6 ms·
> You are assuming a lot about whether the safety designs exist, or are adequate. Uh, yes. Because there are laws governing how we can construct buildings in
by ajross 5y ago
> You are assuming a lot about whether the safety designs exist, or are adequate.
Uh, yes. Because there are laws governing how we can construct buildings in a safe way, and on the whole (c.f. the number of deaths in building fires over time) they work well. So I trust them.
As far as the putative logic flaw, I don't see it. Everything is a tradeoff, even "because money". Saving money on the dorm means lower tuition, more scholarships, more facilities elsewhere, maybe a few new endowed professorships, etc...
- lazide 5y agoLol - I have yet to see any cost savings passed through as lower tuition. More budget for sports, more administrator salaries, MAYBE an endowment but let’s not get too ahead of ourselves. This is just squeezing the undergrads to feed the rest of the machine more efficiently.
- vmception 5y agoYou're assuming those laws are adequate. I wrote that the first time. It's a bad idea, you trust them just because the catastrophes haven't happened. For the next few weeks in your day to day, look at how many emergency exits are disarmed or blocked or locked, look at how many other inspectable things just aren't inspected, like when the last elevator inspection occurred on the ones you use. We're trying to save people that trust the system too much. Let me know if you know any people like that.
- ajross 5y ago> You're assuming those laws are adequate. This is getting toward conspiracy theory territory. It's... a building code. Yes. Yes, I tend to trust building codes that have been keeping all of us safe in our homes and offices for the better part of a century. If building codes don't work, then where are the disasters in all the other buildings? You're saying that every other building in the USA in the 20th century "just happened" to be built safely, despite a thousand year history of terrible urban fires, and that regulation had nothing to do with it?
- pdpi 5y agoNothing conspirational about it. In the follow up to the Grenfell fire[1], my development was reviewed and the cladding in use on several buildings was found… less than ideal. The homeowner’s association is currently drafting a plan to have it replaced. This isn’t some theoretical, conspiracy-laden issue. It’s an actual problem. 1. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grenfell_Tower_fire https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grenfell_Tower_fire
- ajross 5y ago> In the follow up to the Grenfell fire[1], my development was reviewed and the cladding in use on several buildings was found… less than ideal. Yes! And by whom was it reviewed? And what happened when they reviewed it? I'm guessing the answers are "government regulators", and "they made sure it was fixed". And now it's being fixed. You're literally citing the fact that safety regulation worked correctly as evidence... that it doesn't? Without the regulators you'd still be living in a deathtrap!
- vmception 5y agoWhich means one should not trust that new and existing buildings are safe because of the mere existence of code or that there are competent people that exist to review and report. The safety regulation did not work because of the 71 people that died in Grenfell. What would you say if you lived there yourself "ah thats just bad luck for me"? what would you say if you lived there yourself and were one of the people that was reporting to the regulators about the problems in advance "I trust this system, I'm glad this system is based purely on trust, trust works so well, all should trust building codes because they are CODES, I like codes, they are infallible, its so cool that people exist to review the codes as well. This happens so rare due to the codes and not from simply being an uncommon occurrence that challenges building standard." I don't really understand what your perspective here is to be honest. Not being wrong?
- ClumsyPilot 5y ago"Yes! And by whom was it reviewed? And what happened when they reviewed it? I'm guessing the answers are "government regulators" I think you misunderstood the poster - 100 people burned alive because the regulators were asleep at the wheel. That tragic disaster is the only reason his building was checked for adequacy, and it failed, along with thousands of others. Right now there are thousands of buildings which were built and sold in breach of fire regulation, and the apartment owners are being saddled with 100% of the bill even when they own 25% of the apartment. In some cases the cost of repair exceeds the value of the property.
- kixiQu 5y agoLaws work together with norms. The norms of architecture that mandate e.g. windows for living spaces are here being violated so extremely someone's stepping down over it. This is therefore not an average project. Concern seems reasonable.
- bobthepanda 5y agoIt‘s strange that this isn‘t a law. Everywhere where I‘ve lived in the US, windows are required in a room with a bed. I can‘t imagine it wouldn‘t be very pleasant, as an example, someone smoking weed inside a dorm next to me without a way to vent it out.
- ethbr0 5y agoAfaik, most windows in newer, high-density commercial buildings are non-functional. It's difficult to design a large window, that will also open, that also insulates sufficiently to hit modern energy efficiency certifications.
- hackersword 5y agoIn the event of a fire, "opening" the window is not necessarily a function of if the window is MEANT to be opened ... but CAN it be opened. Eg: throwing a chair through it, or firefighters breaking window from outside, etc.
- bobthepanda 5y agoResidential is different, due to generally higher ventilation requirements (e.g. bathroom & kitchen). YMMV, but I live in Seattle, where there has been a residential boom with plenty of towers, and I have never seen a residential apartment with non-functional windows. Every room will have at least one that can open (though for efficiency reasons they're usually casement windows, which are annoying in their own right)
- kixiQu 5y agoI'm in a Seattle tower and the extent to which our windows open is a joke. You can't actually get any ventilation from a 16 inch wide window allowed to open up to twelve degrees. I like the idea of being environmentally friendly but we definitely lost the plot where airflow is concerned.
- randcraw 5y agoThis design came from an amateur architect, someone who has never designed ANY building before and is surely clueless about safety laws and even basic physical structural limits. To imagine the design has seen anywhere sufficient review by others who DO know what they're doing is assuming a lot. All this just to save $200/1500 (13%)? You can get a better discount than that at any retailer.
- mattmcknight 5y ago> This design came from an amateur architect, someone who has never designed ANY building before and is surely clueless about safety laws and even basic physical structural limits. To imagine the design has seen anywhere sufficient review by others who DO know what they're doing is assuming a lot. This is false statement. The architectural design was provided by Van Tilburg, Banvard, & Soderberg, AIA.
- ethbr0 5y agoI think you're overreading the amateur architect angle. Presumably, they didn't say "Hi, Charlie Munger, please draw up a building for us on a napkin." It's in fact a barb that Munger is a non-practicing architect, and apparently ruffled feathers with the professional architect on the committee. Which, from working with some prima donna architects, I am both unsurprised and unsympathetic about. Building engineers ensure everything is to code. Architects fret about whether it looks and feels right. Some architects are good at making livable spaces, but an architecture degree doesn't guarantee that, and a lack of one doesn't preclude it.
- jkaptur 5y ago> Building engineers ensure everything is to code. Architects fret about whether it looks and feels right. The idea that architects don't worry about building code is absolutely incorrect on a project of any scale. Prima donna "starchitects" worry less, but that's because they've hired other architects to handle it.
- ajross 5y ago
- cpwright 5y agoZoning and building codes set forth by a municipality do not necessarily have to be followed by the state government (presuming the UC system counts as part of the state government).