12 ms·
1.1.1.1 for Families
- jwalton 5y agoSince I see from your domain name that you are in Canada, might I suggest Canadian Shield[0] from CIRA (the .ca registry) as an alternative to 1.1.1.1? I have an article about setting it up via PiHole, too[1]. [0]: https://www.cira.ca/cybersecurity-services/canadian-shield https://www.cira.ca/cybersecurity-services/canadian-shield [1]: http://www.thedreaming.org/2020/11/07/pihole/ http://www.thedreaming.org/2020/11/07/pihole/
- emreb 5y agoWhat is the definition of Malware in this case? Which malware list does it use?
- tinuzzo 5y agoOn the malware intelligence, it is a combination of first party threat intelligence (what we see on our own network) and third-party threat intelligence across open source intelligence, specialized malware intelligence vendors, and private threat sharing communities.
- 8fingerlouie 5y agoLooks like a great alternative to NextDNS if you can do without any special configuration. For me, NextDNS is still better. I can setup separate DNS zones for adults, children, IOT, etc. and it works across networks (unlike Pihole/AdguardHome). I can also setup DNS forwards for each zone.
- Terretta 5y agoYou're not even mentioning that NextDNS blocks ads and trackers. This release claims: > * Since launching 1.1.1.1, the number one request we have received is to provide a version of the product that automatically filters out bad sites.* Really? More asked for than ad blocking or tracker blocking?
- caskstrength 5y agoYeah, I would also love to get NextDNS-style offering fro CloudFlare. I'm currently have multiple malware/spyware/adds/annoyances filters enabled and I need them on DNS level because having uBlock Origin in my browser doesn't help me, for example, to prevent spying by my smart TV or phone apps.
- paol 5y agoHate to break it to you, but DNS level blocking won't help you either. Lots of this kind of spying is done through fixed IP addresses.
- WA 5y agoWhat do you suggest instead?
- derwiki 5y agoBlocking traffic to bad IPs entirely, not just blocking DNS resolution to bad IPs.
- caskstrength 5y agoPlease define "lots" and provide source.
- totallymike 5y agoIt will still help, but it won’t prevent this specific issue, to be clear.
- brightball 5y agoNextDNS is fantastic. I love the level of control and flexibility it gives me to set network wide controls and then simple bypasses for the grown ups in the house.
- legrande 5y agoNextDNS is great and all, but it's another third party that could be handing your data over to god knows who. PiHole is local and I don't have to worry about my data being misused.
- 8fingerlouie 5y agoPiHole also performs upstream DNS lookups, which could also be handed over to 3rd parties, be that Google (8.8.8.8), or Cloudflare (1.1.1.1), or even your own ISP. With NextDNS you at least have a TOS that specifies "1. We do not (and will never) sell, license, sublicense or share any of the data submitted directly or indirectly by our users with any person or entity. NextDNS Inc. is an independent company 100% funded, owned and controlled by its founders and will never engage in any data sharing or selling activities, now or in the future." As well as the option to keep logs in the EU, and thus place it under the GDPR, and since IP traffic information is generally classified as PIM, it will be covered.
- Wowfunhappy 5y agoDiscussed at the time: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22748141 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22748141
- naranha 5y agoWorks great from my experience. What's missing and why I'm not using it atm is DNS64 and TLS support.
- bhaavan 5y agoThis was published on `01-April-2020`. So was it a joke or was it not?
- easygenes 5y agoFor me the publish date shows as April 2. They also explicitly say it’s not a joke and explain their own April tradition in the article.
- tinuzzo 5y agoNot a joke.
- dtech 5y agoIt's adressed in the article > However, we've made it a tradition every April 1 to launch a new consumer product that leverages our network to bring more speed, reliability, and security to every Internet user.
- b215826 5y agoI used to use 1.1.1.1 till the day I realized that it doesn't resolve archive.is [1]. I don't particularly care what the details are, whose fault it is, etc., but as an end user, I see this a major problem because with 1.1.1.1 if my browser is unable to resolve a domain, I wouldn't know if it's my DNS's fault or if it's the site's without an explicit check. I also don't care much for family "protection", so right now I don't see a good reason for using Cloudflare over Quad9. [1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21155056 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21155056 [2]: https://www.quad9.net/ https://www.quad9.net/
- codetrotter 5y ago> I don't particularly care what the details are, whose fault it is, etc. https://jarv.is/notes/cloudflare-dns-archive-is-blocked/ https://jarv.is/notes/cloudflare-dns-archive-is-blocked/
- netizen-936824 5y agoThank you! This is incredibly informative on the situation and makes sense. It also makes me happy with clouflare's choice
- stavros 5y agoIt doesn't have the owner's side on it, though, which is not as evil as the article makes it sound. I can post more information when I'm home, but he basically uses that info to thwart attacks.
