4 ms·
I think people spend WAY too much effort worrying about the "small subset of people" who misuse a social system. To the point that their fixation on this small
by Waterluvian 5y ago
I think people spend WAY too much effort worrying about the "small subset of people" who misuse a social system. To the point that their fixation on this small subset causes more waste than just being okay with the fact that some people will misuse a system.
When Covid began, the Ontario Government just handed out cash. You could go to a website and 5 minutes later be set up for a $400 direct deposit into your bank account. You didn't need to prove anything. You just gave them your bank information and personal information and how many kids you have. People got anxious about the hypothetical kind of person who could abuse this. The response was basically: if we try to carefully scrutinize every person, it's going to cost us more, and we're not going to get the money out fast enough. This is for parents who suddenly have to buy Chromebooks and other school supplies for their kids.
If you ask me, I think it all stems from a deep feeling all humans have, but that some cultures greatly amplify: the anxiety that someone isn't rowing while you are.
- awillen 5y agoThere's so much of this thinking that misses the forest for the trees. When you're running a giant government program, fraud and misuse are to be expected. The question "will there be fraud?" is rarely the right one - rather it's "factoring in the cost of fraud, is this still a good program?" There was a fair bit of PPP fraud, but that's okay! It was designed to be relatively easy for businesses to get that money, because getting money into the hands of small businesses was critical. Plenty of the fraud could have been prevented with additional paperwork/validations/etc., but amount saved from fraud by doing that would be completely outweighed by the cost of businesses failing that otherwise could have been saved because they couldn't get the money fast enough.
- t-writescode 5y agoEspecially in the United States, we’re so focused on catching fraud, we probably spend more money on the bureaucracy to stop the fraud than the cost the fraud would have, itself.
- awillen 5y agoYeah, it's this bizarrely shortsighted focus on making it an absolute priority that nobody takes advantage of us as compared to just prioritizing our own well being. We're not even good at being selfish :/
- dlp211 5y agoWorst, we spend so much time trying to prevent fraud, the programs don't reach their full potential to benefit the most amount of people that need it and are qualified to receive it.
- epicureanideal 5y agoAccepting fraud encourages fraud and demoralizes people who are playing by the rules just to watch fraudsters pass them by in life.
- Waterluvian 5y ago"Accepting fraud encourages fraud" is a sensible argument if you live in a society that is breeding fraudsters. I don't think the existence of an opportunity for fraud creates fraudsters. I think it's more a consequence of a society that is failing to equip its people with the education, skills, safety nets, and opportunities necessary to live a moral life. This line of thinking creates a feedback loop, bolstered by systemic racism and poverty bigotry: the riffraff will abuse these systems so we won't offer them, or we'll make them all but impossible to utilize. And then those individuals struggle and are left with little choice when they're drowning.
- tombert 5y agoAs a general rule I am somewhat of the camp of "part of what defines us as a society is how we treat the people who have it the worst." I think even if you could somehow prove that there was a ridiculously huge amount of welfare fraud, I'd still be somewhat supportive of it; I think there's an inherent value of knowing that a safety net exists. If you lose your job, or get into a horrible accident, or have some condition that puts you at a disadvantage, we (as a society) should be looking out for you, particularly in the most wealthy economy on the planet.
- awillen 5y agoI think even if you take a wildly more cynical approach, a substantial amount of welfare is still worthwhile. When people run out of money, society ends up paying for it, whether it's because those people steal and go to prison or end up in the hospital. If you spend $1B in welfare and half of it gets stolen, it's still a great investment if it take down the societal costs of dealing with poverty by $2B.
- tombert 5y agoI really don't see how much my post disputes anything you're saying. I said I don't want people to replace current benefits with UBI, not that I'm against people getting no-questions-asked benefits.
- NtochkaNzvanova 5y agoOh? https://www.usnews.com/news/best-states/california/articles/2021-10-25/californias-unemployment-fraud-reaches-at-least-20-billion https://www.usnews.com/news/best-states/california/articles/... "California has paid at least $20 billion in fraudulent unemployment benefits since the start of the pandemic."
- klyrs 5y ago> ... confirming a number smaller than originally feared but one that still accounts for more than 11% of all benefits paid since the start of the pandemic. The overwhelming majority not being fraudulent. That's rather the point, isn't it?
- NtochkaNzvanova 5y agoSo this would only be a problem if more than 50% is fraudulent? Or what number? 11%, or $20B is still a massive amount of fraud.
- klyrs 5y agoOf course fraud is a problem. But 11% fraud isn't a reason to scrub the program altogether, either.
- NtochkaNzvanova 5y agoWasn't implying that this particular program should be scrapped (though it was clearly implemented in crisis mode, with predictable lack of protection), only arguing against the OP's claim that the amount of abuse of social programs is small.
- dlp211 5y agoYou cited one program built quickly in an emergency. If you take something far more stable and longer running, say SNAP, only about 1.5% is established as fraud.
- jeffbee 5y agoThe fixation on "abuse" of social systems for the less wealthy is just a bias against the poor by relatively wealthy and powerful people. It's not just for food stamps and medicaid. Consider, for example, the utter fixation in the Bay Area with "fare jumping" on BART, where the compliance with the fare system is over 99%, compared with the complete silence among the public and the press on the topic of compliance with parking meters, which is known to stand at about 40%! People believe that armed police should be deployed to eek out the final 1% of BART fares, but nobody advocates for armed police to taser people who don't pay parking meters.
- thanatos519 5y agoExactly. "Public transit" should cost nothing and "Private transit" should pay for it. Unless of course the system doesn't require the distinction of Public vs Private, which it seems inevitably leads to parasitism.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- thanatos519 5y agoAnother Canadian anecdote is that when the government decided that people have been given more than they should have, most people returned the money. I have a great deal of anxiety that these folks aren't rowing: https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2021/oct/27/climate-crisis-villains-americas-dirty-dozen https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2021/oct/27/climat... ... and I mean "these folks" in the GW Bush sense.