9 ms·
Why do placebos work? Scientists identify key brain pathway
- dairylee 5y ago> The placebo effect can bring powerful relief Can it? I don't believe there are any studies that actually show this.
- Pyramus 5y agoYes, that's the reason RCTs are contrasted against placebo not no treatment. If you want too see how powerful this effect can become look no further than acupuncture. Or, for a nocebo result, people have actually died because they thought they had been cursed. Or, maybe less dramatic, people who are given an alcohol placebo still get drunk. Not all, but some do, and we don't know why they specifically and why at all.
- lotsofpulp 5y ago> Or, for a nocebo result, people have actually died because they thought they had been cursed Source? I have yet to hear about an objective malady that can be fixed via placebo/nocebo, like stage 4 cancer, type 1 diabetes, etc.
- ChefboyOG 5y agoI don't know of people dying from a belief that they were cursed, but we do certainly know that placebos can have very real, measurable neurobiological effects. For example, there many studies looking at the body's response to placebo painkillers. The brain often releases neurotransmitters that bind to opioid receptors as if an actual painkiller had been taken: https://www.nature.com/articles/535S14a https://www.nature.com/articles/535S14a The original comment was about placebos bringing "powerful relief," which there is a great deal of scientific research to support. As far as I'm aware, there is no serious medical researcher advancing the hypothesis that stage 4 cancer or type 1 diabetes should or can be treated via placebos.
- cainxinth 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kurdaitcha#Bone_pointing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kurdaitcha#Bone_pointing
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kipchak 5y agoI'm not up to date on if there are any counter opinions to this, but I've heard that placebo's are similar in effect to SSRIs[1] - Though as always there's a lot of buts/ifs there.[2] My assumption is that a placebo causes people to expect things to get better and reduces stress levels, increases sleep quality and so on. I would figure a very supportive social network (family, prayer group) would probably have a similar effect. That being said like you say for something more severe the placebo alone isn't going to do much, but I would imagine if you gave people a placebo that they thought would improve their stage 4 cancer recovery you would probably see an effect. [1]https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4172306/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4172306/ [2]https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4592645/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4592645/
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago"Objective malady" is a deliberately loaded term. Generally in medicine there's a distinction between acute conditions and chronic conditions. Allopathic (western) medicine has proved highly effective at treating acute conditions, including trauma/injury, certain forms of cancer and infection. However, chronic conditions are still one of the primary experiences of many humans relating to their health, and allopathic medicine has generally done quite poorly at addressing these conditions. Other styles of treatment, including placebo, have been shown to be effective in at least reducing the severity or incidence of the symptoms associated with chronic conditions. The fact that you don't want to consider someone's 20 year battle with chronic back pain, or neuropathy, or any other chronic condition, to be "an objective malady" doesn't make you the arbiter of what's real and what isn't.
- lotsofpulp 5y ago> The fact that you don't want to consider someone's 20 year battle with chronic back pain, or neuropathy, or any other chronic condition, to be "an objective malady" doesn't make you the arbiter of what's real and what isn't. Objective means measurable, definable, quantifiable. It has nothing to do with real or not. The human body is so complex with so many possibilities, I find it uninteresting to speculate about unknowns, hence restricting my request to what I am interested in. Dying is an objective condition observable by others, so it piqued my interest as to how it was determined someone died due to a nocebo.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoMost/many chronic conditions cannot be measured, defined, or quantified. The sufferer can give you some estimate on some scale that you describe that relates to the intensity and nature of their experiences. I'm very glad to have seen an increasing number of health care professionals say things along the lines of "we have no idea what is causing their experience, and in fact, we think most it may be entirely psychogenic, but that doesn't change the fact that this is what they are actually experiencing, and that's as real for them as a puncture wound or an infection."
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- allturtles 5y ago> Yes, that's the reason RCTs are contrasted against placebo not no treatment. I don't think so. Placebo is used to blind participants to which study arm they are in. The placebo effect was then discovered after the fact.
- Pyramus 5y agoYou are not wrong - placebos are a practical way to blind a study. The best way to blind, however, is no treatment, but no treatment only gives you the efficacy of the treatment, and not what you actually want to know, the efficacy of the 'active ingredient'. See e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Placebo-controlled_study#Natural_history_groups https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Placebo-controlled_study#Natur...
