3 ms·
> again the overriding belief that the lowest common denominator is the only function worth serving. again refusing the challenge of doing better outright, & op
by bawolff 5y ago
> again the overriding belief that the lowest common denominator is the only function worth serving. again refusing the challenge of doing better outright, & opting into only believing in worse. you've started off by excluding all use cases except the worst one.
I feel that you are mis-stating my position.
> this is a stunning conclusion which i am still working to recover from
Ffs, melodramatic much?
> here's google's docs for how to implement semantic web today. i'm pretty sure most of the lower quartile of developers i've worked with (still not a terrible lot) could get something ok going on an existing project in half a day, based on this.
To be clear, i think most could do even the original rdf if they so desired. My argument is not that they are literally incapable, but that their interests are not aligned with doing so (replace incompetent with lazy if it makes you feel better)
> we sacrifice nothing by working for better. we can make our information better, easily, at little cost to us & none to the lower users, & we can over time find & create a wide range of tools that dont just search, but which generally improve the user experience, in a range of ways. when pages take the step of marking up their contents in machine readable ways, we enable more possibilities, more diversification, more possible flourishing.
We sacrafice opportunity cost. Time spent working on things with unsolved problems and no plan for conceievably solving them is time that can be better spent on solutions that are actually practical (or could be spent on solving those unsolved problems). But by all means anyone who thinks they can make it work, should go make cool things.
I'm not saying that people shouldn't work on semantic web - just that if they do, they should work on solving norvig's complaints or try to make them inapplicable to the specific niche they are working on.
> again i think there's some very abstract words
I don't understand how you are using abstract in this sentence or how my previous comment was abstract.
> picking up the crudest typecast of bad operators one can reach for, & using that to browbeat those who want to try better, more advanced, is what i described as a low bog
Then you should make the argument that the few are sufficient. There's plenty of technologies where you don't need everyone on board. Semantic web as originally envisioned seems like one where you do. If you disagree that you do, this is a good place to attack peter's argument.
> whatever truth there are to peter's views, the world ought try to be better. a better hypermedia is more likely to, in the long run, breed better hypermediaists.
I agree, but we should work on things that are practical given the constraints we have or figure out ways to remove those constraints. Running head first into a known wall, pretending it isn't there, doesn't solve anything.
To give an example - take gnutella vs bittorrent. Gnutella had a problem that many participants were selfish peers (downloaded but didn't upload). If we just said that selfish peers were "bad operators" and we should ignore them in favour of the people who are good, we would be stuck with gnutella. Instead, bit torrent came along, recognized the issue, created the tit-for-tat algorithm, which changed the social dynamics, overcoming the problem.
> ok so this time you're willing to possibly entertain my notion- not assuming everyone is incompetent & goning to be unable to manage it-
That's not my notion. My notion is that people do what is in their personal best interest, and a significant (but not universal) portion have interests that differ from what would be good for a hypothetical semantic web.
In my view, in order for semantic we to suceed you need to either shift the social dynamics so that more operators interests align with what is good for the semantic web, or you need to make the semantic web more robust to misaligned interests. Preferably both.
> activitypub is showing the value of extensible, interlinked structured data, is a hotbed of neat social systems & apps & decentralizations. the js libraries have only recently got good, got modern, but they have; that's a subtle but promising sign to me, a form of success.
I think this is an interesting example, because it modifies the vision of the semantic web just enough to address norvig's points.
Its an isolated system - you don't need the world to use it, just the people you want to follow.
Incompetence is again fixed by only having people who want to participate participate. Additionally most participants use something like mastadon, so dont have to implement it themselves.
Similiarly, there are tools to deal with spam, as well as procedures like requiring invites or admin approval to join.
If anything, i think this is tge exception that proves the validity of norvig's argument. The semantic web doesn't work due to norvig's reasons. Modify the idea slightly to address those reasons, and suddenly it works great.
> but mostly disbelief & scorn has carried the day against the semantic web, kept it from accruing even the slow-burning background interest i think it deserves
When has disbelief & scorn ever actually kept a good technology down? Scorn tends to go away the moment the tech does something valuable to someone (for exame, take drop box).
-------
To conclude, i think you're defining the semantic web differently than how Norvig is.
Could something related to but not quite the same as the original vision of the semantic web take off? sure definitely. Your example of activitypub is a good one in my mind.
