3 ms·
Well I don’t think he’s saying it would fail in America because the US is leading, but actually because it’s behind in health. Either way such generalized comme
by aksss 5y ago
Well I don’t think he’s saying it would fail in America because the US is leading, but actually because it’s behind in health. Either way such generalized comments are always off target because the US is a hugely large and varied place (in climate, population, terrain, design, etc). It’s hard to say anything categorically will or will not work across the country. The key error here isn’t thinking too highly or badly about this country or another, it’s about making sweeping generalizations.
When imagining bike policy, stop thinking nationally in context and start thinking hyper-locally.
Maybe if your city matches key elements of one in another country that implemented a successful program to do X, your city could stand to learn a thing or two. To presume that a prescription from Copenhagen would be equally valuable across the the vast scope of conditions in the US as an entire country is a ludicrous assumption from the start. This isn’t a “pride” thing, or an issue of the US accepting something, it’s an issue of scale and comparing apples to oranges. Bike lane policies cannot be a national issue here, they are local issues. Each locality needs to learn how to enable different transport modalities from other cities, yes, but what works in NYC will not be the same solution for Tampa, for example, or Bozeman.
- spaetzleesser 5y agoThe statement was “ it just wont work for America. ”. It wasn’t “it may be dependent on the locality”. You have to start somewhere and not throw the towel before you got started. Especially with biking I constantly hear the argument “some people may get sweaty a few days of the year so we have to keep driving cars the rest of the year too”. I thought this country is dynamic and innovative but in many ways it’s very stuck in its way. Same with healthcare. When new ideas come up people say it won’t solve all (of the many) problems so let’s just stick to a terrible system.