4 ms·
I mean. I am not trying to underscore the work. But I feel you are making it sound magical. This is not much different than cooking, is it? Try making bread
by taeric 5y ago
I mean. I am not trying to underscore the work. But I feel you are making it sound magical. This is not much different than cooking, is it? Try making bread or beer by adding things out of order.
I feel so much of this mysticism is driven by over reliance on associative and distributive laws for elementary math. And it is super annoying because I know I do the same thing.
- maroonblazer 5y agoHe's not making it sound magical. He's pointing out how hard it is.
- taeric 5y agoI think I was just sticking on the gp's "In my mind STEM topics exist on a scale that has math at one end..." Especially with the first supporting evidence being that order matters on how you mix things. Only in very elementary math, it seems, is that not the case. Yet, we stick on that heavily. That is, I wasn't trying to counter the point. I intend my point to be a further exploration on why that makes things feel more complicated. Near mystical, in that we can't always explain why an order is important. Sometimes we can, of course.
- DiggyJohnson 5y agoI track your point, though I might add that in advanced mathematics, things can often be reasoned in multiple directions, or sometimes proved via multiple methods. Often things are demonstrated irrespective of changing parameters, or otherwise the parameters are well understood to define the problem. This isn't true for many orgo chemicals, based on the OP. The scale of sensitivity to initial and intermediate (!) conditions is un-intuitively high.
- taeric 5y agoMakes sense. I think it is from a definition perspective, though. Statically, it is easy to define things independent of the process that governs them. Such that it is a middle college class that really covers dynamic systems for structural analysis. With most earlier classes being static analysis. Even electrical classes started on analog circuits and power transmission later in courses. Early circuits are centered around ready dc connections. Or steady state ac ones.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- DiggyJohnson 5y agoI see it as a sensitivity to initial conditions. If anything, beginner cooks are more likely to overestimate this sensitivity (afraid to sub ingredients, Your examples of bread or beer avoid this, but then consider whether brewing beer is a good, differentiating counter-example to organic chemistry. ;)
- taeric 5y agoYeah, I confess I picked baking and brewing specifically. Was also thinking cheeses making. And agreed that for many processes, it is initial conditions. I also consider scaffolding for things like keystone arches. The final result being something that is only doable with items that are no longer there.