3 ms·
Despite having a good chunk of my "retirement" money in the market, I try to avoid paying much attention to it's day to day issues. So no, I did not see what ha
by PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago
Despite having a good chunk of my "retirement" money in the market, I try to avoid paying much attention to it's day to day issues. So no, I did not see what happened to MSFT.
But look, the point is that there are two fundamental reasons to buy a stock. One is to collect dividends paid to stock owners (so called "blue chip" stocks). The other is because you believe the price of the stock will rise. (For the big players, there's also the issue of corporate control, but that's not a factor for most investors, even many institutional ones)
There are many reasons why the price of a stock will rise. One of them could be more people wanting in on the dividend payout, and them being willing to pay (a bit) more than the current price. That could happen due to demographic changes (ie. shifts in the number of people who want dividend paying stocks), it could happen due to a change in the expectation of what those dividends will be (as in your MSFT example).
But it can also (and demonstrably has) happen(ed) that the price rises because derivative beliefs about the likely future price. And that's precisely what happened in the case of amzn and dozens if not hundreds of tech startups over decades: there was never any profit (and in some cases there never would be any profit), but there was a belief about either:
1. that future profit would be above a certain level
2. the number of people who believed in 1, and so would drive the price up
3. the number of people who believed in 2, and so would drive the price up
4. [ repeat as deep as you think feasible ]
As for the Gates anecdote, I prefer the stories from German CEOs who express wonderment at the idea that anyone would pay attention to quarterly results.
- WalterBright 5y agoAgain, it all boils down to expectation of future profit. It makes no difference (except for tax purposes) if the dividends are paid to shareholders, or if they are retained and the stock price goes up by the amount of the dividend. As the differing tax treatment of capital gains and dividends changes, companies change their dividend payouts to match. > But it can also (and demonstrably has) happen(ed) that the price rises because derivative beliefs about the likely future price. And that's precisely what happened in the case of amzn The future price reflects expectation of profit. Amazon actually creates quite a bit of profit, they just plow it back into the business.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoYou've modified your claim quite a bit. > The value of a corporation is inevitably linked to its profits. > Again, it all boils down to expectation of future profit. Maybe you feel these are equivalent statements. I don't. I think they are fundamentally different. People's expectations about a company's future profitability are, to me, entirely different from a company's actual profit. Blue chip companies have stock values that are tightly tied to their actual profit, unless there's some reason to think they might be on the verge of some sort of breakthrough that will make the stock price climb dramatically (because of anticipated future growth). Non-blue-chips have stock values that have a substantial component derived entirely from 1st, 2nd or 3rd order expectations about profit, and this can move stock prices dramatically even though there is no actual change in the company's profitability. So, if you had only said "it all boils down to (1st, 2nd or 3rd order expectation of future profit", I'd agree with you. But you started by saying "the value of a corporation is linked to its profits", and I can't agree with that except for blue chip (type) companies.