- wyager 5y agoPlacebos probably don’t do much of anything compared to no treatment. It’s almost all mean reversion. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12535498/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12535498/
- FabHK 5y agoExactly. Thanks, I had forgotten where I had read that, this is a nice source. Here's the TL'DR: The placebo effect is maybe not quite as powerful as it is sometimes made out to be. And the reason is spontaneous remission or reversion to the mean. 1. Initially, researchers tested a treatment, and when the patients got healthier, it was assumed that it was the treatment. 2. Then researchers got smarter, and tested a treatment against a placebo (control), ideally double blind and randomised etc., and when the control group got better, it was assumed to be the placebo effect, and when the treatment group got even better, the difference was the treatment effect. 3. Then researchers got even smarter, and tested a treatment against a placebo (control) and against no treatment at all, and when the no-treatment group got better, it was assumed to be reversion to the mean or spontaneous remission; when the control group got even better, that difference was the placebo effect; and when the treatment group got even better, that difference was the treatment effect. Going from 1. to 2., it was realised that many treatments are not quite as potent as hoped, and that the placebo effect is quite strong. However, going from 2. to 3., it was realised that the placebo effect is not quite as potent either, and that there is considerable spontaneous remission or reversion to the mean.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoIf you're going to reference papers from 2004, you should likely follow up on their subsequent citations and refutations: 2007 paper that specifically cites Hróbjartsson et al., but claims that they overlooked certain specific effects: https://bmcmedicine.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/1741-7015-5-3 https://bmcmedicine.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/1741-... 2019 review that also cites Hróbjartsson et al., but catches up on subsequent and broader placebo/nocebo research and concludes that both still seem efficaceous in the right contexts. https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpsyt.2019.00365/full#B29 https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpsyt.2019.0036...
- wyager 5y agoGood question. It’s a shame that you’re being downvoted. It’s not clear that placebos actually do anything. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12535498/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12535498/
- Pyramus 5y agoDo you expect a single study to overturn decades of research and medical practice? Leaving aside that 'absence of evidence is not evidence of absence', that would need to be extraordinary evidence, right? I'm not surprised at all you doubt the existence - it's a very common phenomenon that modern medicine/science struggles to explain (yet) and it's a very weird phenomenon. E.g. placebos still work when you know it's a placebo, it works for animals, it works so well that insurance will cover it etc. Maybe Bad Science by Ben Goldacre is a good starting point as a book.
- wyager 5y ago> Do you expect a single study This is a meta study. > to overturn decades of research and medical practice? “Medical practice” has an atrocious record of being based in fact. There is, in fact, plenty of research on placebo, and the preponderance seems to suggest that it’s weak or non-existent. > E.g. placebos still work when you know it's a placebo, it works for animals This is consistent with, and in fact favors, the theory that it’s actually just mean reversion. > Maybe Bad Science by Ben Goldacre is a good starting point as a book I don’t think pop scientism books are a good place to start.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoSee my other response to this link at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29028133 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29028133
- andrewon 5y agoThat reminds me of the idea that brain as a predictive engine that constantly refine its internal model to match anticipated sensory outcome. In this case the inference is way more complex based on cognition that the placebo would help relieve pain. Based on this idea, however, the study does not identify the key pathway responsible for placebo effect, but only the result of it. If the brain anticipate relief of pain, the parts related to pain would activate. If it anticipates other effects, other parts of the brain would do.
- WORMS_EAT_WORMS 5y agoSuper interesting comment and thoughts. Thanks for sharing - I never thought of it this way.
- rtkaratekid 5y agoIf the brain anticipates relief from pain, wouldn’t the parts of the brain relates to pain be depressed rather than activated?
- refurb 5y agoThink further downstream, beyond the pain sensing part of the brain. So opioids are know to be great pain relievers. What is interesting is for certain types of pain, they don’t actually make the pain go away, they just change the perception and emotional response to it. Patients who receive opioids say “i can still feel the pain, but it doesn’t bother me now”. So to your question, the impact of opioids isn’t necessarily on the pain sensing centers but rather further downstream in terms of how those sensations are perceived. If you take a placebo and expect it to relieve pain, your brain adjusts to assume that outcome. It’s not that different than asking you if you’re tired right now. If you have to go to work you might say “yes”, but if you’re about to jump on a plane for a vacation you might say “no”.
- nefitty 5y agoMy likely oversimplified understanding of dopamine is that the brain is constantly simulating the outcomes of possible actions. Simulated actions that result in "success" states generate dopamine, with different pathways generating varying levels at any one time. The pathway that generates the greatest net dopamine is pursued, the realized outcome of which then reinforces/dampens the path's simulation function by generating other neurotransmitters.
- captainmuon 5y agoI've never understood placebos. Naively you'd assume they work the other way around, as the body attempts to achive homeostatis. So if you think you have taken a pain killer, the body would ramp up pain sensitivity to counter it. But as far as I know a lot of studies have shown placebos work. One thing I haven't seen discussed is that maybe there is a subconcious social pressure element to placebos. Like: I just got a big injection from the doctor, surely it is going to help, I can't complain yet again about it. Sometimes I wonder, what if people take a placebo, report that they feel better, but continue to suffer internally? And are not even able to identify this, because their internal pain gauge is affected by the placebo. They think it helps. Maybe you could detect this by non-voluntary indicators of pain - avoidance reflexes, concentration loss, etc.. Back to the homeostatis argument, there are placebo-like effects that accidentially work. In autogenic training, you can warm up your body parts by imagining fire. What I think happens is, the body anticipates heat, widens the blood vessels to regulate against the heat, but in the cold environment this actually warms up your arms or legs.
