6 ms·
No, this would be an Oculus-specific account. There are enough legitimate criticisms of Facebook that we don't have to go around inventing false ones. Edited
by loeg 5y ago
No, this would be an Oculus-specific account. There are enough legitimate criticisms of Facebook that we don't have to go around inventing false ones.
Edited to cite the announcement transcript[1]:
> And as we’ve focused more on work, and frankly, as we’ve heard your feedback more broadly, we’re on making it so you can log into Quest with an account other than your personal Facebook account.
> ... I know this is a big deal for a lot of people. Not everyone wants their social media profile linked to all these other experiences.
[1]: https://www.rev.com/blog/transcripts/meta-facebook-connect-2021-metaverse-event-transcript https://www.rev.com/blog/transcripts/meta-facebook-connect-2...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- iforgetti 5y agoDoes Meta provide a guarantee that data won’t be unified between Facebook and Oculus accounts ever? If not, what is the value of this distinction beyond PR?
- micromacrofoot 5y agoOculus no longer exists. It's Meta, which is The Facebook company.
- CharlesW 5y agoAnd just to add a bit more color, Oculus-the-subsidiary became Oculus-the-brand in Sep 2018.
- croes 5y agoThat's FB's claim at the moment and after so many tricks and lies by FB I'm pessimistic. Their contract excuse to circumvent the GDPR does not make them credible.
- AlexandrB 5y ago> No, this would be an Oculus-specific account. This is not stated anywhere. I don't see why Facebook couldn't create a Meta SSO that you can use for Facebook and/or Oculus and call it "job done". For them it's a win/win. Most people would choose to "migrate" their Facebook login to Meta. Those annoyed by this could just create a Meta account. Notably there's no mention of whether you'll need to use your real name for logging into Oculus as you do with Facebook. My bet is: probably.
- Closi 5y ago> No, this would be an Oculus-specific account. Hmm, the statements you posted don’t quite say that. I guess it’s still possible that users could be required to register a “meta” account which is separate to your personal Facebook account, although you can sign into your personal Facebook account with your meta account via single sign on. I think this would technically meet their wording while also not fulfilling the spirit of what everyone wants. For instance, you can have a Google account that isn’t linked to your personal Gmail account, because not everyone wants their search history linked to their email - just change Google to Meta, Gmail to Facebook and search history to social media.
- nixpulvis 5y agoWhy the fuck do I need to log into my monitor?! it's bad enough the driver demands a running application which tries to sell me shit and pushes me into a place I don't want to be at all. It's literally hijacking my computer.
- onion2k 5y agoWhy the fuck do I need to log into my monitor? Because you bought a system that only has apps from your monitor's app store available, and that means you have to prove who you are to use them. It's no different to phones, consoles, etc.
- q3k 5y ago> It's no different to phones, consoles, etc. You can use a Nintendo Switch or an Android phone without an online account.
- tl 5y agoNot really. Nintendo eShop and Google Play Service will dark pattern you towards having an account in cases where they don't outright require it like DLC expansions to the "physical" cartridge you "bought".
- tgsovlerkhgsel 5y agoYou can't install apps through "normal user" means on the Android phones I've had unless you add an account. De facto, that means you need an account. Yes, I know you can try to find copies of your banking apps on apkmirror and sideload, but... no. (Also, wouldn't that mean that you have to manually confirm every single app update, so a 10-minute button pushing session every week?)
- croes 5y agoYou can use via Link with a PC or side load apps, so Oculus apps aren't needed. Since when is it ok that I need an third party account to access my computer?
- 5y ago
- ImPostingOnHN 5y agoWould Facebook be physically prevented from ever accessing or linking to data on the Metafacebookulus account, ad vice versa? If not, sounds like a Facebook account by another name.
- micromacrofoot 5y agoIt's literally the same company, why would it be prevented?
- long_time_gone 5y agoBecause of the security and risk implication of not preventing it. Goldman Sachs is both an investment bank and an asset management firm, literally the same company. However, they have clear protocols in place to separate the two sides because otherwise the opportunities for impropriety are too high. I could see a similar argument for separating Facebook and Oculus accounts.
- micromacrofoot 5y agoSure, but Goldman Sachs business model isn't aggregating and selling data. Facebook's is.
- ImPostingOnHN 5y agoThe fact that the two components of an analogy are not the same thing is the point of the analogy. If they were the same thing, the analogy would be useless. In this specific analogy, the point is, despite having different business models, society benefits from either conglomerate separating their respective two aforementioned business units.
- long_time_gone 5y agoNo, their businesses are managing money and taking companies public. They're overall revenue would benefit from aligning those businesses, but they aren't allowed to. They are kept separate because of the risks of having them together. The Facebook scenario is a different (but comparable) situation.