3 ms·
I'm not proposing we cut off Hospital / school funding to make our mega-dense utopia with maximum tax $$$$ per population here. (Yes, I too have played lots of
by dragontamer 5y ago
I'm not proposing we cut off Hospital / school funding to make our mega-dense utopia with maximum tax $$$$ per population here. (Yes, I too have played lots of Sim City. I'm well aware of the unrealistic corners of the game).
I'm simply pointing out that Factorio has a factory-like system that has the "buffering" problem innate to the game mechanics. As far as I can tell, the problem of buffering in real life is closely modeled by Factorio correctly.
Sim City is on the unrealistic side. But Factorio / Hearts of Iron / OpenTTD seem to do a good job of making the "real world issues translate well into a game". I think most people would benefit if they played those games and learned from them.
- mindslight 5y agoI'm making the general point that results from optimizing for any model are going to depend entirely on the assumptions baked into the model. I haven't played Factorio, but based on your description it sounds like it leaves out price signals because the player has omniscience. If a supply chain is directed by a centralized entity, then yes, keeping intermediate inventory doesn't do much. But our actual economy is based on distributed decision making coordinating through price signals. And so what inventory buffers allow a company to do is see that an in/out buffer is getting depleted, and then gradually raise bids/prices to compensate. FWIW I think there's way too much discussion focus on the keeping of inventory, as it is just one of many ways that the system can have slack. Things like having some extra machinery so it's not all running 24/7, having enough employees so that there is no overtime on a regular week, or treating your employees well so that they'll go the extra mile - these are all ways that production can be ramped up quickly when needed, that don't exist if a business is trying to optimize every last bit of short term profit. I agree that more people should learn system dynamics and modeling though, whether through games or otherwise.
- dragontamer 5y agoIn Factorio, the part where the human "interacts" with the factory is given a name, called "The Mall". (You ship all of the products that the human intends to use to a central location). You do have a nominal amount of supplies buffered up in the mall, but only as much as you ever expect the human (ie: yourself) to ever use at any given time. Let me discuss the Belt hiearchy. Belts are used to move items around the factory, but are used relatively unpredictably. Iron makes gears. Iron + Gears make Yellow Belts (slow). Yellow belts + Gears make Red Belts. Red Belts + Lubricant + Gears make Blue belts (fastest belts). Lets say you're at endgame, so you'll only be using blue belts (very expensive, but useful to the human to have fewer "SKUs" so to speak to think about. Yellow/Red belts save on material but blue belts are best, so you end up just "eating the cost" in most cases). There's really only one item you should buffer: blue belts. All other components (gears, yellow-belts, red belts, and lubrican) should be made on a "just in time", 0-buffer solution if at all possible. Yellow-belts and Gears are furthermore used in other items: such as underground belts, splitters (for belts), or inserters / assembly machines / automated turrets (gears). Buffering up gears "at your belt factory" starves your other factories (ie: buffering up 1000 gears at the belt-factory means that your turret-factory will be starved and idle)