- notjosh 5y agoI think my favourite simple example to illustrate this is thinking of (or image searching a picture of) a lemon. A lot of people can feel increased saliva production under their tongue, despite nothing at all actually changing, in anticipation of the sourness. Brains are magical :)
- iamcurious 5y agoYou are onto something factoring social pressure. Social pressure has a direction, if a doctor says you are going to get better it is creating a pressure on yourself to get better. In many cases that pressure might be all you need. The homeostasis effect might happen in an adversial situation. Say instead of a doctor, an opponent says something. It might cause to overcompensate in the opposite way. We could call that reverse placebo or by its more common name "spite".
- locallost 5y agoThere is a lot to how you perceive something that influences how you will react to what's going on. I was just today thinking about the difference between how both my children were born. There were so similar in the time they happened, how they were late, how the birth was triggered etc. But in the first case we were picked up by an emergency vehicle (there was no emergency, they just told us to do this), so it was dark, with this scary blue light as if somebody is dying, to some hectic in the hospital. And in the second we went very quietly to our appointment, rode the bus on a sunny day, took a relaxing walk outside the hospital as we were waiting etc. When it was done with the first, my wife was pale and shivering, completely out of everything, and with the second she was just exhausted but could still smile and enjoy taking our newborn. And she looked happy. Of course there is the case of the first being more scary because of the unknowns, but you could also make a case that it was so traumatic that it should've ruined the second one. I also fell down on ice once and had a case of whiplash. I got worried as I was reading about the potential long term, especially in the US. And I then switched to the German Wikipedia that said doctors in Germany tell patients to relax for a few days and it will go away, and that long term issues are virtually unknown. You could go on and on really. When you go to a doctor and they have almost no time for you, you will not feel better. Compare that with going in to somebody doing homeopathy. A friend told me they went and got a cup of tea and an hour to talk about their health issues. So the body is obviously complicated.
- dr-detroit 5y agoMore like why does anybody think chemical treatments are so effective when the studies are totally crooked? The placebo effect is just reality correcting the numbers for you.
- hyperpallium2 5y agoIt's been experimentally shown that the placebo effect is enhanced by being administered in a hospital-like setting, by a person dressed as a doctor, with a big + on a big pill. My personal theory is that if you have convincing evidence that you are safe and being looked after, your body can divert resources to deal with the problem, instead of being on guard.
- jrs235 5y agoWhich begs the question: If placebos (sometimes) work, (particularly when administered in hospital settings and when expensive, at least in the eyes/brain of the patient) is it unethical to administer/provide them?
- pfortuny 5y agoIt is unethical to say that you are administering a medicine when you are not doing it, except in trials to which the subject has agreed.
- Tyrannosaur 5y agoI 100% agree, but that doesn't mean we can't still administer placebos: I've read elsewhere that you don't have to lie to the person to still have a successful placebo effect- they can still receive a benefit even knowing it's not a real drug.
- Buttons840 5y agoPlacebos work even when people know it's a placebo. We might want to establish a baseline, like the pretender has to remind the patient he's just a pretender once a year. But if a pretend doctor can help, then go for it.
- agumonkey 5y agoI agree. Similarly relativism can evaporate some pain. You can feel pretty bad if you think you're alone in a situation. Just knowing someone went through the same issue relieves part of the pain, even though nothing changed in your life.
- vlovich123 5y agoIs there any research into the variation of susceptibility to placebos? My gut feeling is that there are people who are much more susceptible and those who are much less, and I’m curious if that’s supported by any research and, if so, how that difference is developed. Also, I’m confused by the conclusion of the article. If they’re literally exciting or dampening a control pathway in the brain that controls pain, how is this placebo/nocebo? Sounds like a straight up causal effect, not a vague one controlled by the patient’s expectation….
- cariaso 5y agoyes https://www.snpedia.com/index.php/Rs4680 https://www.snpedia.com/index.php/Rs4680 and the others mentioned at https://www.snpedia.com/index.php/Placebo https://www.snpedia.com/index.php/Placebo
- tantalor 5y agoSeems strange they would use petroleum jelly which is a well known treatment for burns. It is not a placebo; it's not inert like sugar pill or saline. This could seriously skew the results towards "pain relief" end of spectrum.
- dcow 5y agoIt’s a moisturizer that treats water loss and protects skin in the presence of real burns. It doesn't do anything to pain. These people weren’t burned. And I think Lubaderm is more commonly “well known” these days.
