Ok, now it's clear. So yes I agree that controlling false discovery rate is an unsolved problem that p-value doesn't address. Yes of course applied stats are a

Ok, now it's clear. So yes I agree that controlling false discovery rate is an unsolved problem that p-value doesn't address. Yes of course applied stats are a kind of 'soft science', at least regarding the interpretation of results. Statistical theory on the other hand, is very well defined. So that doesn't justify considering assumptions made from erroneous conceptual understanding. This is where we disagree, I guess.