4 ms·
Before the App Store: the carriers took 70% After the App Store: Apple takes 30% But let’s not pretend that most of the App Store revenue comes from poor indi
by scarface74 5y ago
Before the App Store: the carriers took 70%
After the App Store: Apple takes 30%
But let’s not pretend that most of the App Store revenue comes from poor indie developers. It comes from pay to win games, loot boxes, and other in app purchases with zero marginal costs.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- smoldesu 5y agoOh, so it's not that big of a loss since most of the people don't deserve that revenue anyways! So Apple on the other hand is totally entitled to that money?
- scarface74 5y agoI was hoping that Apple Arcade killed all play to win games or at least took a bite out of their revenue. But again, you’re not standing up for the poor starving Indy developer. You’re standing up for companies that are doing far more sinister things going after “whales” than anything Facebook has ever done.
- smoldesu 5y ago> You’re standing up for companies that are doing far more sinister things going after “whales” than anything Facebook has ever done. There are several things wrong with that statement. 1. If these companies engaged in truly destructive business practices (and it could be proven), then Apple has a duty to remove those apps. Every developer has to pay them $99/year to be registered, so that money should be funding the removal of these supposedly exploitative and 'sinister' apps. 2. You cannot prove that the majority of these businesses are all big. 2a. Even if you could prove that, it's common knowledge that Apple is the largest company in the world, which renders that entire argument moot. 3. How do you delineate between indie developers and 'whales'? 3a. When you do differentiate the two, how is it ethical for the largest company in the world to ask for more of their profits? 4. Apple isn't standing up for the poor indie developer either, which is why it's perfectly reasonable to ask them to do better. There is not a company on this planet with more liquid cash than Apple, so there's nothing wrong with asking them to just improve their treatment of developers when consensus is that they're one of the most exploitative and destructive companies in the field of consumer electronics.
- scarface74 5y ago1. I agree. While Apple hasn’t gotten rid of the scammy apps, they have introduced an alternative - Apple Arcade - where they do fund Indy developers so they don’t have to make scammy pay to win games. 2. I said that most app revenue comes from “whales”. Those are the players who spend the most money on play to win games. https://medium.com/shopify-gaming/mobile-gaming-is-a-50b-industry-but-only-5-of-players-are-spending-money-f7f3375dd959 https://medium.com/shopify-gaming/mobile-gaming-is-a-50b-ind... 3. Indy developers are selling a product that has value. The “whales” are the 5% of consumers buying loot boxes and candy crush coins (?). 3a Most of their profits are not from the App Store. Most of their profits come from a simple ethical business model - I give them money they give me stuff. Unlike Google and Facebook or the aforementioned games. 4. Who are all of these poor developers Apple should be standing up for? In the link above (and the numbers were confirmed during the Epic trial), most money is coming from games with in app purchases. If you look at the top selling apps on the App Store now, the last one that I can remember that came from Indy developers is WidgetSmith. How many Indy developers would be successful if Apple took a 15% cut instead of a 30% cut?
- smoldesu 5y ago> Who are all of these poor developers Apple should be standing up for? Well, there's the FlickType guy[0] who got kicked off the app store only to have his product completely cloned by Apple. Then there's the Hey! email people who went to hell-and-back just to get an inoccuous update approved. Not even a year ago there was a class-action lawsuit against Apple by developers[2], and Apple's "compromise" was to charge less for a service that was provably garbage. They know their 30% cut is illigitimate, that's why they backed off so quickly. Even still though, they charge certain people 30%, others only 15%, and then the big companies like Netflix get away with 0%[3] because of insider deals that other apps cannot benefit from. So fixing that would be a good start. Then they need to allow for alternative payment processors (as pressure mounts from countries like South Korea and France), and hopefully get rid of their asinine sideloading requirements that do nothing for the user except make it harder to get the functionality they want. These feel like non-negotiables to me, and as a developer I have no intention of supporting their software or using their hardware until it's fixed. [0] https://www.inputmag.com/tech/apple-blocked-the-flicktype-watch-keyboard-then-announced-a-clone-of-it https://www.inputmag.com/tech/apple-blocked-the-flicktype-wa... [1] https://www.engadget.com/apple-basecamp-hey-email-app-store-154225649.html https://www.engadget.com/apple-basecamp-hey-email-app-store-... [2] https://www.axios.com/apple-settles-developer-class-action-c13bb308-daf3-4231-a399-ffd48b6b2c52.html https://www.axios.com/apple-settles-developer-class-action-c... [3] https://twitter.com/TechEmails/status/1444367219509637123 https://twitter.com/TechEmails/status/1444367219509637123