- lngnmn2 5y agoBrain is conditioned by the sensory input augmented with "verbal knowledge" (how it is encoded is irrelevant). Religious and mystic experiences work exactly the same way. When many other people around you do strange things they start to make sense. So, basically, it is fooling of neural nets by giving strong cues or whatever you might call them. In religion such strong cues are other people's facial expressions and body language. The brain's neural networks recognize strong signals of "taking positive actions" or whatever.
- ramblenode 5y agoThis is the connection more people should be making. The placebo effect is a social effect. Somebody else whom you trust has given you something. More generally it is an expectation, but the double-blind nature of placebo studies means that it is also always a social transaction. The effect is boosted by the perceived authority of the prescriber (white coat, hospital, colored pill). The same mechanism probably underlies higher survival of religious-minded cancer patients.
- podiki 5y agoWhile I always thought placebo (and nocebo) is quite amazing, I've had that tempered from some reading of it perhaps not being a large effect beyond a regression to the mean. For example, here's one paper [0], with a quote from the abstract "Analysis of the trial outcomes demonstrated that the reduction observed in the placebo group was of the same magnitude as predicted by regression to the mean." Or from [1] in their summary: "In clinical practice, the phenomenon [regression to the mean] can lead to misinterpretation of results of tests, new treatments, and the placebo effect" This has been discussed in some popular sources as well, like the fun book The Math of Life and Death by Kit Yates. [0] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15975061/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15975061/ [1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1125994/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1125994/ Edit: see also this helpful explanation elsewhere in the comments [2]. The thread there highlights this paper [3] with the key conclusion of "There was no evidence that placebo interventions in general have clinically important effects. A possible moderate effect on subjective continuous outcomes, especially pain, could not be clearly distinguished from bias." [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29025886 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29025886 [3] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12535498/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12535498/
- Pyramus 5y agoA couple of comments (not a medical expert): It's likely that the placebo/nocebo effect is confounded by regression to the mean - a typical example are diseases with some sort of cyclical pattern, e.g. some forms of depression. But there is strong evidence that there is an effect beyond that: E.g. cancer patients die significantly sooner when they get a negative prognosis [1]. Acupuncture is so effective for treating certain forms of chronic (!) pain that in some cases it's covered by German health insurance since 2007 [2]. If you have been treated in a hospital for pain related issues, e.g. after a surgery, it's not unlikely you have received placebo instead of pain killers (depends a lot on jurisdiction). Regarding [3] specifically, the obvious elephant in the room is that 'absence of evidence is not evidence of absence'. Also see the refutations pointed out by user PaulDavisThe1st [4]. What I take away from that study is that yes, in some contexts, regression to the mean may account for a major portion of the placebo effect. [1] https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(73)91754-6 https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(73)91754-6 [2] https://www.verbraucherzentrale.de/wissen/gesundheit-pflege/aerzte-und-kliniken/akupunktur-wann-zahlt-die-kasse-12462 https://www.verbraucherzentrale.de/wissen/gesundheit-pflege/... [3] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12535498/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12535498/ [4] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29028133 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29028133
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- m3kw9 5y agoPsychological effect can amplify the pain you are experiencing. By really noticing and associating the pain with something worse than it is, it makes it hurt more. Placebo can take your mind off it and make it less noticeable.
- twofornone 5y agoSo how does one deliberately trick oneself to benefit from the placebo effect when knowingly receiving a placebo? I guess ignorance really is bliss.
- mathattack 5y agoCall me a pedant but it kills me when these are done on such a small sample size. (27 participants)
- wolverine876 5y agoVolunteer for studies?
- mdp2021 5y agoIf that were the problem, improve recruitment.
- wolverine876 5y agoBased on limited conversation with researchers, they are constrained by budget for experimental subjects and other resources (equipment, drugs, staff, etc.).
- mathattack 5y agoOnce you have a hint that there may be something there, it’s worth seeing if it holds for a larger same size.
- wolverine876 5y agoI would love to see a thread of people describing their own placebo responses, but one difficult part of understanding the response is that few people will admit to it.
- Noe2097 5y agoThis article/study is all and only about "pain modulation". Is it to say that there is only one placebo effect, which is always reducing pain? Aren't there placebo effects going "beyond" pain relieving? (Or is it the title that is generalizing the scope of the analysis too much?)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- richardatlarge 5y agoWe did a spoof ad for a psychiatry magazine when I was at Adbusters: https://static.substack.com/p/now-available https://static.substack.com/p/now-available
- paperoli 5y agoThe reason it works is because consciousness is fundamental to reality as shown by double slit experiments. The viewer creates their reality. A tree doesn’t fall in the woods if no one is there to see it.