Could the original vision of the semantic web take off - i don't think so unless it fixes its incentive problem.
Of course if someone creates it and it works, i would be happy to be proven wrong.
- rektide 5y ago> To conclude, i think you're defining the semantic web differently than how Norvig is hahah. now why, why on earth would i use someone who clearly didnt/doesnt-get-it's limited conception? > feel that you are mis-stating my position. i dont feel like im being genuinely dealt with either. i felt like most of your points are fairly orthogonal interjections & i have been trying to return more to the article & my comments on them. the topic feels on going mis-stated to me & i am clarifying what we're actually discussing at the root, as i see it. > Ffs, melodramatic much? your words have felt dangerously misleading to me in a couple core places, forcing worse-is-better framings onto the scene repeatedly, & i do not think i am being melodramatic; what you are seeing is genuine alarm. i think i am being appropriately based. i do feel very strongly about this all, i feel like it is far to soon to be making conclusions & closing ourselves off to possibility. but i see fait accomplis written all over the outlooks i have given & it feels radically confining to me & very uncomfortable. im sorry i dont have a more clear promising inspiring case to rest my assertion on, that the old & new & ongoing reverberations of semantic web are mostly alike, represent an ongoing continual & vital thread of information. it's a long long voyage & it feels premature. i recommemd again to everyone my original points vis a vie whether Norvig has insight or not. if you are Google, maybe listen. everyone else, these three points Peter has made: my read is still that he never had a clue and/or was actively sabotaging a better web.
- bawolff 5y ago> hahah. now why, why on earth would i use someone who clearly didnt/doesnt-get-it's limited conception? Because we're discussing his argument. Traditionally its assumed when you discuss the validity of someone else's argument you take on their definitions for the purpose of discussing the argument (or argue something like: their argument is irrelavent because they define terms differently so it doesn't apply in the situation i care about). If your position is: "norvig is wrong when you take his words out of context to make them mean something different than what he meant" - all i can say is, yes obviously. Literally no-one disputes that. > your words have felt dangerously misleading to me in a couple core places, forcing worse-is-better framings onto the scene repeatedly If you mean my premise that not all people in the world (or to be less hyperbolic, a significant portion) have their incentives aligned with the semantic web, i would say: A) that's not what the term worse is better means in computers B) a core premise to an argument is not the same thing as framing. C) i'm not sure how you can say its misleading. I'm making a claim about the world. The generalized version (that getting humans to all agree on something is like hearding cats) is a fairly popular view point. Like all descriptive claims about the world, it could be true or it could be false. You haven't really provided any evidence or argument that its false. I don't understand what you think is misleading about it unless you think everyone who disagrees with you is being misleading. Edit: after rereading your post, and in an attempt to be fully fair - you might be referring to the premise that semantic networks need wide adoption before having value. I would still say that that's a premise not a framing. I only support the premise in the context that norvig was talking about originally - some sort of open membership highly distributed knowledge base useful for general search (what i would call the w3c semantic web "vision"). If you talk about semantic networks more generally, than this premise sometimes falls down, which seems to be where you're going with this argument. However i suspect that Norvig would also agree that semantic networks can potentially suceed in different contexts than the specific one he was talking about. I think most people agree with that statement. > but i see fait accomplis written all over the outlooks i have given & it feels radically confining to me & very uncomfortable. I don't know what to tell you. The world is an uncomfortable place and sometimes it sucks. Wishing for something doesn't make it so. The world is changed by people who recognize problems and figure out how to fix them or work around them. You clearly care about the semangic web - that person could be you! Those who simply ignore the inconvinent don't usually accomplish much. > what you are seeing is genuine alarm. With all due respect, if this relatively polite disagreement causes genuine alarm, i would strongly suggest avoiding twitter. > my read is still that he never had a clue and/or was actively sabotaging a better web. In some ways this is the most damning statement about the semantic web of all - if all it takes to kill a technology is for a google exec to be somewhat dismissive of it 20 years ago, then its clearly a pretty weak technology. Hell, google even provided a bunch of the initial funding for wikidata which is arguably one of the few success stories of semantic technologies. Which is not to say its isn't beautiful. I totally understand why people are enamoured with it. The idea is a wonderful dream; the pretty parts are very pretty. Alas a technology isn't only defined by the beautiful parts.