- jrwr 5y agoThis has come up a few times. Mostly the owner is set in their ways and are mad at CF for not providing the DNS flags that allow outside CDNs to figure out what IP you are closest to. From a 2019 thread about this: The archive.is owner has explained that he returns bad results to us because we don’t pass along the EDNS subnet information. This information leaks information about a requester’s IP and, in turn, sacrifices the privacy of users. This is especially problematic as we work to encrypt more DNS traffic since the request from Resolver to Authoritative DNS is typically unencrypted. We’re aware of real world examples where nationstate actors have monitored EDNS subnet information to track individuals, which was part of the motivation for the privacy and security policies of 1.1.1.1. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19828317 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19828317
- bserge 5y ago*for "dysfunctional" families. It's not even blocking TikTok! :D
- New_California 5y agoOne should use DNS servers offered by one's VPN provider. Otherwise, it leaks to both VPN provider and DNS provider.
- so_throwaway 5y agoThis is irrelevant, no one using a VPN is also configuring a 'family-friendly' DNS resolver.
- skrebbel 5y agoWhy not? I use a VPN to give my half-Danish children access to Danish TV from outside Denmark, and I also have, well, children who I might want to protect against evil content such as nipples. I don't do the latter but that has little to do with the fact that I use a VPN sometimes and more to do with the fact that we're not American and American ideas of what's "family friendly" feel extremely alien to us. In fact, given that they have an option that blocks malware but not nipples, I might actually use this.
- so_throwaway 5y agoI mean, you don't seem to be a counter-example to the claim that "no one using a VPN is also configuring a 'family-friendly' DNS resolver".
- DeathArrow 5y agoHow cool would it be to be able to only allow malware but not nipples? :D
- ec109685 5y agoDon’t most vpn providers encapsulate both udp and tcp?
- drexlspivey 5y agoI had to stop using 1.1.1.1 because I am getting rate limited when using their “cloudflared” dns-over-https proxy. My pretty modest home network and the various services running make 20-25k queries per day and I get a lot of REFUSED responses. Google on the other hand has no problem serving all of them. I even set a local cache to bypass the dns TTL but the problem is that sometimes 10 or more queries arrive at the same moment from a service.
- omegalulw 5y agoWhy can't you not set up a local DNS on any PC backed by 1.1.1.1 if you really want to stay with Cloudflare?
- jgrahamc 5y agoDid you talk to someone at Cloudflare about this? That sounds... odd.
- elithrar 5y agoAs John says - sounds odd - but please drop me an email with more details - silverlock at cloudflare Understanding the # of unique names, peak QPS, % of response types, etc will help. I consider it a “bug” if you can take the same profile of DNS queries to another resolver and see no issues ;-)
- danuker 5y ago> 10 or more queries arrive at the same moment from a service. I suspect you hit some sub-second ratelimit.
- FunnyLookinHat 5y agoThat's not too many requests, but running any form of a home network would still benefit moderately from a local DNS server. You could even install something like dnsmasq on the most heavy-using boxes to cache lookups locally. Granted, I'm saying this as yet another home-network admin who hasn't quite... ahem... gotten around to installing a DNS server. ^_^; I'm mostly sharing this here in case someone else has a similar problem and wants a solution.
- vultour 5y agoI know they consider "1.1.1.1" to also be a product name, but it's very confusing when the text says 1.1.1.1 50 times, and then there's 2 mentions of "Oh, the service is at 1.1.1.2".
- nobrains 5y agoThe name they could have used: 1.1.1.2 (1.1.1.1 for families) Or more correct: 1.1.1.3 (1.1.1.1 for families)
- yjftsjthsd-h 5y agoIt still results in kinda weird readings when the product name is also one of its subproducts but not all of them. Like a coffee shop called "The Big Cup" with a menu "The Big Cup", "The Medium Cup" and "The Small Cup".
- _fat_santa 5y agoThey laid it out pretty simply in the article: 1.1.1.1 - General 1.1.1.2 - No Malware 1.1.1.3 - No adult content Personally I like how they laid this out, makes it super easy to remember.
