26 ms·
I'm in sympathy with that argument, but I don't think that singularly driven people are motivated by profit alone, and that they'll stop if there's some change
by anigbrowl 5y ago
I'm in sympathy with that argument, but I don't think that singularly driven people are motivated by profit alone, and that they'll stop if there's some change is the underlying property ownership calculus.
Also, it's worth considering that not everything great is good, so perhaps a braking or governance system (in the sense of an engine) is worth requiring on any enterprise sufficiently large to become a juggernaut.
- WalterBright 5y agoIf a committee can reject their initiatives, how are they going to implement them? > it's worth considering that not everything great is good, so perhaps a braking or governance system (in the sense of an engine) is worth requiring on any enterprise sufficiently large to become a juggernaut. Yeah, let's just throw SpaceX in the trash heap. Nevermind that NASA, the organization run by committee, has failed to make space accessible and routine. The "braking system" is already in place. It's the free market. Once the "juggernaut" fails to please the customers, it goes down the tubes.
- bryanlarsen 5y agoSpaceX is already run by committee. The president of SpaceX is Gwynne Shotwell and she is widely believed to regularly reign in Elon Musk. For example Elon wanted to cancel the Falcon Heavy project when NASA said they would never man-rate it, but Shotwell over-ruled him until he changed his mind. Musk controls enough shares that he could get rid of Shotwell at any time, or reduce her power, but he chooses not to.
- WalterBright 5y agoSmart leaders have a nay-sayer to whisper in their ears when they're making a mistake. That doesn't mean they aren't in command, though. The fact that Musk can get rid of her at any time speaks for itself. It doesn't mean she's a committee, either. I've long suspected that the reason McCartney and Lennon wrote great songs for the Beatles, and not-so-great ones afterwards, is because each was willing to tell the other when their work was crap. Afterwards, they just had sycophants who'd tell them every note they wrote was fantastic.