source it. The left margin in one of Apple's preference fields is about one typographic space wide. It's good horizontal rhythm when considered as part of the text element. A good designer knows when to treat space as part of the text, and when to treat it as part of the layout.
The author's preference fields have a 16 pixel wide margin, which has a nice numerological relationship with other elements, but has no relationship with the text at all.
The resulting designs have a kind of twisted harmony that you can get by looking at it and thinking about the multiples of 4 pixels throughout the interface, but they lack any real visual harmony to my eye.
It would be convenient if design were as simple as snapping everything to some simple grid. For better or worse, things are much more complicated than that. And Apple has done much more work to establish a complex harmony across many visual properties than the OP.
- gfodor 15y agoI think you've nailed it. Apple's focus on typography, spacing, and proportion puts it directly at odds with the notion that a UI can always be fit snugly into a fixed width grid pattern.