3 ms·
So the new experiment has three flasks. One is borosilicate, the other two are teflon. One of the teflon flasks has pieces of borosilicate floating in it. Both
by noduerme 5y ago
So the new experiment has three flasks. One is borosilicate, the other two are teflon. One of the teflon flasks has pieces of borosilicate floating in it. Both the teflon flasks failed to reproduce the results of the original experiment.
Couldn't the takeaway here be that life is allergic to Teflon?
- anshumankmr 5y ago>Couldn't the takeaway here be that life is allergic to Teflon? Shocking
- high_byte 5y agoI might have missed something. says the teflon flasks produced less organic material, but I assumed it was only the teflon without borosilicate? my understanding was that borosilicate contributed to creation of organic materials.
- mrob 5y ago"The results: far fewer organic compounds formed in the experiments using just the Teflon flasks." Not the clearest way to phrase it, but I agree it most likely means the loose borosilicate bits worked too.
- high_byte 5y agothat's what I thought. I think they meant "flask", or several "plain teflon flasks" were involved.
- nobrains 5y agoThe takeaway is that the silica / silicate in the glass acted as the silica in the rocks and gave a more closer to real-life scenario, so it solidifies the original experiment even more, while noting that the original authors did not intend this.
- noduerme 5y agowhat I mean is, how do they know that's what helped the reaction? The other two flasks were of a different material, but the same as each other. How do they know that material A aided the reaction as opposed to concluding that material B impeded it?
- DanielVZ 5y ago> This finding supports the authors' original hypothesis. Corrosion on the surface of the glass (due to the hot and caustic water circulating through it) plays a key role, since this releases silicon-dioxide molecules into the solution. This in turn acts as a catalyst to speed up the chemical reactions between the nitrogen, carbon, and hydrogen atoms that ultimately create organic molecules. In addition, they found that the corrosion on the glass also forms millions of tiny pits. The authors think those pits could serve as tiny reaction chambers, also speeding up the rate at which organic molecules form in the experiment. 1. It's known to be a catalyst in the chemical reaction 2. They believe that the tiny pits in the corroded glass also speed up the reaction. This could explain why the material of the flask matters.
- wongarsu 5y agoThat sounds like they had a hypothesis, did an experiment, the experiment matches their hypothesis, so they came up with a reasonable explanation why. But if noduerme had done the same experiment with the hypothesis "life can't form in the presence of Teflon" the experiment would have also confirmed his hypothesis, and he would have given you a reasonable explanation why that is. It would have been more convincing/thorough if they had also tried e.g. a steel and a silicon carbide reaction flask.
- burnished 5y agoNo, I don't think so. Organic compounds still formed just fewer. They might reasonably expect that the teflon, being far less reactive, did not appreciably influence the experiment.
- 5y ago