3 ms·
I don't think anyone was under the impression that it's cost effective to manufacture in the US. The US push to get TSMC in the US is 1000% about risk mitigati
by kube-system 5y ago
I don't think anyone was under the impression that it's cost effective to manufacture in the US. The US push to get TSMC in the US is 1000% about risk mitigation... and I have a feeling that the nay-sayers from ROC might be concerned about losing political significance with their western trade partners.
- 8eye 5y agonailed it. thank you for pointing it out. truthfully
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dv_dt 5y agoCost effective over a long time horizon may not look cost effective over a shorter one
- tablespoon 5y ago> Cost effective over a long time horizon may not look cost effective over a shorter one And cost effective over a shorter horizon may not look cost effective over a longer one. Just ask all those species that specialized to a niche then went extinct when that niche disappeared.
- LurkingPenguin 5y ago> ...and I have a feeling that the nay-sayers from ROC might be concerned about losing political significance with their western trade partners. This. I live in Taiwan, and while I love the country and hope that it never falls to the CCP, I do believe that a primary reason TSMC's manufacturing remains so heavily concentrated in Taiwan is to increase the stakes for the West. Very few Taiwanese I know believe that Taiwan is capable of repelling a Chinese invasion or attack without the support of the US, and protecting the Western world's access to semiconductors is a big incentive for the US to think twice about letting Taiwan fall. While TSMC folks will tell you that their operation is so heavily concentrated for manufacturing and supply chain efficiency/optimization reasons, it is very unusual for a company as big and important as TSMC to have so little diversification in the geographical footprint of its operations.
- worrycue 5y ago> nay-sayers from ROC might be concerned about losing political significance with their western trade partners It's more than that. TSMC's competitive advantage is their volume. It allows them to experiment and iterate faster than everyone - some say it's a big reason why Intel fell behind. Moving production into the US and out of TSMC's hands kills that.
- m0zg 5y agoThis problem will solve itself in the next few years when China retakes Taiwan. There's not a whole lot anyone can do about that, although I predict quite a bit of saber rattling. Open warfare is not an option (China has nukes), and "sanctions" are self-defeating, since we import far too much. If they leave an "out" (which they'd be wise to leave) the US establishment will take it, although the rhetoric will be quite severe I'm sure. Indeed re-shoring high end silicon is an unambiguous bet on exactly this eventuality - there'd be no reason to spend the billions otherwise.