- unityByFreedom 5y agoI like it too. If Cloudflare posts become the impetus for reading the article, all the better. Their posts are well written and they don't burden the reader with what the editor wants you to know after hooking you with a headline.
- systemvoltage 5y ago1.1.2.1 - General with no ads 1.1.2.2 - No Malware and no ads 1.1.2.3 - No adult content and no ads This would be amazing if they have the guts to do it. I suspect they will one day when they become huge (they're already handling some 10% of global internet traffic). Today, I want a big corporate pi hole that is managed for me - enough fire power to block shitty ads. Completely undercut Google, FB, Twitter ad machines. More eggregious are the media companies such as Adobe and their ad-tech. For businesses ads are super important and we also need to consider the other side of the coin.
- imglorp 5y agoHow about 1.1.1.3, pi-hole?
- flatiron 5y agoi use 1.1.1.2 as my dns on my pihole. just in case they catch something pihole doesn't
- jpmonette 5y agoFor the most up to date information about 1.1.1.1 for Families, here's their product page: https://1.1.1.1/family/ https://1.1.1.1/family/
- jaimex2 5y agoDNS filters are a joke, too easy to bypass.
- arlcode 5y agoIf your 12 year old is getting a malicious link via whatsapp on their tablet it can make a difference. (e.g. they'll ask you why this doesn't work and you might explain malware etc) It's certainly not something for every circumstance, but given that most people (including family members) are just end users makes sense.
- eloisant 5y agoIf my teenager figures out DNS and manages to bypass it, I'd be proud.
- jaimex2 5y agoYou mean if they ask Google what to do?
- leesalminen 5y agoThat’s always been my rule of thumb, too. I still remember defeating NetNanny on the PC my parents gave me 20 years ago. My dad was proud of me.
- dmw_ng 5y agoAll providers are in on this "free" public DNS scam for the same reason, and it makes me wonder why anyone would voluntarily donate their entire home's click analytics to a super-aggregator free of charge. Did I miss the link to the payment page? Cisco at least release some low frequency summaries of the data they are able to collect: https://s3-us-west-1.amazonaws.com/umbrella-static/index.html https://s3-us-west-1.amazonaws.com/umbrella-static/index.htm...
- apecat 5y agoCloudflare's public DNS's privacy promises are audited by KPMG https://www.bleepingcomputer.com/news/security/cloudflares-1111-dns-passes-privacy-audit-some-issues-found/ https://www.bleepingcomputer.com/news/security/cloudflares-1...
- dmw_ng 5y agoThat is almost 2 years old, and does not seem to cover aggregate processing applied before the logs are deleted. FWIW stripping the last octet is the same as happens in EDNS, it is far from anonymous.
- cnst 5y agoSo, they basically still collect, log and process the exact same data as Google DNS, but disallow anyone else from having it, breaking legitimate uses of DNS for GeoIP targeting and DoS mitigation? How convenient!
- yjftsjthsd-h 5y ago> legitimate uses of DNS for GeoIP targeting and DoS mitigation What legitimate uses would those be, and how is DNS involved in DoS mitigation?
- cnst 5y agoA good example is Cloudflare's own CDN business — they require you to delegate your domain name to their DNS servers by name, not by IP address with your own glue records on your own domain name. Because they want to be able to use all the resources available to stop DDoS, including EDNS Client Subnet provided by other resolvers. Same goes for GeoIP — EDNS Client Subnet was specifically created for effective and cheap GeoIP. (BGP anycast isn't cheap.) I mean, both issues are exactly why archive.is had to put the block in place. For sure both of these usecases are pretty legitimate. BTW, what's the actual legitimate need to block ECS? After a domain name is resolved by DNS, you still have to connect directly to the hostname by an IP address, and your IP will be leaked — there's no way around this, that's how internet works. Cloudflare knowingly runs these marketing campaigns trying to obscure this simple fact that easily invalidates the need for their services, and invalidates the benefits of their service compared to competition.
- muglug 5y agoNeeds a (2020)
- kd913 5y agoWhy is this here? It was launched last year? Also, people should really be using Dnscrypt-proxy/DoH/DoT. Otherwise it's really easy for your ISP just to read/capture your DNS requests.
- deskamess 5y agoI was happy to set up 1.1.1.1 for my daughter on her Iphone7 but it never seemed to work well with Mobile Data (Freedom Mobile Canada). Internet would always be spotty/non-existent. The app being used was Google Classroom. In the end we turned off 1.1.1.1 and Google Classroom started working. Anyone experience anything similar?
