3 ms·
So... How was this not discovered 18 months ago? There are plenty of people taking fluvoxamine already, which acts as a natural experiment. After a few thou
by londons_explore 5y ago
So... How was this not discovered 18 months ago?
There are plenty of people taking fluvoxamine already, which acts as a natural experiment. After a few thousand hospitalizations, this effect size would have been obvious (ie. March 2020). At that point, a double-blind study could have been run, which (if done in a city with many infections) could have given results within weeks.
What bit of health research dropped the ball on this?
- SketchySeaBeast 5y agoWouldn't this sort of "obvious" link require tracking every patients entire history? Couldn't it be lost in other confounding factors? This seems like it would require a lot of good data and then strong analysis chops to pull that pattern out.
- hdjjhhvvhga 5y agoBut this is exactly where we should double our efforts, because the problem is technical: we do have lots of data to analyze already. The influence of anti-histamine drugs was relatively quickly discovered because everybody expected asthma patients would get worse and the opposite was happening, so this was an obvious thing to examine. But many more drugs may play a role and these are hiding in plain sight - I hope researchers try to organize around it and make more meaningful discoveries.
- SketchySeaBeast 5y agoI'm not saying it wouldn't be a good idea if it was possible, but do we have enough sanitized, high quality, and complete medical data to pull that off? Given the number of potential interactions with all the different medications and conditions, could we actually pull out those links without a ton of confounding variables? Would it produce signal, or just noise?
- hdjjhhvvhga 5y agoGiven enormous resources spent on everything COVOD-related, from tests and vaccines to the costs of lockdowns and restrictions, I think we should at least try to analyze the data looking for the low-hanging fruit, then try to account for confounding factors, and if still interesting look at it closer. Not easy, but definitely possible for large hospitals - they do have enough data, they just need competent people to analyze them and make preliminary findings. On the other hand, we are probably most interested in patients who got infected but did not end up in a hospital. Were they taking any meds routinely? I don't think it's easy to gather this kind of data unless people share them voluntarily with an organization they trust.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoI think you are underestimating the the challenge, but I like your optimism. If states like California can hire 20,000 contact tracers, it seems plausible to hire 20,000 people to transcribe medical records into a database for analysis and remove personal identification.
- walterbell 5y agoFluvoxamine has been part of some (criticized) protocols https://covid19criticalcare.com/covid-19-protocols/math-plus-protocol/ https://covid19criticalcare.com/covid-19-protocols/math-plus... https://www.treatearly.org/fluvoxamine https://www.treatearly.org/fluvoxamine
- AnthonBerg 5y agoIndeed. It’s good at this point to trace why fluvoxamine has been part of those recommendations – it’s based on theory and studies, the same previous work as this current, larger, and better powered study is based on. (The criticism of the protocols is warranted however, and is partly a separate matter.)
- javagram 5y agoUniversal health care and centralization of patient records would probably be required to do what you’re talking about. If scientists actually could mine everyone’s data easily it would be a lot easier to do stuff like this. Privacy laws and the fact that so much of the medical system is disconnected from itself get in the way - it’s normal for every new doctor to ask the same questions again because there’s no reliable way to share information.
- AnthonBerg 5y agoPeople have indeed been saying that this might work, how it would work, that it appeared that it did work, and that it urgently needed studying for a quite some time. There was also indeed a French observational study that showed that people on SSRIs did notably better among those hospitalized for COVID. And a few other smaller studies. I’d suggest looking towards Dr. Angela Reiersen and Dr. Farid Jalali and see if their words haven’t been making consistent sense for a while now.