3 ms·
>Blizzard could shutdown WOW and you would loose all of your loot, but if it's on a public ledger then your loot survives Your loot is worthless without the ga
by charcircuit 5y ago
>Blizzard could shutdown WOW and you would loose all of your loot, but if it's on a public ledger then your loot survives
Your loot is worthless without the game. Why would you still want it?
- mindcandy 5y agoThere's a whole lot of BS in NFTs at the moment. But, there is one thing they are good for: Everyone is crying out for a decentralized, interoperable metaverse that is not walled-off and owned by corporations. OK. So, how does anything of monetary value interoperate in that scenario? So, you can make your metaverse service, I can make mine, and we can both interoperate by supporting each other's APIs. But, some of our services cost us significant money to provide and have market value to our users. We can make with work out for everyone by recognizing ownership of certain NFTs as decentralized verification that a given user has rights to things of value in our services. We don't have a lot of examples of this so far because corporations are incentivized to wall you off from their competition and the public has not the means to securely control and verify value outside of the blessings of the corporations. But, now we can do it without them.
- ryan_lane 5y ago> Everyone is crying out for a decentralized, interoperable metaverse No one is crying out for a metaverse.
- charcircuit 5y ago>OK. So, how does anything of monetary value interoperate in that scenario? The same way things of monetary value interoperate on the internet currently. Anyone right now can create their own ecommerce site right now and start selling things for money just fine.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- joshmarlow 5y agomindcandy's comment sums it up well, but I'll just add that the loot is worthless without the game now - that's the point of vendor lockin. But if items and their properties are stored in a public-by-default way, then other games can incorporate those items in it (without Blizzard's permission). So if you get some loot in one game, it can become available in others. The neat idea is that application data from different sources become composable by default. Frankly, I'm not much of a gamer - but an open ledger is the only basis that I can see to avoid vendor lock-in for the increasingly nuanced virtual environments that we are building.
- fl0wenol 5y agoAll of this assumes that other games will "play by the rules", in the sense that they won't let you use an item that you don't own. If I can see the resource (and in all current models, the content of the signed media/document an NFT authorizes is public) then I can use myself if my client is so configured. Most games give value to loot by forced scarcity, NFTs don't implicitly enable this at all.
- joshmarlow 5y agoI think that's right locally - you can of course make your local software ignore the ownership of nfts. But if the crypto/ledger doesn't line up, then other better behaved clients can (and arguably have an incentive to) just ignore what your client says. That could mean (in a gaming context) that the rest of the network just ignores your progress in the game (ie, new loot acquisitions). It's the same thing with Bitcoin node software - any node could broadcast a transaction that contains more BTC than the address actually has. But the crypto/ledger won't add up, so the network just wouldn't accept it. In fact, flooding the networks with forgeries would devalue the network (and the operator's investment in the project). Games built on a public ledger benefit from playing by the rules - doing otherwise would devalue their investment in building on the ledger.
- charcircuit 5y ago>But if items and their properties are stored in a public-by-default way, then other games can incorporate those items in it (without Blizzard's permission). So if you get some loot in one game, it can become available in others. This only makes sense for like gambling games / other financial stuff that values those items as a substitute for money. What game designer would let some other company add items to your game without your oversight? Why would you bother devoting developing time into mao king sure everything renders correctly and has the correct properties in game. What if the other game gets hacked and now people start bringing OP items into your game. If you are designing a game you typically want to have control over the whole experience.