4 ms·
I'd say the shape of our disagreement here follows a fundamental problem with the patent system. It's impossible to directly refute the argument that it only s
by mindslight 5y ago
I'd say the shape of our disagreement here follows a fundamental problem with the patent system.
It's impossible to directly refute the argument that it only seems obvious in retrospect, short of finding some people who became isolated/frozen/etc in Y2K and asking them to judge.
Which is why we look to prior art. But that forms a much weaker argument - while we've seen stackable bins and bin aggregation carts for decades, we hadn't seen them in use at high volume invasive security checkpoints, as such checkpoints didn't exist before. Does applying a longstanding technology to a newly needed purpose constitute invention?
The patent system asserts that this answer is undecidable, and thus defaults to issuing a patent. Whereas to everyone else looking at the constructive behavior of this system, it looks an awful lot like lawyers getting paid a bunch of money to generate paperwork that divvies up ownership of the intellectual commons.
- nickff 5y ago>"Does applying a longstanding technology to a newly needed purpose constitute invention?" Yes, if the technology is new in that 'field'.
- mindslight 5y agoSure if you're just describing the patent office's current policy. But based on the number of people who criticize patents for "X with computers" "X over a network" "X with advertising" etc, I'd say most people disagree that's how it should be. Granting monopolies on straightforward implementations of straightforward concepts for simply being the first to register does not drive innovation, it kills it.