2 ms·
The examiner rejected it as obvious. More limitations were added that made it no longer obvious. It's the new version that was ruled valid. Consider (120 years
by HWR_14 5y ago
The examiner rejected it as obvious. More limitations were added that made it no longer obvious. It's the new version that was ruled valid.
Consider (120 years ago) a patent on "using energy to move a vehicle quickly". Well, that's stupid and obvious. But using an ICE to move a car was not. So you add more details and limits until it's no longer obvious.
- rkagerer 5y agoMore limitations were added that made it no longer obvious You mean this one? "... moving said tray cart to said proximate end of said scanning device" I guess my bar for non-obvious is a lot higher.