8 ms·
New Orleans shoeshine man wins legal battle over $30k seized by DEA agents
- b8 5y agoThe nonprofit Institute for Justice has a few cases similar to this one. It's a shame that the government can take peoples money without charging them with a crime. I'm not sure how someone would get their money back without hiring lawyer or having a non profit fight for them. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3bN-mpvg_-o https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3bN-mpvg_-o
- short12 5y agoGood now reduce the budget of the DEA by 30k * 1000 percent It would be a start
- theandrewbailey 5y agoDefund it entirely, along with the ATF, NSA, CIA, and maybe the FBI.
- cycop 5y agoBut keep Homeland Security?
- rpmisms 5y agoNo, they should go too.
- theandrewbailey 5y agoKeep some. FEMA, Coast Guard, and the Secret Service are good ideas. (They don't overthrow governments, spy on everyone, siege civilians, nor habitually seize things without warrants.) Some kind of border protection is necessary for a functioning state, but all those agencies seem staffed with sociopaths on power trips.
- rpmisms 5y agoThey all share extremely limited scope, which is helpful.
- tinus_hn 5y agoMaking sure forfeited assets don’t end up in the coffers of the institute that takes them would be a start to disincentivize this kind of theft.
- yourself92 5y agoThe war on drugs is a failure by any measurable standard other than who made the most money off the backs of the prosecution of our citizens.
- LeifCarrotson 5y agoCongratulations to drugs for winning the war on drugs. Congratulations to the DEA for winning the budget for the war on drugs.
- cronix 5y agoAaaand congratulations to the end beneficiaries of all of this action - big pharma, who made a boatload selling highly addictive, legal drugs and leaving a trail of decline, death and despair in its trail. Clamp down on the illegal stuff while simultaneously boosting the potency of legal stuff to the point it's often greater. Those dirty generic heroin users should use Fentanyl patches, like Duragesic®.
- alphabettsy 5y agoYou shouldn’t have to prove innocence or provide any evidence at all to keep your property when there is no charge or conviction.
- mbg721 5y agoBig government is always big government--severe, unapologetic, and poorly-directed. It's bizarre watching various coalitions form to defend it.
- alphabettsy 5y agoMaybe, but it seems the issue here is the carve-out in the law that makes this possible. Small police and sheriff’s departments do the same thing so it’s not just an issue of big government.
- mbg721 5y agoAny abusive government is big if you're looking at a small community, agreed.
- rpmisms 5y agoBig government enables this behavior by example.
- kevingadd 5y agoThis is simply not true. A government of almost any size can act freely in this way without sufficient oversight. If you're out in a rural area at the mercy of the local sheriff it doesn't matter how much "big government" your state has. The only way "small government" would remedy this is if they were so outnumbered by the populace that citizens could take their property back by force. But in reality, the citizens would just get gunned down.
- rpmisms 5y ago
- bruceb 5y ago"It’s not clear when the funds will be returned to Warren, but prosecutors said that they will “make all best efforts” to do so by Thanksgiving" Insult to injury. They took his money within a few mins of meeting him. This shouldn't happen in the first place, but they should have to return the money within 72 hours of verdict/resolution.
- csomar 5y agoIt'll at best take months, and at worst require another lawsuit.
- ChuckNorris89 5y agoWhen the government institutions act like the mafia.
- tenuousemphasis 5y agoThey more often do than don't.
- FireBeyond 5y agoWell, they covered that too. "As part of the deal [to get his money back], he agreed not to pursue legal action against the government".
- meragrin_ 5y agoNo money in a reasonable amount of time, no deal. No deal, nothing to stop him from pursuing legal action.
- csomar 5y ago> Well, they covered that too. "As part of the deal [to get his money back], he agreed not to pursue legal action against the government". I think that doesn't cover the payment itself, the gov. entity just recognized the debt but he needs to collect. It he wants to enforce collection, he'll need to get a court order (not really that knowledgeable about the US system, so maybe he already have the right to enforce collection).
- rokahnhn 5y agoI wonder how the DA could settle with the victim (we won’t keep the money if you promise not to sue) when the original civil forfeiture charge is technically against the money, not against the victim. I wonder if he has the right to continue legal action against the DA because he did not receive any benefit for relinquishing his legal rights. If a civil rights organization chose to pursue this and convinced a court that the DA would have to provide restitution, that may convince law-enforcement that there’s a cost to pursue civil forfeiture if it’s without basis.
- sdenton4 5y agoWell, /I'm/ not suing you, the money that you stole is suing you...
- FireBeyond 5y agoExcept that, unfortunately, theres precedent / case law from higher courts saying that civil forfeiture is entirely acceptable as a concept.
- Zak 5y agoCivil asset forfeiture abuse is an important ongoing political issue, but it is not hacker news. Off-Topic: Most stories about politics, or crime, or sports, unless they're evidence of some interesting new phenomenon. Videos of pratfalls or disasters, or cute animal pictures. If they'd cover it on TV news, it's probably off-topic. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- ceejayoz 5y agoScroll down a little. > Please don't complain that a submission is inappropriate. If a story is spam or off-topic, flag it. Don't feed egregious comments by replying; flag them instead. If you flag, please don't also comment that you did.
