3 ms·
Even if I was to buy that there's some theoretical argument that no dollar may be taxed more than once (which I don't), the income isn't the capital gains. It's
by PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago
Even if I was to buy that there's some theoretical argument that no dollar may be taxed more than once (which I don't), the income isn't the capital gains. It's not related in any way to the capital gains. A corporation may have enormous profits, and zero capital gains. It may have enormous capital gains, and zero profits. The capital gain has not been previously taxed.
- WalterBright 5y agoThe value of a corporation is inevitably linked to its profits.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoNot really. Amazon, a company I once knew a bit about, showed gigantic growth in stock value with minimal or zero profit. This is hardly a new story. But it wouldn't matter anyway, given GP's point. Taxes on corporate income are not taxes on the capital gains of those who hold corporate stock.
- WalterBright 5y agoI know about the Amazon case. The stock price was linked to expected future profits. Which will be taxed. The stock price can deviate for a time from the current profits, but it will inevitably move back to what the overall profit is. The reason is simple. The gains in value of a company are when (revenue > expenses), i.e. it comes from profit. > Taxes on corporate income are not taxes on the capital gains of those who hold corporate stock. Yes they are, because they reduce the value of the stock (and hence the capital gains) by the same amount. There's no free lunch.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoThis is a deeply simplistic reading of stock trading. People who buy (or used to buy) "blue chip" stocks in the hope of collecting a nice monthly dividend payout certainly see things the way you're describing. But there are plenty of people who buy stock because they believe the stock price will increase for reasons that may or may not include profits. The idea that "gains in value of a company ... comes from profit" is some sort of glorified 1850-1970s view of how stock prices vary. Once we allowed for derivatives, amongst other things, this sort of simplistic approach to stock trading has become more and more of an anachronism. To use amzn as an example, though they are hardly unique, lots of people bought amzn stock because they belived that other people believed that the stock price would increase. We have entire sub-sectors of stock trading that use high level math and leading edge technology (and or day-trader gut feelings) to try to earn from fluctuations in stock pricing that are best a derivative of profits, but more typically 3rd order effects.
- WalterBright 5y agoOnce again, if the stock price outpaces profits, it is because the investors are expecting FUTURE profits. You appear to believe that this is some anachronism. It is not. The people who believe it is not based on (expected future) profits are in for a rude awakening. If the expected future profits don't materialize, the stock tanks. Why do you think TSLA jumped when Hertz ordered a ton of Teslas? It wasn't based on the value of that deal, it was based on the EXPECTED FUTURE PROFITS from the legitimizing effect on Tesla sales from Hertz' vote of confidence. People expect other rental fleets to now be buying Teslas. And those expected future profits just got priced in to the stock. Of course, they could guess wrong. But the two numbers, stock valuation and profits, will inevitably converge. ANY news that affects future profits is going to affect the stock price. All those mathematical models are just attempts to predict just what the magnitude of those effects will be. Not realizing this is like looking at the thermometer today and drawing a conclusion about climate change.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago> Once again, if the stock price outpaces profits, it is because the investors are expecting FUTURE profits. This is just false. We live in a world where stock trading occurs based on at least 3rd order derivatives. My belief about her belief about his belief can drive me buying or selling stock. I don't have to believe anything about future profits, I only have to believe that you believe that somebody else believes something about future profits. But I don't even have to believe that. I can simply have an expectation that I can surf the volatility of a given stock, without regard for its "underlying causes", and make a profit doing so. You don't actually think all those hedge fund quants do is some fancy computation of expected future profit, do you? > The people who believe it is not based on (expected future) profits are in for a rude awakening. If the expected future profits don't materialize, the stock tanks. The people who are no longer playing the simplistic game are already gone when that happens.
- WalterBright 5y ago> This is just false What do you imagine it is based on? Collector value? The position of Mars in the sky? > I can surf the volatility of a given stock You can make a profit in Vegas with your system, too, but you'll lose in the long run because the math is inevitable. > You don't actually think all those hedge fund quants do is some fancy computation of expected future profit, do you? Hedge fund long term results struggle to match the S&P 500. The owners of the hedge fund, however, do far better than their customers. All those commissions, fees, percentages and loads. I put my money where my mouth is, and it's not in hedge funds. > are already gone when that happens 2008 Oops!