5 ms·
You might also consider adding a web bug image to your confirmation email. If the user loads the confirmation email's HTML, you know it is a real email address
by cpeterso 15y ago
You might also consider adding a web bug image to your confirmation email. If the user loads the confirmation email's HTML, you know it is a real email address even if they don't click the confirmation link.
Admittedly, it might be someone ELSE'S email address, but they could manually unsubscribe from your mailing list later.
- moonlighter 15y agoUsing image links 'calling back home' isn't reliable, because email clients have options to prevent such images from being shown automatically, especially if those emails might be considered spam.
- philfreo 15y agoConsidering Outlook and Gmail block them by default, it's extremely unreliable
- robryan 15y agoIn this case though, it shouldn't hard confirmations, a possibly increase them a little. Unless people choose not to confim because they get a "images have been blocked" message.
- mkopinsky 15y agoIt will also give better data - you can see of the people who opened the email and displayed images, what percent actually clicked the link.
- nupark2 15y agoAdmittedly, it might be someone ELSE'S email address, but they could manually unsubscribe from your mailing list later. That's half the point of verifying e-mail addresses. Doing this is likely to engender significant ill-will in anyone who is an unintended recipient of your e-mails.
- blakeperdue 15y agoI have a different view. I hate having to confirm my email address when I signup for a mailing list. It's more annoying to confirm my email address 50 times, versus the 1 time I have to unsubscribe from a list that someone signed me up for by accidentally entering my email address.
- latitude 15y agoI am actually considering not sending a confirmation email. Every maillist message already includes an immediate unsubscribe list, and I thought perhaps to add a small note at the bottom of subscriber's first email, something like --- You are receiving this email because someone (presumably you) subscribed $(email) to the $(maillist-name). Subscription request was received from a network address of $(ip) on $(date). If you did not request this subscription, or would like to be removed from the maillist for another reason, visit this link to unsubscribe - $(link). A bit of a mouthful, but essentially this simply piggy-backs the confirmation request on an actual mailing list message. Thoughts?
- dennisgorelik 15y agoIt's better to use double-opt-in: 1) Enter email on web page. 2) Open confirmation link in email inbox. If you skip second step - there is a risk that email ends up in spam folder and is constantly delivered there. Another risk - user did not really request your subscription. That would often result in your emails being marked as spam.
- latitude 15y agoYeah, I guess the biggest issue is someone plugging in john@acmecorp.com just to test the subscription form, and then actual John getting a maillist message and tagging it as a spam. The question here is if the same John would or would not tag a plain confirmation message as spam too, and I suspect that he would, in which case what I wrote above is no worse than a double-opt-in in edge cases.
- moeffju 15y agoFor one, I don't know of any client that still loads remote images without confirmation, much less 1x1 tracking images. Secondly, if I can sign someone else up without their knowledge and get you to send then unsolicited mail, you're risking legal problems.