- rdtsc 5y ago> Drug-sniffing dogs were called in, and they detected the presence of drugs on some of the money Of course they were called in, they knew money often has drug residue on it and those dogs will be guaranteed to find something. > In addition to returning all of the seized money – $28,180 – prosecutors agreed to dismiss the case against him with prejudice, meaning they cannot go after the money at a later date. As part of the deal, Warren agreed not to pursue legal action against the government They don't want any precedents to get in the way in the future. Can someone else pursue legal action instead? Say, his family as they were deprived of it as well?
- kevin_thibedeau 5y ago> money often has drug residue on it All money that's been in circulation has drug residue on it. Courts should not be admitting that as evidence.
- stavros 5y agoI think that was the GP's point.
- defen 5y agoI think civil asset forfeiture is a farce and should be ended. At the same time, the idea that a 58 year old man would spend his life savings by purchasing a $30,000 truck from a stranger who lives a thousand miles away, using physical cash, seems extremely suspect to me. Do people think the events described would be a reasonable basis to obtain a warrant for phone / travel records, to see if he'd been associating with known drug dealers?
- asah 5y agoPerhaps true but it's a _very_ dangerous precedent to allow legal behavior to be treated as "suspicious" and grounds for anything. Want an example? You and I are posting on an internet forum whose name has the word "hacker" in the title !! :-)
- x86_64Ubuntu 5y agoSaying that the police should use the presence of cash as reasons to search someone's phone and travel records with the backing of the Drug War is a losing proposition. Always seeking to tie in actions to the Drug War is how we got to the instance that's being discussed.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> Do people think the events described would be a reasonable basis to obtain a warrant for phone / travel records, to see if he'd been associating with known drug dealers? I'm not sure I'd support this, but I wouldn't be viscerally opposed to it either. Taking the money on the basis of that suspicion alone, however, is criminal.
- ceejayoz 5y agoThere are plenty of people who don't trust the banking systems. If you've bounced checks in the past, you may also be blacklisted from them entirely. Quite a few Americans rely on check cashing places because they don't have an account. (edit: 5.4% of Americans don't have a bank. https://www.fdic.gov/analysis/household-survey/index.html https://www.fdic.gov/analysis/household-survey/index.html) A person shouldn't be subject to seizure of their savings just because they're a little different than most in the handling of their finances. I might be OK with the warrant you describe, but that's not what this was.
- jimt1234 5y agoSee this comment I wrote 3 years ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17398314 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17398314 Her brother was a good, hard-working, enterprising dude. The situation basically broke him, and not just financially. He was always a "manly man", a strong head of his household, but he and his family had to go live with his mother. The whole situation was so sad, and for nothing - a handful of Modesto cops saw an opportunity to get free shit.
- sdoering 5y agoWow. I am speechless. I can't understand how a society can accept a practice like that. I know that there is a lot of shit in Germany if you dig for it. But that is a very different level.
- polotics 5y agoMy shock at realizing, at the Ivy-league graduation ceremony of a cousin, that the demeanor and vibe of even the most elite eastern US-ians had something of the wild west in it.
- vkou 5y ago> Wow. I am speechless. I can't understand how a society can accept a practice like that. I hate to be glib about it, but that's Modesto for you. Most of the towns in that area are ran in that way. It's especially bad when it comes to corruption and criminality within the police, because they face next to no accountability from higher up the political ladder (they are essentially untouchable by the state and federal government), and because ~half the local voters will unconditionally support them, and because there's only so many political fights the other ~half will get into.
- asimpletune 5y agoIs it just me that thinks it’s weird that when they win they just get their money back? How can that not create an incentive to abuse the trust placed in law enforcement officers? Are there any missing checks and balances I’m missing on this that go unreported?
- sonotathrowaway 5y agoI remember an interview that NPR had hosted with both a philly DA and a UPenn law professor (Lou Rulli) specializing in civil forfeiture. I remember it because of how thoroughly the law prof eviscerated every defense that the DA put forward in defense of the practice, the episode itself was held in the wake of the Philly DA seizing a grandmothers home because her grandson sold a small amount of marijuana outside of it. The DA was trying to actively avoid answering the question of how evicting an elderly woman on fixed income from her home without due process was legal. It turns out that the Philadelphia Police prior to the current DA specialized in robbing minorities via civil forfeiture, and were some of the most prolific abusers of civil forfeiture in the country, treating the seized money as profit they could use towards their budget, which incentivized them to find victims who couldn’t fight back.
- bradwood 5y agoBitcoin fixes this duck
- runako 5y agoOur institutions are fundamentally organized to mistreat the poor and unlucky.
- mullingitover 5y agoIt's unfortunate, there was some real progress being made on civil asset thefts by government, or 'forfeitures' as they're euphemistically labeled. Then something happened in 2016[1] that pretty much destroyed all that progress. [1] https://outline.com/Xujbxc https://outline.com/Xujbxc