3 ms·
Almost nobody pays the estate tax. >When a person dies, their assets could be subject to estate taxes and inheritance taxes, depending on where they lived and
by PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago
Almost nobody pays the estate tax.
>When a person dies, their assets could be subject to estate taxes and inheritance taxes, depending on where they lived and how much they were worth. While the threat of estate taxes and inheritance taxes does exist, in reality, the vast majority of estates are too small to be charged a federal estate tax—which, as of 2021, applies only if the assets of the deceased person are worth $11.70 million or more
(Investopedia; https://www.investopedia.com/articles/personal-finance/120715/estate-taxes-who-pays-what-and-how-much.asp https://www.investopedia.com/articles/personal-finance/12071...)
- WalterBright 5y ago> applies only if the assets of the deceased person are worth $11.70 million or more And hence they apply to billionaires, which is the topic of this page.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoActually most billionaires manage to reshuffle their assets to that their estate, such as it is, is under the limit by the time they die. The main people hit by it are those holding large amounts of valuable land, and there are very few of them. Almost all mentions of the estate tax in this thread has been generic whining about the fact that there is an estate tax. For almost all US persons, there is no estate tax.
- rsj_hn 5y ago> Actually most billionaires manage to reshuffle their assets I was talking to some people sufficiently wealthy that this is a concern, and their point is that the only reason some don't transfer their assets like this is fear of their own children. Unless you really are a farmer, or small business owner, the estate tax is completely optional if you trust your kids. In 2019, there were only 2,570 estate taxes filed. > Almost all mentions of the estate tax in this thread has been generic whining about the fact that there is an estate tax There is also whining among people that they need to spend so much on accountants and lawyers to avoid what is essentially a completely bypassable tax. So you can see how socially it is not a good use of our human capital to create this enormous tax avoidance industry, and how it would be much better to pass laws that didn't need to do things like value privately held businesses or artwork in order to determine your tax liability.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoIf there are taxes, there's a tax avoidance industry. I mean, c'mon, there's a gigantic tax avoidance industry just for regular income tax. The proposed law under discussion here explicitly excludes privately held businesses and artwork.
- rsj_hn 5y ago> I mean, c'mon, there's a gigantic tax avoidance industry just for regular income tax. Because we have an extremely complex tax code. But seriously, eliminate all corporate taxes and replace that with a 10% VAT. Treat all income the same -- I don't care whether it's a long term capital gain, or a meteor filled with gold crashing into your yard, don't distinguish at all. Put it all into a single bucket, get one number, look that up in a progressive rate table. Pay a percentage. No deductions of any kind for anything. Not for mortgage, not for kids, not for school, not for charity, not for solar panels, etc. But only tax income, not assets. That would eliminate 99% of tax prep work.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoThe correct answer in my opinion has nothing to do with corporate taxation. The US government for some reason(s) (for another day) is almost completely unwilling to simply redistribute money to fund things it decides are worthy goals. Instead it creates tax credits and deductions that are supposed to do the same thing (at least for "the worthy"). We need to stop using tax code to implement policy. Taxes should be taxes, and if the government decides to pay people to encourage them to install solar PV/have children/buy new cars/invest in bitcoin/whatever, then the government should send them a check to do so. So we're mostly in violent agreement, except that if corporations have any of the rights of people (and likewise, if people can somehow claim to be corporations), then I want them taxed just like people.
- rsj_hn 5y agoYeah, I agree on the households. The point about corporate taxes is we have so many loopholes. Historically, nations adopted a VAT because it's great at squashing tax-avoidance, as it encourages snitching. Basically you report you paid someone X, and then they have to pay the VAT instead of you. So it's a very clean and elegant solution to dealing with the problem of corporate accounting and tax avoidance. In terms of treating a corporation the same as a household -- so that it pays taxes on all revenue, the problem is the economic distortions. There are just some businesses - like grocery stores -- that have high turnover and low margins. Other businesses have low turnover and high margins. And the tax code should not really penalize one at the expense of another. E.g. groceries just don't last, they have to be sold quickly. Furniture lasts a while. The reality of that natural difference trumps any appeals to logical symmetry in treating corporations the same as households.