4 ms·
>services providing reverse chronological feeds should be considered platforms while services providing algorithmic feeds should be considered publishers A rev
by krapp 5y ago
>services providing reverse chronological feeds should be considered platforms while services providing algorithmic feeds should be considered publishers
A reverse chronological feed is no more or less algorithmic than any other - any sort requires an algorithm. You're just criminalizing algorithmic complexity, which is insane. There's no reason the same n items in a list should expose a site owner to different degrees of legal liability because they're sorted one way versus another.
What about cases when the user can choose a different sort? Is a company liable based on whether or not a user decided they wanted to see content in anything other than strict chronological order? Is Twitter publishing or promoting content as soon as users tag it? Does sorting by karma make Hacker News a "publisher" of content? Do downvotes and flags count as "promotion" of the downvoted content, or all non-downvoted content?
- donmcronald 5y ago> What about cases when the user can choose a different sort? Is a company liable based on whether or not a user decided they wanted to see content in anything other than strict chronological order? No. If I’m asking for it and they give me what I asked for, that’s not publishing. If they pick some content that would normally be buried and jam it in my face because some ML algorithm thinks it’ll cause engagement that’s publishing. > You're just criminalizing algorithmic complexity, which is insane. I don’t think it’s insane. I think letting black box ML algorithms moderate public discourse is insane. I have no problem with that being turned into a liability for big tech.
- adgjlsfhk1 5y agowhat about spam filters?