6 ms·
I think the only thing I really quibble a bit with is the description of "dumber". Our "domestication" has historically been more that we've gone from a genera
by cogman10 5y ago
I think the only thing I really quibble a bit with is the description of "dumber".
Our "domestication" has historically been more that we've gone from a generalist species to a specialist society. With that, things that were previously probably a boon for survival and reproduction become less so (For example, quick reaction times don't matter so much when you have a city wall to keep out predators and a backup hunting party).
My assumption is that what we've lost is more our brain matter used to sleep in trees and wake up/run from predators at all hours of the night. Stuff that's less important when you have night watchman, fires, and shelter.
It's similar to how dolphins have huge brains, but most of that is dedicated to sound processing. If dolphins learned how to make huts, farm fish, and fight off predators I'd imagine the part of their brain dedicated to processing sound would start to shrink as there isn't the evolutionary pressure to keep it around.
Sort of like how humans might be evolving towards color blindness because being able to tell the difference between red and green doesn't necessarily increase our ability to have children. That might lead to weird changes in our eyes and brains that could shrink them but wouldn't necessarily mean those humans are any dumber than their predecessors.
- algebraically 5y agoGood point.
- matheusmoreira 5y agoSounds like we need to take control of this evolutionary process and start engineering it. Just because we are no longer required to use these abilities on a daily basis doesn't mean we don't want them. Evolution can go to hell with its "pressures", humanity is supposed to get better over time, not worse.
- bobthechef 5y agoSounds like eugenics. Heh, no thanks. Also "better" and "worse" only mean something relative to an end. I do not deny ends (I take human nature to be teleological, for example), but many "evolutionists" (i.e., those who accept a basically materialistic worldview) do deny the reality of ends (and are wholly incapable of accounting for them even if reduced to mental phenomena by virtue of having painted themselves into a metaphysical corner).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- exporectomy 5y agoDo you have a real concern with eugenics or is it just because your culture demonizes it? We already have little bits of eugenics baked into law and culture. Why not a little bit more? It doesn't have to involve death camps.
- SamoyedFurFluff 5y agoEugenics involved horrific deprivations of human dignity for arbitrary decisions of what seemed at the time to be “self evidently good” traits that are much less self evidently good now… if the traits were even retained.
- notriddle 5y agoSame reason so many people object to censorship: nobody can be trusted with that kind of power.
- exporectomy 5y agoIs that really why eugenics is demonized? That the human race (not any living individuals) is giving up its freedom to some sort of fallible authority? I guess, like censorship, people only object to an arbitrary subset of it. People love censorship of "really bad" ideas just as they love eugenics of "really bad" genes. Most people seem happy with asserting our authority of gene selection over animals though :P Conservationism is that. Not to mention actual selective breeding and killing of course. Perhaps we rightly believe humans truly are capable of being benevolent arbiters of who gets to reproduce and who doesn't in animals.
- cogman10 5y agoAnimal breeding is somewhat different from human breeding. With animal breeding, there's almost always a set goal. Getting a fatter, tastier, more hardy, or in the extreme, aesthetically pleasing animal. I doubt we'd really use eugenics for any of them. However, a pure eugenicist might say "Well, why not? Why not select for people less prone to cancer, more physically fit, with better immune systems?" So then it comes into the question of what eugenics has historically been used for. The worst example would probably be the sterilization of gay people. We used it against mental illness in an age where lobotomy was considered a good treatment for mental illnesses such as hyperactivity. And all of this, of course, sort of belays the fact that for humans there seems to be no reason why we couldn't use gene therapy in place of breeding programs. Why do we need eugenics when we can directly target the aspects we want in the future generation (and quite a few people would opt in for those changes). We already seem some of this just in genetic testing of embryos and fetuses. When people know a fetus has downs syndrome, they get abortions and try again. I could see the same with a whole host of chronic illnesses.
- vlovich123 5y agoYou're making a value judgement like "better" and "worse" as if there was a clear global optimum that you can reach. Why do you assume that's the case? Let's assume there even is a global optimum. Why do we think this global optimum would be invariant on environment? We have clear examples of species that fail to adapt to their changing environment quickly enough dying off. If you took the survivors of a change and then changed things back, those survivors might die again. That means you are fit to the environment you find yourself in. As the environment changes, you're not "better" or "worse" than someone who's more fit to a different environment. Humanity is not getting strictly better on all stats. It's like a video game. We might tweak improve some stats and have to give up others. We are a bit more unique in that we largely optimize for the environment we create for ourselves, but that doesn't mean humans are constantly "getting better" over time. You could maybe try arguing that the human condition has improved over time due to technology, medicine, etc, but even that's an imperfect analysis because our historical record is so inaccurate.
- matheusmoreira 5y agoSurely having sharper and more intelligent humans is an objectively better uncontroversial outcome. If there's even a chance that our environment is somehow downregulating important features such as intelligence, we must find a way to reverse that process.
- hawk_ 5y ago> Surely having sharper and more intelligent humans is an objectively better uncontroversial outcome What if there's a level of intelligence above which humans decide not to reproduce?
- matheusmoreira 5y agoI question the intelligence of a human species that does not reproduce.
- vlovich123 5y ago
- bobthechef 5y agoI agree that smaller brain does not mean dumber. This is a very simplistic idea of what brains are for. Whales have huge brains, but I would guess that has more to do with their size. I don't understand what you mean by "generalist" vs "specialist". I think intelligence is related to why, for example, human beings lack armor, fur, and all sorts of specialized features, functions, and excellences that other species have. Human intelligence can dream up an indefinite if not infinite number of functions which are "offloaded" to technology. We wear clothing and can adjust it depending on the climate which allow us to adapt to environments more than any other species. We have optical instruments which can extend our vision beyond that of any other species depending on need. We have all sorts of communication instruments which allow us a greater range of communication than any other species. We can harvest food in ways that put all other species to shame. We can outrun, fly, and swim any other animal. I could go on. Any capacity other species have we can (at least in principle) exceed with the help of technology, all thanks to human intelligence. Assuming selection as an explanatory model, I don't see why we should expect to see that basic feature going away. Even with greater specialization in one direction or another, you still need much of that basic underlying generality.
- inawarminister 5y agoAFAIK human natural niche was persistence hunting. Due to our body shape and ability to sweat, we can outrun prey species in the long run. That's how we're engineered, by natural selection in Ice Age Africa. Persistent trekkers that can throw sticks and stones. Later, we domesticated dogs and other species, then made more and more advanced technologies. But at it's core? Our niche was that.
- robbedpeter 5y agoI'm pretty sure that humans are apex persistence hunters - we can run any animal to death, not just prey species. It's a brutally effective adaptation. It's the greatest weapon we had until fire. Even fat modern lazy humans have it in them - kick in survival mode brain chemistry and enough luck to keep chasing a deer's trail for days, the deer will die of exhaustion before the human.
- 5y ago
- The_Colonel 5y ago> Sort of like how humans might be evolving towards color blindness because being able to tell the difference between red and green doesn't necessarily increase our ability to have children. Doesn't this hold true for "dumbness" as well? Being dumb is no longer an obstacle in having a reproductive success. I wouldn't be surprised if there was a peak in the reproduction rate bell curve around IQ 80-90.
- im3w1l 5y ago> Our "domestication" has historically been more that we've gone from a generalist species to a specialist society. Outsourcing violence to the police is a huge step of domestication.