- xd1936 5y agoDid you set up both 1.1.1.3/1.0.0.3 and also 2606:4700:4700::1113/2606:4700:4700::1003? Maybe there was some IPv6 issues. https://developers.cloudflare.com/1.1.1.1/1.1.1.1-for-families https://developers.cloudflare.com/1.1.1.1/1.1.1.1-for-famili...
- flatiron 5y agothis is definitely the solution, mobile is mostly ipv6 in my experience
- adamcharnock 5y agoOne thing I can think of is: perhaps some sections (all?) of their network is IPv6 only, and the carrier does XLAT64. In which case they would provide custom dns servers which resolve IPv4 dns records to IPv6 addresses. Custom DNS servers would not do that, therefore IPv4-only services would not work. May well have been something else though.
- Mindwipe 5y agoLaunched last year. Was incredibly abusive against sexual minorities then, and is still the same. A product anyone who built it should be genuinely ashamed of.
- TOMDM 5y agoCan you please expand on this, I'm not familiar with the controversy and don't understand what you mean
- WORMS_EAT_WORMS 5y agoIf I recall, some sites providing help and information on certain things were flagged as adult content and blocked which made a bunch of people mad. Cloudflare I think corrected a bunch, came out with a fairly reasonable explanation why, and then even showed how to setup special rules to override it.
- kemayo 5y agoCloudflare's explanation: https://blog.cloudflare.com/the-mistake-that-caused-1-1-1-3-to-block-lgbtqia-sites-today/ https://blog.cloudflare.com/the-mistake-that-caused-1-1-1-3-... They said that one of their providers for site-classifications had two feeds called "adult content", one which was a fairly clear porn-blocker, and one which included the LGBTQIA+ stuff as well. Apparently when they launched they flubbed which of those feeds was used because of the name-confusion.
- rappatic 5y agoMind explaining what you mean by this?
- motyar 5y agoIs there a version of 1.1.1.1 for broke? With ad-blocking!
- lupire 5y agoAdGuard DNS
- funOtter 5y agoPosted 2020-04-01 ... why is it relevant now?
- dcow 5y agoThis is from April last year and needs a 2020 tag.
- NikolaNovak 5y agoWoW I just realized this... thx. It does put some perspective :)
- nkrisc 5y agoAny tips/ideas for configurations for selective content blocking by device? I'd like to block content on the kids' devices, but not for the adults in the household. I'm not concerned about circumvention at this point. I'm currently using a pi-hole for ad blocking, so I'd like to configure something at that level, unless there's a better way.
- yabones 5y agoPut those devices on a separate subnet would be the easiest way. In order of technical complexity: * Buy a second router, plug it into your existing one, set the DHCP options to point to 1.1.1.2 * Reconfigure your existing router to add a second subnet (192.168.2.0/24 etc) with its own SSID * Use DHCP reservations to push 1.1.1.1 to known devices (adults) and 1.1.1.2 to all others; it could be done the other way, but all iPhones/Macs can randomize MAC addresses making evasion very simple There may be a way to do this inside Pi-Hole, but it would probably be based on IP range rather than MAC address, which is much easier to circumvent.
- nkrisc 5y agoThanks for the ideas, it gives me somewhere to start investigating. I already have several subnets for other reasons, so I might try that route.
- p4bl0 5y agoAre there some DNS services that block ads and trackers (or at least as much ads and trackers as possible) at the DNS level?
- GNOMES 5y agoAny updates from Cloudflare on their replacement for EDNS that they are making with Google/Facebook/Netflix etc? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19828317 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19828317 ``We are working with the small number of networks with a higher network/ISP density than Cloudflare (e.g., Netflix, Facebook, Google/YouTube) to come up with an EDNS IP Subnet alternative that gets them the information they need for geolocation targeting without risking user privacy and security. Those conversations have been productive and are ongoing. If archive.is has suggestions along these lines, we’d be happy to consider them. ``
- cnst 5y agoIt's a problem of their own making that doesn't require a solution. After the client gets the IP address of the content web server from the DNS resolver, the client has to connect directly to the content web server, and the whole IP address — not just the subnet — is immediately shared with the content server anyways. The market is supposed to regulate this abusive behaviour by showing how much slower the websites work when resolved through Cloudflare DNS compared to Google DNS or any other DNS providers that support EDNS Client Subnet. It seems that most of DNS benchmarks simply test how fast the names resolve, not how good of a resolution it is. So, it's a miss on the benchmark side.
