7 ms·
which is what you would normally expect, on the other hand following the conservative narrative on these kinds of things my parents definitely would have spent
by bryanrasmussen 5y ago
which is what you would normally expect, on the other hand following the conservative narrative on these kinds of things my parents definitely would have spent it on gambling, drugs, and alcohol.
- yardie 5y agoConservatives != conservative politicians != conservative donors. UBI is incredibly popular amongst conservatives, except for 2 particular groups: conservative pols and their rich conservative donors.
- jandrese 5y agoThere is a big contingent that believes UBI would only increase "laziness". How are you supposed to staff an incredibly shitty low paying job if people aren't literally starving? Offering more money or better working conditions is a nonstarter, they would rather just move the work offshore.
- mythrwy 5y agoAlso a strong contingent that believes it makes poor macroeconomic sense as it simply increases inflation with no gains (but probable losses) in net societal standard of living.
- kfprt 5y agoThis is of course ridiculous. UBI money is much more likely to be spent increasing the velocity of money in the economy than if it were spent bailing out companies. It's very hard to run a consumer economy whilst making the consumers too poor to afford to spend much.
- what_is_orcas 5y agoI can't tell if this is satire, so I'll respond to it as though it is not. > How are you supposed to staff an incredibly shitty low paying job if people aren't literally starving? Why should anyone be forced to do that shitty of a job? Why can't the wage be increased and/or the quality of treatment be increased? > Offering more money or better working conditions is a nonstarter, they would rather just move the work offshore. This works for things like software developers, but not for the majority of food & service industry.
- jandrese 5y ago> Why should anyone be forced to do that shitty of a job? Why can't the wage be increased and/or the quality of treatment be increased? Because if you did that we wouldn't have billionaires.
- what_is_orcas 5y ago> Because if you did that we wouldn't have billionaires. that sounds like a good thing
- animal_spirits 5y agoYeah, I really think it depends on more factors than how much money they make. There's so many socioeconomic variables that influence behaviors. But, I do think it could be valuable to try certain models out to learn more about what affects spending.
- teddyh 5y agoHow about avoiding strawmanning people and instead argue with people’s actual opinions as they show up here?
- t-writescode 5y agoI know you're upset; and I know the parent comment above you is upset, as well. This is an exhausting argument on all sides because no one sees eye to eye and it really seems obvious to everyone why the other side is wrong.
- chickenpotpie 5y agoI’m sorry to use anecdotal evidence, but I have to strongly disagree this is a straw man. I spent the first 20 years of my life surrounded by strong conservative influences and the belief that people getting assistance are addicts and stupid with money is key to the conservative platform. Most of conservative economic beliefs rely on the idea that poor people are poor because they’re stupid or lazy.
- greenail 5y agoI would argue that the conservative economic view is not that poor people are stupid or lazy, rather government subsidy incentives (welfare/UBI) can motivate people to act stupid or lazy which ultimately only promotes the need for more government intervention. An endless cycle which ultimately results in enriching the government bureaucracy itself.
- bena 5y agoI would entertain that notion if they would apply that logic more evenly. But they don't, so I won't. Because when it comes to government subsidy incentives, the argument is made that it encourages businesses and the wealthy.
- dlp211 5y agoThat was a fine position to have prior to say 2000 when we didn't have a lot of good data and ways to analyze it. We now have data and incredible analysis tools, that outcome is not representative of what actually happens.
- ehihieuhntieu 5y agoWhat you've claimed was stated by the author of the study, and there may indeed be some who make such claims. However, I would characterize the conservative position thusly: 1) Government subsidies increase the rate of choices that lead to receiving subsidies. 2) Single-parent households represent the supermajority of low-income households. 3) Single-parent households result in the worst outcomes for children and society. 4) Becoming a single-parent household is a result of poor decision making. 5) Subsidizing single-parent households will increase the number of single-parent households, leading to worse outcomes for society, regardless of the effects on the individuals receiving subsidies.
- CheezeIt 5y agoThe conservative argument is that it’s theft. And that it would be spent in rent.
- thanatos519 5y agoI have a symmetric opinion: rent is theft.
- t-writescode 5y agoThe argument that taxation is theft is a libertarian one. Some conservatives are libertarian and some libertarians are conservative; but, it is not an exclusive stance.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- CheezeIt 5y agoNo, conservatives think transfer payments are theft. It’s not that it’s simply taxation.
- prepend 5y agoSpending on kids increased. I expect spending also increases on gambling, drugs, alcohol, etc. It’s not surprising that with more money, people spend more. People with kids spend on kids. But not kids exclusively. The question that wasn’t answered was whether this was an efficient intervention. If our goal is to help kids then there are likely other interventions that are better than cash to everyone, including non-parents (ie, daycare, school lunches, library programs, etc)
- yunohn 5y ago> higher-income households were also more likely to spend payouts on nondurables, which he speculates may be “lavish” spending, I find that expenses on recreation or lessons do not increase among parents across the socioeconomic spectrum and that only middle-income and, particularly, low-income families’ spending on education is responsive to payouts in the short term. This last result is aligned with a series of studies suggesting that lower-income parents may use cash transfers to “catch up” with their more affluent counterparts. From the paper, linked in the article. Quite disingenuous to assume that low income families must be wasting money on substances, while the statistics always show that richer individuals obviously can afford and do spend more.
- prepend 5y agoIt seems obvious that richer families spend more. They have more to spend. I am assuming that everyone just spends more on stuff. The part of interest, that I don’t see in the paper, is if the ratios change with added income. Not the absolute amounts. What is of interest to me is that if someone spent 10% of their disposable income on education, do they spend 10% of their extra cash on education? Or is it different. Likewise for substances. What’s the baseline percent and the percent spent of extra cash. And then compare across socioeconomic classes. It’s frustrating to see such bonehead statements like people who get money spend money without describe other things of interest. I don’t think anyone debates that rich people spend more than poor people.
- yunohn 5y ago
- CoastalCoder 5y ago> the conservative narrative Are you sure there's just one "conservative" narrative on the issue? Even if we limited the discussion to considerations that only conservatives find compelling, I suspect we'd see at least 2-3 distinct issues.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Proven 5y ago[dead]