2 ms·
Both welfare and UBI skirt the fundamental underlying issues of access to capital, voice/control in the workplace, equality of opportunity, concentration of wea
by cmrdporcupine 5y ago
Both welfare and UBI skirt the fundamental underlying issues of access to capital, voice/control in the workplace, equality of opportunity, concentration of wealth, concentration of power, etc. All of that would just still go on, but people would just probably-not starve.
In fact I wonder if UBI were implemented if many of these things could worsen as political pressure from the working classes in the form of unions and political parties and the like would weaken. If you're able to feed yourself via UBI, why vote for a "left wing" party, or go on strike, or go to a demonstration etc in order to push for more workplace rights, etc.? Hence why I think actually there's plenty of support for UBI from people who would not normally be advocates of extensive social programs.
Many old school Marxists saw welfare programmes as nothing more than an "escape valve" for the excesses of capitalism. Good as a "transitional demand" but harmful in the long run.