- BatteryMountain 5y agoWell one of my domains resolves to some dodgy russian website when using cloudflare's dns. I did everything in my power, including trying to contact them, but it still resolves to the russian host. On any other dns server it resolves correctly to gandi's parking page. Cloudflare did send me an email within 10 seconds to say that no support ticket can/will be logged since I'm not a paying customer (or just customer on their system) and that they case is closed. i get it, but it's still a nasty feeling. And yes I did use their dns flusher, it didn't help. I switched all my networks back to google's dns.
- BatteryMountain 5y agoAnd the reason why it pissed me off was, I thought my mikrotik router or raspberry pi + pihole got compromised. I spent two hours trying to track down the problem, reset all dns setting on gandi, resetting and updating the router etc... just to find that it worked fine on my phone on MNO's network...then I digged further and found if I switch my dns to anything other than 1.1.1.1, it worked fine. So I don't care what features they are flinging at this point, dns being hijacked is no good.
- bennyp101 5y agoThat seems less "sticking to principles" and more "we aren't resolving correctly, but can't/won't tell you why?"
- tinus_hn 5y agoIf you are using dnssec this should be impossible, right?
- dhaavi 5y agoJust tweet at the 1.1.1.1 account, it‘ll resolve for you on Twitter. ;P See https://twitter.com/1111Resolver https://twitter.com/1111Resolver
- runlevel1 5y agoThat's an odd problem. A few possible causes jump to mind: A. Someone is poisoning it between you and Cloudflare, but only for DNS requests directed towards Cloudflare. B. Someone is poisoning it between Cloudflare and Gandi. C. Someone was able to trick Cloudflare into thinking it is the authoritative DNS provider and its authoritative DNS servers are the same ones as its recursive resolvers. D. Something got missed in troubleshooting. (Not trying to be a jerk, it's just always a possibility.) You could probably surface whether it's A or B by playing around with DNSSEC. I'm not certain, but you might be able to figure out if it's C with this: https://rdap.cloudflare.com https://rdap.cloudflare.com
- legrande 5y agoWho bears the brunt of the task of collecting every adult/NSFW domain out there? Doesn't such a list grow by huge numbers each day? What is the name of this list, and where can I get it?
- SamuelAdams 5y agoSearch for block lists, here’s a popular one that is updated regularly. https://raw.githubusercontent.com/StevenBlack/hosts/master/alternates/porn/hosts https://raw.githubusercontent.com/StevenBlack/hosts/master/a...
- legrande 5y agoWow. Incredible list. Thanks for sharing. Noticed some of them weren't NSFW domains, just problematic ad-tech domains, but still very useful.
- tinus_hn 5y agoI’m pretty sure adult sites register themselves for inclusion on this kind of blocklists because they have not a whole lot to gain and a lot to lose when serving their content to children.
- Tommek 5y agoYou know, for educational reasons ... :D
- systemvoltage 5y agoCompletely off topic: These stupid illustrations (corporate memphis) are totally unneccessary. The whole blog post would read cleaner with less distraction.
- chriscjcj 5y agoI experimented with 1.1.1.3 on a small network segment by configuring DHCP to make 1.1.1.3 the default. I found that they resulted in numerous false-positives that turned out to be a real nuisance. As I went around to various machines and either overrode the DHCP settings with another DNS and/or added lines to the hosts file, I decided that just because you _can_ use DNS for content filtering, doesn't mean it's a particularly effective modality. Cloudflare does have a tool that allows you to correct false positives... https://radar.cloudflare.com/categorization-feedback/ https://radar.cloudflare.com/categorization-feedback/ But I found that the corrections I made were ignored with only one exception. The one I successfully corrected took many attempts over several weeks. I ended up throwing in the towel on the whole thing and giving up on Cloudflare DNS altogether. That's not to say that others couldn't find value in it. I just found it to be more trouble than it was worth.
- OJFord 5y ago(2020) - I was pretty confused by the 'Not a Joke' paragraph about 1st April traditions for a bit!
- SadWebDeveloper 5y agoThis is really need awesome kinda like opendns.
- Vixel 5y agoSo, it's not 1.1.1.1, it's actually 1.1.1.2 ? That's confusing. Why not call it 1.1.1.2 for families?
- Giorgi 5y agoFor families? more like for family home network only. Families now own cell phones with mobile data.